Key takeaways
- Compressibility determines the residual thickness of the insulation beneath the fluid or traditional screed.
- Excessive settlement destroys dynamic elasticity and degrades impact sound insulation.
- Storing pallets of bags or tiles creates permanent and irreversible settlement.
- The installation of distribution platforms is mandatory for any traffic prior to pouring.
Compressibility, thickness under load and compliance with acoustic requirements
The floating screed, together with the load-bearing floor, forms a mass-spring-mass system designed to attenuate impact sound transmitted to the floor below. The spring function is provided by the resilient underlay. Its performance depends directly on its dynamic stiffness and its ability to maintain its integrity under the self-weight of the screed and the operational loads planned for the project.
- Compressibility c (SIA 251 standard)
- The measured difference between the nominal thickness of the insulation without bearing load (d_L) and its stabilised thickness under a standardised test load (d_B). This value quantifies the predictable crushing of the material under the finished structure.
The SIA 251 standard specifies the use of underlays whose compressibility remains compatible with the nature of the mortar and the use of the rooms. For cement screeds or calcium sulphate-based fluid screeds in residential buildings, the maximum permissible compressibility is strictly regulated to prevent differential edge deflection and the opening of shrinkage cracks. The thickness under load also determines the finished reference level for door thresholds and technical connections.
| Resilient material type | Typical compressibility | Behaviour under permanent load | Main acoustic risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Floor mineral wool | Medium (2 to 5 mm) | Controlled progressive settlement according to load class | Loss of elasticity in case of excessive local crushing |
| Elasticised expanded polystyrene (EPS-T) | Low to medium (1 to 3 mm) | Excellent shape memory under distributed loads | Sensitivity to heavy point indentation |
| Thin cross-linked polyolefin foams | Very low (less than 1 mm) | Minimal deformation under static load | Immediate degradation by roller shear |
When the insulation is crushed beyond calculation tolerances, its dynamic stiffness increases sharply. The spring system becomes rigid, which cancels out the expected acoustic gain. The in situ result no longer complies with the requirements of the SIA 181 standard regarding sound protection in buildings. Lateral and direct transmissions of footfall noise then increase measurably during acoustic acceptance testing.
Mechanical protection before pouring and management of construction site loads
On the construction site, the acoustic underlay laid on the raw slab remains particularly vulnerable until the screed is executed. The most destructive error is tolerating the temporary storage of heavy materials by other trades. A single pallet of masonry elements, binder bags or tiles placed directly on acoustic insulation generates a point pressure that largely exceeds the permissible resistance of the product.
To preserve the integrity of the underlay and guarantee the requirements of the SIA 251 standard, the team leader must establish strict access discipline right from the start of unrolling the insulation. No third-party intervention must be authorised without specific protection measures.
- Mark out and rope off the installation zone to prohibit any storage of pallets, heavy trestles or rolling scaffolding.
- Systematically lay running paths using OSB panels or thick planks to distribute the pressure of wheelbarrows or repeated traffic.
- Check the perfect continuity of the protective polyethylene film to prevent cement laitance from infiltrating the joints of the crushed insulation.
- Formally refuse the pouring and notify site management if a zone compressed by wild storage is discovered during the prior inspection.
If crushing is observed prior to pouring work, the deformed material must be cut out and replaced over the entire damaged area. Carefully splice the replacement pieces while respecting the tightness of the strips to maintain the homogeneity of the acoustic insulation complex.
Compressibility diagnosis and repair of damaged insulation
On a building site, the wild storage of pallets of cement, plasterboards or masonry trestles on a freshly laid acoustic underlay causes a point stress well above the permissible operational load. Resilient insulations intended for impact sound insulation operate on the mass-spring-mass principle: their efficiency relies on calibrated compressibility and an elastic ability to return to their initial geometry after loading. When a pallet weighing one tonne rests on a few dozen square centimetres of underlay via its wooden blocks, the elastic limit of the material is shattered. The mineral fibres collapse, the polyethylene foam cells burst or fuse, and the elasticised expanded polystyrene loses its damping structure. The nominal thickness under load, although defined by the SIA 251 standard to guarantee dynamic damping, is no longer ensured. The residual thickness remains fixed at a fraction of the calculation value, creating a rigid zone incapable of damping structure-borne vibrations.
- Topographical survey of crushingCheck the altimetry of the insulation with a two-metre straightedge and a vernier calliper as soon as unauthorised heavy stock is cleared. Any residual plastic deformation exceeding the thickness-under-load tolerance defined by the manufacturer requires intervention.
- Clean cut of the ruined zoneNeatly open the sealing film with a straight-bladed utility knife, then cut out the degraded underlay along a regular rectangular perimeter, extending at least ten centimetres beyond the visible crushing footprint.
- Vacuuming the substrateClear away dust, rubble and delaminated insulation fragments resting on the structural concrete to guarantee a perfectly flat seating for the replacement piece.
- Insertion of a new adjustment pieceCut a new panel of the exact same nature, compressibility class and nominal thickness. Fit it to the nearest millimetre with tight joints, without creating any extra thickness or peripheral play.
- Reconstitution of surface sealingLay a sealed protective sheet overlapping the existing film by fifteen centimetres, then completely seal the perimeter using waterproof reinforced adhesive tape to prevent any mortar laitance infiltration.
| Nature of the acoustic insulation | Failure mechanism under overload | Observed residual thickness | Loss of impact sound attenuation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dense rock or glass wool | Mechanical fracture and definitive crushing of the fibrous texture | Less than 40% of the initial thickness | Drop of 8 to 15 dB in the improvement index |
| Elasticised expanded polystyrene | Crushing of elasticised cells, loss of dynamic elasticity | Less than 50% of the initial thickness | Drop of 6 to 12 dB in the improvement index |
| Cross-linked polyethylene foam | Rupture of closed micro-cells under high point pressure | Less than 60% of the initial thickness | Drop of 5 to 10 dB in the improvement index |
| Thin recycled fibre underlay | Extreme compaction and rigid matting without resilience | Less than 35% of the initial thickness | Drop of 10 to 18 dB in the improvement index |
Impact sound transmission to the floor below and acceptance protocol
Compliance with the limit values set by the SIA 181 standard for the weighted impact sound level depends on complete decoupling of the screed structure. When an impact occurs on the finished floor, the mechanical wave propagates through the thickness of the mortar. If the underlay has retained its nominal elasticity prescribed by the SIA 251 standard, the vibratory wave is absorbed and converted into internal friction. Conversely, if a crushed zone creates a rigid or semi-rigid contact with the concrete floor, this zone acts as a direct vibration inducer. Acoustic energy passes through the intermediate floor without noticeable attenuation and diffuses into the rooms on the floor below in the form of perceptible airborne structure-borne noise. Adult footsteps, moving chairs or the dropping of small everyday objects then generate unacceptable sound pressure levels, which are a frequent source of work acceptance disputes.
- Verification of the geometric integrity of the resilient layer over 100% of the usable surface prior to the installation of heating pipes or mesh reinforcement.
- Systematic inspection of areas beneath provisional traffic routes, doorways and work areas of other trades.
- Survey of thickness under actual load by non-destructive sounding in locations that supported skips, carpentry trestles or pallets.
- Verification of the absolute continuity of peripheral edge strips, without interruption at metal door frames or passing technical ducts.
- Formal prohibition of manual or motorised rolling machinery traffic directly on the insulation system without a protective distributing running path.
Management of disputes, sagging and acoustic non-conformities
When pallets of render, mortar or plasterboards have been stored by another trade on the laid acoustic insulation, the localised crushing destroys the cellular structure of the resilient material. The thickness under load is no longer guaranteed and the dynamic stiffness of the product increases irremediably. Pouring liquid or traditional screed under these conditions leads to a systematic acoustic bridge and blatant non-compliance with sound protection requirements according to the SIA 181 standard. The screeder who discovers this situation on their site must record the anomaly with photographs and formally notify a work interruption notice to the project management, in accordance with the general rules of the Code of Obligations relating to the duty to notify.
- Joint inspection record and measurement of degraded areasInterrupt work, mark out the perimeter compressed by the pallets on the ground and have a joint inspection record signed with site management and the person responsible for storage.
- Identical replacement of the acoustic insulationClear away the crushed panels. Relay new insulation of the same compressibility class in accordance with the SIA 251 standard, restoring the continuity of the peripheral edge strips and the sealing of the polyethylene film to prevent dripping.
- Management of a defect observed after hardeningIf post-pouring impact sound measurements reveal excessive transmission to the floor below, incomplete peripheral mechanical decoupling or crushing under screed, this entails spot sawing, extraction of the floating screed and complete repair of the system.
During the final acoustic expert assessment phase, in situ acceptance controls according to the SIA 181 standard do not forgive any crushing under load or any cement grout that has penetrated between the insulation panels. If the screed sags differentially along the skirting boards, cracks at the corners or transmits an inadmissible noise level to the floor below, the screeder who poured without written reservations exposes themselves to having to demolish and re-execute the entire work at their own expense. Continuous protection using distribution panels prior to pumping constitutes the only way to ensure final acoustic compliance.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if technical ducts prevent the acoustic underlay from lying flat?
Sanitary or electrical ducts and pipes must never be placed directly under the acoustic insulation without levelling. According to the SIA 251 standard, an equalising screed or an encasing levelling layer must be carried out beforehand to obtain a flat substrate. Laying a thin underlay over protruding pipes causes indentation points, abnormally compresses the insulation, reduces acoustic performance and risks cracking the floating screed during loading.
How to check that an acoustic underlay retains its nominal thickness under load?
The screeder must check the product data sheet indicating the compressibility class in accordance with the SIA 251 standard. The useful thickness under load, measured in the laboratory under standardised stress, determines the predictable sagging of the insulation. On site, the absence of mechanical crushing is visually checked before pouring. A graduated ruler makes it possible to measure the residual thickness at passage zones. Any significant deviation makes it necessary to replace the compressed strips or panels before pumping the mortar.
Why does the impact sound in the floor below increase if the peripheral edge is pierced?
The peripheral edge strip guarantees complete lateral decoupling between the screed and load-bearing walls. If a penetration, a torn strip or a burr of cement creates a hard contact between the floating slab and the vertical wall, the mechanical vibrations of footfall noise bypass the acoustic insulation. Acoustic energy then propagates into the building structure. The SIA 181 standard requires perfect sealing to prevent any direct transmission to adjacent rooms.
Can binder bags or tile pallets be stored on a freshly poured screed?
No heavy storage must take place on a floating screed before it has reached its required mechanical strength, generally after several weeks of curing. Placing pallets too early applies excessive point loads to the still young screed. This can compress the underlying resilient insulation beyond its elastic limit, leading to residual deformations, through-cracking and definitive deterioration of the impact sound insulation required by the SIA 181 standard.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 181Sound protection in buildings
- SIA 251Screeds in buildings
