Key takeaways
- Fifty bags of binder represent over a tonne handled by physical strength.
- The OTConst requires work to be planned in order to reduce impairments to physical health.
- The silo connected to the mixer completely eliminates the manual carrying of screed powders.
- The all-terrain pallet truck and crane ensure uninterrupted supply to mixing stations.
Calculate the cumulative load to demonstrate the real cost of manual carrying
On a traditional screed or site-mixed fluid screed construction site, the logistical reflex often consists of ordering pallets of binder bags or pre-packaged dry mortar. Each bag weighs between 25 kg and 40 kg. When a screed layer single-handedly supplies the mixer or mixing pump, they lift, pivot and set down each unit at tub height. Over an area of 120 m² poured at a thickness of 60 mm with a mortar dosed at 300 kg per cubic metre, the mass of dry mortar exceeds two tonnes. If this mortar is prepared entirely from pre-dosed 25 kg bags, the worker handles exactly ninety-six units during their shift.
This volume of manual carrying does not merely constitute temporary fatigue: it represents a direct invisible cost for the company. By lifting fifty bags per day, a worker moves a tonne and a quarter. Multiplied by a weekly cadence of five days, the load reaches over six tonnes per man. Musculoskeletal disorders of the back, knees and shoulders lead to drops in output from midday onwards, not to mention absences for acute lower back pain. The construction work ordinance explicitly prescribes that the employer must plan execution stages in order to minimise the risks of occupational disease and bodily injury. Presenting this calculation to company management makes it possible to contrast the hourly cost of human downtime with the amortisation of handling equipment.
| Delivery method | Unit mass | Number of handlings | Cumulative load carried | Back exposure |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Standard bags on the ground | 25 kg | 65 handlings | 1,625 kg | Critical (repeated bending and twisting) |
| Big bags with spreader bar | 1,000 kg | 2 slingings | 0 kg carried by hand | None (mechanical guidance) |
| Gravity or pressure silo | Bulk | 0 powder handlings | 0 kg carried by hand | None (continuous automated supply) |
From motorised pallet truck to mobile silo: making the supply chain reliable
To eliminate or reduce manual carrying without disrupting construction site planning, the company must adapt its tools to the volume of the contract. When site layout or reduced quantities require bagging, the basic rule is to eliminate pedestrian carrying. The pallet must never remain at the edge of the plot. Horizontal transport to the mixer must be carried out using an all-terrain forklift, a site dumper or a high-lift pallet truck adapted to unpaved ground. This pallet truck keeps the pallet at waist height, which prevents the worker from bending down to the ground to grab each bag.
- Hydraulic high-lift pallet truck: brings the pallet 80 cm off the ground to load the tub without lumbar twisting.
- Inclined conveyor belt: transports bags from the storage area to the elevated hopper of the mixing pump.
- Lifting jib for big bag: unloads powder directly into a continuous mixer without human effort.
- Mobile construction site silo: connected by a screw conveyor or sealed pneumatic transfer to the mixer.
As soon as the screed volume exceeds twenty to thirty cubic metres on the same phase, installing a mobile binder or dry mortar silo becomes the standard solution compliant with the requirements of the construction work ordinance. The silo eliminates pallet unloading, weather-exposed storage and the release of cement dust into the breathing zone. However, it requires rigorous upstream organisation: the foundation slab must support the total loaded weight (often twenty to thirty tonnes), access for the delivery truck must be secured, and water and adequate power supply connections must be checked prior to installation.
The rental and transport cost of a mobile silo, ranging from a few hundred to over a thousand Swiss francs depending on the duration and volume delivered, is largely offset by the regularity of automatic dosing and the complete absence of MSDs at the mixing station. For comparative analysis of expenditure items on tenders, consult the section dedicated to cost estimates.
Positioning the screed silo and connecting the continuous mixer
Moving from bags to dry mortar delivered in a mobile silo transforms the screed layer's logistical organisation. Instead of unloading pallets, splitting packaging with a trowel and breathing in binder dust above an open tub, the team has a closed flow. Bulk supply guarantees perfect mixing consistency for calcium sulphate-based or cement-based fluid screeds, while eliminating the bagging effort. However, this installation requires strict coordination with site management from the preparatory phase onwards.
- Installation platform: stabilised, compacted ground or concrete slab capable of supporting a total mass of up to 35 tonnes when fully loaded, with sufficient vertical clearance for the rotation of the delivery truck's arms.
- Water supply: connection of a minimum diameter of one inch with a constant dynamic pressure of 2.5 to 3 bar, essential for supplying the continuous mixer without the risk of premature setting in the mixing column.
- Electrical supply: connection to a protected construction site distribution board, generally using a 32 A or 63 A CEE socket depending on the combined power of the silo foot mixer and the transport compressor.
- Pipe routing: direct path to the screed pump or routing of injection hoses to upper floors while avoiding sharp bends and crushing by other trades.
| Construction site parameter | Manual bag mixing (50 bags) | Dry mortar in mobile silo |
|---|---|---|
| Gross mass handled | 1,250 kg lifted and poured by arm strength | 0 kg (pneumatic transfer or gravity) |
| Mixing labour | 1 worker dedicated permanently to the hopper | Automated supply controlled at the lance |
| Average pumping output | 3 to 5 m³ per hour depending on physical pace | 8 to 15 m³ per hour in uninterrupted flow |
| Site waste management | 50 soiled paper bags, residual dust | Zero packaging waste, clean construction site |
When topographical configuration or screed surface area does not justify deploying a heavy silo, using a mobile mixing station supplied by big bags constitutes the recommended intermediate tier. This process eliminates unit carrying while maintaining great flexibility of access to narrow construction sites or paved courtyards.
Floor-level mechanical aids and residual handling of bagged binders
Self-levelling floor smoothing compounds, moisture barrier membranes and resin mortars for waterproof coves remain packaged in bags or drums. For these one-off substrate preparation works, the construction work ordinance obliges the employer to plan execution in order to minimise health impairments. Lifting a 25 kg bag from the ground to a twin-paddle mixer tub repeatedly dozens of times per day causes debilitating spinal injuries. Mechanical assistance must intervene as soon as the load break occurs.
For horizontal distribution across residential or office building levels, the installation team must have specific rolling equipment: short pallet trucks with polyurethane steering wheels to cross raised access floors or platform trucks with reinforced axles. Setting up rolling mixing stations equipped with a mechanical drum tipper makes it possible to pour the levelling compound directly onto the floor without lifting the liquid mixture, the mass of which regularly exceeds 40 kg once the mixing water is added.
The management of physical effort is not negotiated solely between the foreman and workers: it is calculated and integrated into the justification report addressed to site management. The extra cost of an electric facade hoist, an inclined material lift or a compact elevator is largely offset by the rotation speed of batches, the absence of sick leave for lower back pain and strict compliance with the installation schedule for subsequent coverings.
Logistical blockage, transfer breakdown and pacing arbitration
On a screed construction site, a breakdown in mechanized supply immediately forces the team back to emergency manual carrying. When a silo extraction screw jams on a lump of wet mortar or the facade hoist breaks down, the usual reflex is to unload complete pallets on the shoulder to maintain the mixer's pace. This behavior turns an ordinary mechanical breakdown into a physical disaster for installers and exposes the company to prolonged sick leave for acute lower back pain.
As soon as the mechanical means stops unexpectedly, the site manager interrupts mixing rather than forcing workers to carry fifty 25 kg binder bags in a chain gang. The operating calculation must be applied without delay: mobilising three workers to manually carry twelve hundred and fifty kilograms of admixtures or fast mortar costs more unproductive hours and muscular fatigue than bringing out the silo plant repair technician or renting a light vehicle-mounted furniture lift.
If bagging remains unavoidable to finish a technical room or threshold joint, the team breaks down the task by imposing intermediate rolling platforms, narrow-tub barrows and two-person grips for each heavy package. If back pain is reported by a screed layer during handling, work is stopped immediately. The foreman records the event in the daily report, submits the accident report without delay and requests in writing from the client a revision of the intervention schedule due to a lack of shared lifting facilities.
Frequently asked questions
How to financially justify installing a silo to management?
The calculation contrasts the silo rental with the loss of labour hours. Handling fifty bags of screed represents over a tonne moved on the back, mobilising a worker for unloading and opening bags for two hours. Mortar mixed in the silo feeds the pump directly without intermediate handling. The savings in unproductive hours and the elimination of lower back pain risk offset the transport cost of the container from eighty square metres poured onwards.
What cumulative daily load makes it mandatory to stop carrying bags?
SUVA guidelines on manual load handling establish a critical limit of six to ten cumulative tonnes per day per worker under ideal postural conditions. For the screed layer carrying twenty-five-kilogram bags on unsecured stairs or technical flooring, the musculoskeletal risk becomes critical from two tonnes per shift. Mechanised supply becomes mandatory as soon as this threshold is predictable.
What should be done if the construction site crane refuses to supply binder pallets to upper floors?
The construction manager reports the refusal in writing to site management, citing the construction work ordinance. According to the contractual site planning, access to shared lifting devices must be guaranteed to transport entire pallets onto load-bearing floors. If access is blocked, the screed work is postponed to prevent installers from hoisting bags by human strength through stairwells.
Which light mechanical aids should be preferred when the silo truck cannot access the building?
In narrow streets or under inaccessible archways, the alternative relies on an all-terrain electric pallet truck unloading pallets near the entrance, coupled with a motorised tracked transporter or a towed pump-mixer. If mortar must be prepared in bags, adding a pneumatic bag lifter to the mixing chassis spares the screeders' spines by bearing the vertical effort during repeated feeding of the tub.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 251Screeds in construction: material specifications, execution and installation requirements
- OTConstOrdinance on the Safety and Health Protection of Workers in Construction Work: Workstation Planning and Load Handling
- LTrEmployment Act: Health protection and measures for the prevention of bodily integrity
