Key takeaways
- The absence of movement joints causes the tiling to buckle during thermal expansion.
- The technical diagnosis requires precise thermal mapping before any mechanical cutting in the screed.
- Curative sawing restores free movement without cutting into the embedded underfloor heating pipes.
- Unavailability compensation depends on the respective fault between the screed layer, the tiler, and the site management.
Identify the lack of movement joints and the mechanisms behind lifting
Dome lifting or the sudden bursting of large-format tiles on an active underfloor heating system is a classic defect in French-speaking Switzerland. This phenomenon frequently occurs in the middle of winter, when the heating system flow temperature reaches its maximum operating level. The screed, typically cement- or anhydrite-based, undergoes thermal expansion proportional to its linear expansion coefficient and temperature rise. Lacking decompression spaces, compressive stress builds up in the floor until it exceeds the adhesive bond strength of the tile mortar or the mechanical strength of the ceramic edges, causing an explosive failure.
Movement and expansion joints must be planned from the design stage and respected in the screed as well as in the hard floor covering to allow movements without excessive constraints.
norme SIA 251
| Screed type | Maximum jointless surface area (SIA 251 standard) | Observed thermal behavior | Typical failure mode |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calcium sulphate fluid screed | Up to 200 m² (max length/width ratio 2:1) | Low initial shrinkage, continuous linear expansion when heated | Horizontal shear at the adhesive-screed interface |
| Traditional cement screed | 40 m² or 8 m maximum length | Significant hydraulic shrinkage combined with thermal cycles | Tenting in the centre of the room with edge bursting |
On-site diagnosis begins with a thorough examination of execution plans and the heating activation protocol established by the screed layer. The failure to transfer joints planned by the designer or the total omission of the setting-out plan is the root cause. On site, the investigator sounds the area with a acoustic mallet: a hollow sound systematically precedes the line of failure. They then check the edges of the room. If the perimeter insulation strip has been trimmed too low or bridged by the tiler's grouting mortar, the screed abuts against the masonry, removing any degree of freedom.
Conducting remedial sawing and managing downtime costs
Stabilising the damaged area requires the immediate creation of a movement joint a posteriori. This technical intervention presents a major risk: piercing the hot water pipes embedded in the floating screed. The company cannot carry out any blind cutting without accurately mapping the hydraulic network.
- Thermal mapping of the heating networkCool the floor completely, then restart a rapid temperature rise under the heating engineer's supervision. Locate the layout of the heating coils using a high-resolution thermal camera to trace the routing zones on the floor.
- Selective removal of damaged tilesClear the lifted strips using a light rotary hammer fitted with a flat chisel without damaging the screed body, while vacuuming up ceramic fragments and residual adhesive.
- Controlled mechanical sawing of the screedSet the depth of the diamond wall chaser equipped with a micrometric stop and connected to an industrial vacuum cleaner, to a maximum of one-third of the screed thickness, strictly between two pipe turns.
- Installation of the expansion profile and smoothingInstall a deformable profile suited to traffic and thermal loads, before handing the file over to the tiler for laying the new floor covering.
The neutralization of premises during the appraisal and sawing phase generates financial claims made by the client, such as commercial operating losses or the rehousing of occupants. In Swiss construction law, these costs fall under consequential damage caused by defects governed by the rules of the Code of Obligations service contract. The allocation of the final burden depends on the sharing of fault. If the screed layer failed to request a joint plan before pouring or refrained from notifying site management of a continuous surface exceeding the limits of the SIA 251 standard, their liability is engaged. However, the tiler is also liable for the defect if they laid their covering bridging a non-existent joint or bridged the perimeter without issuing a written notice to site management.
The unavailability compensation must be calculated based on the proven actual loss, supported by strict documentary evidence. For the overall estimation of remediation costs and screed repairs, the reader should refer to the specialized sections on the /soumissions/ website.
Curative sawing and recreation of movement joints on heated screeds
On the damaged construction site, the tiles removed in full strips reveal a continuous cement screed of over sixty square metres, lacking any intermediate joints. Thermal expansion hindered by the absence of decompression space generated destructive shear in the adhesive, lifting the tiles like a roof ridge under the effect of the temperature gradient. The SIA 251 standard prescribes methodical cutting of heated surfaces to absorb these reversible deformations. Total demolition of the work is not required: curative repair by mechanical sawing allows an expansion joint to be created a posteriori in the hardened mortar, ensuring the complete preservation of the embedded heating coils.
The operation requires millimeter precision to avoid rupturing the synthetic heating tubes. The setting-out of the new joint complies with the criteria of the SIA 251 standard: systematic joint creation at doorways, cutting of L- or T-shaped recesses, and compliance with a maximum length-to-width ratio of two to one. The heating network is put back into circulation at low temperature to bring the heat transfer fluid to approximately thirty-five degrees. The operator uses an infrared thermal camera to visualize the circuits through the stripped mortar and mark the axis of the tubes. If the screed thickness varies, high-frequency georadar completes the diagnosis to measure the concrete cover with a tolerance of less than ten millimetres.
| Diagnostic method | Observed precision | On-site constraints | Risk to the heating coil |
|---|---|---|---|
| Active infrared thermography | +/- 15 mm in plan | Heating in service at 35 °C and stripped floor | Low if thermal contrast is stable |
| High-frequency georadar | +/- 5 mm in depth | Clean and perfectly dry surface | Nil: three-dimensional visualization of the pipes |
| Exploratory manual chipping | Approximate | Slow and dusty progression | Critical: direct impact from percussion tools |
The cut line is opened using a rail-mounted circular saw fitted with a dust extraction housing connected to a class M industrial vacuum cleaner, in accordance with the requirements of the Ordinance on Construction Work regarding air purity. The depth stop is set with a minimum safety margin of fifteen millimetres above the identified pipes. In areas free of pipes, the cut goes through the entire thickness of the screed to reach the underlying thermal insulation. The lips of the saw cut are brushed, dusted, and coated with a suitable primer. A cylindrical polyethylene joint backing prevents three-sided adhesion before injecting a heat-resistant elastomeric sealant.
Thermal stabilization protocol and downtime compensation
The sudden lifting of a tiled floor immediately renders the room unfit for its intended use. Whether it is a retail area, offices, or rental housing, the interruption of use generates tangible financial harm. The Code of Obligations and the SIA 118 standard govern the compensation for consequential damage caused by defects in the work. Unavailability compensation is not based on a simple flat-rate claim: it requires a file of accounting evidence validated by a fiduciary, including net commercial operating loss, suspended contractual rents, storage costs for evacuated furniture, and temporary accommodation for occupants during curative work.
After elastic sealing of the sawn joint, thermal recovery must be carried out methodically before the tiler re-intervenes. An abrupt temperature rise would ruin the adhesion of the sealant and crack the perimeter of the repair mortar. The installation is reactivated in increments of five degrees per day up to the maximum level, maintained for seventy-two hours to relieve stresses, then cooled down gradually. This test thermal protocol is the subject of a report countersigned by site management. Once the substrate is stabilized and its residual moisture checked, the CFC 282 tiler can lay the new elements, scrupulously replicating the flexible joint directly above the saw cut.
Dispute management, technical arbitration, and compensation for premises
When tiles crack and tent under thermal stress, the crisis situation blocks the operation of the building. The first measure requires organizing a formal joint inspection record bringing together site management, the screed company, and the tiler. A meticulous examination allows the constructed work to be compared against the requirements of the SIA 251 standard. The screed layer must then establish whether they complied with the provided movement joint plans or if the design neglected maximum permissible surfaces.
- Securing and destructive diagnosisThe damaged area is cordoned off without delay to prevent injuries caused by sharp edges of broken tiles. Targeted chiselling along a failure line makes it possible to check the thickness of the screed, the adhesion of the setting mortar, and the complete absence of resilient separation.
- Thermal location of heating coilsBefore any curative cutting, the heating engineer operates the network to allow the technician to map the pipes with a thermal camera. This rigorous detection rules out any risk of damaging pressurized hydraulic networks during cutting.
- Settlement agreement and expert arbitrationIn the absence of a direct agreement, the parties appoint a professional expert to analyze the chain of responsibilities between screed installation, compliance with drying time, and grouting, in accordance with the rules of the Code of Obligations (CO).
When amicable agreement is delayed, site management initiates the formal notice procedures provided for by the SIA 118 standard in order to commission a third-party company at the expense and risk of the defaulting parties. To preserve their rights, the screed layer submits technical reservations in writing if the initial jointing was not planned in the quote or if the tiler bridged a shrinkage joint without decoupling. Finally, remediation must incorporate a new heating cycle before re-gluing to purge residual tensions.
Frequently asked questions
Who bears the unavailability compensation for a closed business during screed sawing?
The repair of financial damage depends on the sharing of liability established by the technical expertise. If the absence of joints results from a failure to follow the plans prescribed by the SIA 251 standard, the screed layer is liable. If the engineer's plan omitted the jointing or if the tiler blocked perimeter movement, the burden is shared. The corporate civil liability insurance then intervenes to cover the proven operating loss during the work.
At what depth should the screed be sawn without risking piercing the heating coils?
The cutting depth of a curative movement joint generally reaches the upper third of the screed thickness. To avoid devastating water damage, the intervention requires precise preliminary localization of the coils using a thermal camera during heating. A diamond disc saw equipped with an adjustable micrometric stop is mandatory. The screed layer must maintain a safety margin of at least fifteen millimetres above the upper generator of the heating pipes.
Can cracked tiles simply be re-glued after sawing a joint in the screed?
No, sustainable repair requires treating the entire interface. After curative sawing of the screed mortar according to the SIA 251 standard, the created joint must be replicated exactly in the setting bed and in the tiling. Hollow adjacent tiles must be removed one metre on either side of the fracture, adhesive residues eliminated, a profile or flexible elastomeric sealant installed, and a thermal stabilization cycle performed.
How to prove that the initial heating activation is not the cause of the floor cracking?
The production of the heating activation protocol constitutes the core document of the file. Signed by the heating engineer and endorsed by site management, this document records the gradual increase in flow temperature, the maximum plateau, and controlled cooling. If this cycle complies with the screed manufacturer's instructions and recognized rules, the defect results directly from hindered expansion due to the absence of joints, and not from thermal shock.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 251Floating screeds, installation rules, and movement jointing of heated surfaces
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, defect management, and formal notice
