Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 281Cement or anhydrite screed: selection and executionChapter 6 of 10 in the section

Flatness: tolerance by class, measurement with a straightedge, and what the tiler will demand

This chapter details the flatness tolerances applicable to screeds according to Swiss rules. You will learn how to carry out a joint inspection record with a straightedge and a wedge gauge, how to distinguish between standard and increased tolerance classes, and how to contractually lock in requirements right from the tender stage to avoid disputes when laying large-format elements.

Key takeaways

  • Standard flatness according to SIA 251 standard does not guarantee the laying of a large format.
  • Measurement must obligatorily be carried out using a rigid two-metre straightedge with a wedge gauge.
  • Any requirement for increased flatness requires a price supplement negotiated as soon as the initial quote is drawn up.
  • The joint inspection record before the tiler's intervention relieves the screed layer of subsequent unjustified challenges.

Measuring flatness according to SIA 251 standard and checking tolerances by class

On Swiss construction sites, the geometric handover of a completed screed is based on the appearance and spacing criteria defined by the SIA 251 standard. The screed layer must deliver a surface where hollows and bumps do not exceed the permissible thresholds for the planned system. However, the conformity of the work depends directly on the class agreed upon when ordering. Without a specific mention in the tender description, the normal tolerance applies by default, whether the screed is cement-based or calcium sulphate-based.

Surface flatness tolerances according to SIA 251 standard requirements
Execution classMeasuring spanMaximum permissible deviationUsual application field
Normal tolerance2.00 m straightedge5.0 mmStandard bonded floor coverings, standard tile dimensions up to 30 × 30 cm
Normal tolerance0.20 m straightedge2.0 mmLocal surface continuity to avoid sharp unevenness
Increased tolerance2.00 m straightedge3.0 mmLarge-format tiles, jointless floors, thin bonded slabs
Increased tolerance0.20 m straightedge1.0 mmSpecial requirements explicitly prescribed in the construction contract

To validate these values in the field, the screed craftsman does not rely on a simple glance or a laser level projected onto the walls. The verification protocol requires standardised mechanical equipment. The check is carried out using a rigid, non-deformable, rectified 2 m aluminium straightedge, placed on edge on the floor without exerting excessive pressure. Additionally, a twenty-centimetre metal ruler makes it possible to evaluate point defects.

  1. Sweeping and clearing the areaCarefully clean the inspection area. Any aggregate residue, grain of sand or plaster spatter will distort the contact of the straightedge with the substrate.
  2. Free positioning of the straightedgePlace the 2 m straightedge on its natural support points without trying to force the profile. Turn the straightedge in several directions, particularly diagonally and at pass junctions.
  3. Searching for the maximum deflectionIdentify the lowest point located between the supports of the straightedge using a graduated metal wedge gauge, avoiding any approximate reading with a tape measure.
  4. Recording valuesNote down on the construction site report the precise location, measurement direction and measured value expressed to the nearest half-millimetre.

Managing the gap between the screed layer's conformity and the tiler's requirements

The classic finishing work conflict arises when the tile layer refuses to intervene, citing a substrate that does not meet their requirements. However, a screed showing 4 mm under the two-metre straightedge perfectly complies with the normal class of the SIA 251 standard. This difference in assessment is explained by the rapid evolution of floor coverings: large-format porcelain stoneware slabs require a perfectly regular thin adhesive bed to avoid creating unacceptable edge offsets, known as lippage.

Large-format tile
Ceramic elements where one side exceeds sixty centimetres or whose unit surface exceeds 0.36 m², requiring strict substrate regularity to avoid any visible height difference between adjacent slabs.

The tiler cannot compensate for a 4 or 5 mm hollow by applying an excessive amount of adhesive without risking differential settlement during drying and cracking. Faced with this situation, the site management frequently attempts to make the screed layer responsible for remedial work or corrective sanding. However, legally and technically according to the Code of Obligations, the contractor is only obliged to execute their work in accordance with the qualities promised when concluding the contract. If the tender did not explicitly prescribe an increased tolerance, the screed delivered in the normal class has no defects.

  • Verify right from the quoting phase the exact nature of the final floor covering planned by the architect in each room.
  • Notify in writing in the quote that the prices are understood for a normal tolerance according to SIA 251 standard, unless there is a specific addendum line.
  • Quote a separate position for the increased flatness class as soon as tiles larger than 60 × 60 cm appear in the schedule.
  • Organise a joint inspection record with the straightedge and wedge gauge with the site management before the tiler arrives.
  • Have the floor handover report signed to certify compliance with contractual tolerances before any finishing work laying begins.

Joint inspection method: the rigid straightedge and the graduated wedge

To cut short any disputes when handing over the work, the flatness check of a screed is conducted according to a strict geometric protocol. Visual assessment or a summary check with a spirit level has no contractual value in the face of acceptance requirements. The conformity check relies on the combined use of a rigid, non-warped aluminium straightedge with clean, rectilinear support heels, and a millimetre-graduated measurement wedge or a set of calibrated feeler gauges.

  1. Cleaning and surface preparationCarefully sweep and vacuum the inspection area. Hardened surface laitance, screed bar pulling burrs and residual grains of sand immediately distort the contact of the straightedge and must be eliminated before any reading.
  2. Static positioning of the straightedgePlace the 2-metre straightedge without exerting any vertical pressure other than its own weight. Scan the area along two orthogonal axes and at least one diagonal, particularly looking for pouring day joint areas, doorways and room perimeters.
  3. Searching for maximum deflection by inserting the wedgeSlide the graduated wedge under the profile where the apparent gap is most pronounced between the two contact points of the straightedge. Reading the deflection is done without forcing the tool under the metal, otherwise the measured thickness would be distorted by lifting the straightedge.
  4. Close-up check with the short rulerRepeat the operation with a short 20-centimetre straightedge to track down localised undulations and close hollows. These short defects are invisible over a two-metre span but prohibitive for the seating of tiles.
Deflection limit values according to SIA 251 standard for cement-based or calcium sulphate-based screeds
Flatness classPermissible deviation under 2 m straightedgePermissible deviation under 0.2 m straightedgeUsual application field
Standard class (SIA 251 standard)≤ 5 mm≤ 2 mmTraditional laid screed, textile coverings, thick bonded parquet
Class with increased requirements≤ 3 mm≤ 1 mmMedium-format tiling, thin flexible roll floor coverings
Special requirement (special agreement)≤ 2 mm≤ 1 mmRectified large-format porcelain stoneware (side > 60 cm), thin XXL formats

Large-format tiling: the standard quote trap and contractual provisions

The classic dispute between the screed layer and the tiler stems from an initial ambiguity in the description of services. A screed delivered within the limits of the standard class of the SIA 251 standard exhibits a maximum hollow of 5 millimetres under the 2-metre straightedge. This tolerance is perfectly legal and free from legal defects within the meaning of the SIA 118 standard, if the tender description specifies nothing else. However, a tile installer laying 60 × 60 centimetre, 120 × 120 centimetre tiles or giant thin porcelain stoneware plates in a bonded installation categorically rejects such a substrate.

For the team leader and the estimator, increased flatness is not conceded at the time of pouring: it must be studied as soon as the quote is drawn up. Obtaining a 2-millimetre tolerance under the 2-metre straightedge on a traditional cement screed struck off with a straightedge requires increased compaction time, a tighter density of guides or screed pegs, and often thorough mechanical power-float finishing as the mortar sets. If the tender specifies a calcium sulphate self-levelling screed, this precision is more accessible due to the fluidity of the mix, but it nevertheless requires rigorous selection of pumping rates, careful cross-de-aeration and rigorous control of pouring heights using a millimetric laser.

The flooring professional's responsibility is to raise a clear technical reservation right from the call for tenders: if the floor covering plan indicates large format tiles or rectified natural stones, the price quote must explicitly mention the required class. Any preparatory work involving fine sanding, surface smoothing or the application of a self-levelling compound to make up for a discrepancy between the standard class and finishing tolerances must be the subject of a separate quote position. This contractual distinction protects the screed laying company against unjustified payment retentions upon handover of the finishing work lot.

Flatness dispute management and site arbitration

Conflict almost always breaks out when the tiler lays their straightedge before installing large-format slabs. If the initial tender only mentioned a standard screed according to SIA 251 standard, the work handed over by the screed layer respects standard tolerances, but proves incompatible with the bonded installation of large-dimension elements. Blocking the site or demanding free remedial work without a contractual basis is a frequent mistake made by the site management.

  1. Joint inspection record with the straightedgeSite management summons the screed layer and the tiler to the site. Measurements are taken using the rigid 2-metre straightedge and the graduated measurement wedge according to the SIA 251 standard method. Each hollow or bump outside contractual tolerance is recorded on a plan with its exact value.
  2. Checking contract documentsThe architect compares the award description with the survey. If the contract did not specify an increased tolerance, the screed is deemed compliant with the usual requirements of the SIA 251 standard. The rectification necessary for the subsequent covering then falls under a change order.
  3. Choice of technical remediationOn cement screed, localised extra thicknesses are eliminated by mechanical diamond disc sanding. Residual lippages and hollows require a compatible fibred self-levelling floor screed. On calcium sulphate-based fluid screed, planing must preserve the structure without overheating the binder.
  4. Financial allocation of workAccording to the award rules and the SIA 118 standard, remedial work located within the agreed standard tolerance is not chargeable to the screed layer. If deviations exceed the general permitted tolerances, the portion of sanding or levelling linked to these defects remains their sole responsibility.

Frequently asked questions

What flatness tolerance applies by default on a new screed?

Without specific mention in the tender description or the construction contract, the basic requirements of the SIA 251 standard apply for screed work. They authorise a maximum deviation under the two-metre straightedge adapted to standard coverings. This usual tolerance allows conventional installation, but it automatically rules out the direct bonded installation of very large-format ceramic slabs without a prior levelling layer.

Who bears the cost of skimming if the screed complies with the quote?

If the joint inspection confirms compliance with the flatness class agreed in the quote, the screed layer has fulfilled their contractual obligation according to the SIA 118 standard. The application of a smoothing compound or an equalization mortar necessary for large-format tiling constitutes an additional service. These remediation works must be the subject of a site work order or an addendum validated by the client before any intervention on the surface.

How to record a flatness defect contested by the tiler?

The check must obligatorily be carried out jointly using a two-metre aluminium straightedge and a standardised bevelled measurement wedge. Each observed deflection is measured in millimetres, marked with wax chalk on the floor and reported on a room location plan. The report signed by the site management and the two companies fixes the points requiring targeted sanding or skimming.

Can a general false level be corrected by simply sanding the screed?

Mechanical sanding only treats ridges, burrs and local bulges over a few millimetres of depth. It in no way allows for the correction of an erroneous general slope or an extended hollow. Furthermore, excessively planing a floating screed risks weakening its mechanical resistance and reducing the minimum cover required over underfloor heating pipes, which would necessitate completely redoing the affected area.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 251Specifications, execution and flatness requirements of screeds in buildings
  • SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work and management of additional services

In the same section