Key takeaways
- Standard SIA 251 sets the flatness tolerances measured under the two-metre straightedge.
- A stabilised surface cracking is bridged with resin without justifying complete demolition.
- A localised hollow sound without total loss of adhesion does not systematically compromise the future floor covering.
- Standard SIA 118 governs the choice between physical rework of the work and negotiated financial price reduction.
Distinguishing an admissible flaw from a blocking obstacle for the subsequent trade
On Swiss construction sites, the handover of a floating screed regularly gives rise to premature disputes from the site management or the flooring installer. Any deviation from a theoretically perfect state does not constitute a construction defect. Technical analysis first requires characterising the physical nature of the anomaly: is it an excess of the geometric tolerances of standard SIA 251, a structural mechanical flaw specific to the wearing layer, or simply a minor hydraulic shrinkage reaction? This distinction determines the continuation of the construction site and prevents unjustified stoppages.
- Flatness tolerance according to standard SIA 251
- Admissible deviation measured under a metal straightedge placed on two high points of the finished screed surface. For a screed receiving a standard bonded floor covering, the maximum allowed deflection is four millimetres under the two-metre straightedge, unless stricter specifications are outlined in the construction contract.
A defect is classified as blocking when it directly compromises the mechanical adhesion, durability or final flatness of the floor covering. For example, residual moisture exceeding the prescribed limits prior to the installation of waterproof parquet or large-format tiling prohibits any intervention by the subsequent trade. Conversely, a general level error of one millimetre beyond the normative threshold, or a marginal area exhibiting a slight hollow sound without crumbling or vertical movement under load, in no way blocks the installation of a carpet or floating parquet.
| On-site inspection | Technical qualification | Impact on the subsequent trade | Required action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deflection of 6 mm under the 2 m straightedge | Out of flatness tolerance | Blocking for large-format tiling and bonded parquet | Grinding of high spots or self-levelling smoothing compound |
| Fine shrinkage crack of less than 0.5 mm | Non-structural cracking | Non-blocking after stitching | V-grooving and casting of reactive resin |
| Localised hollow sound without cracking | Superficial adhesion debonding | Non-blocking for unbonded installation | Monitoring or targeted injection if subjected to heavy loads |
| Height difference at a joint | Thermal or mechanical curling | Blocking for all types of thin floor coverings | Planer routing or mechanical reprofiling of the edge |
Addressing non-conformities: technical repair or price reduction in accordance with standard SIA 118
When a deviation exceeds contractual limits, the site management cannot immediately demand the demolition of the work. Swiss building practice rules and standard SIA 118 establish a strict hierarchy between remediation at the contractor's expense, acceptance with localised repair, and compensation via financial price reduction when the intended use remains fully guaranteed.
- Joint inspection record of the anomalyThe site foreman carries out an on-site examination in the presence of the site management and the flooring installer. Each flaw is located on a plan with mention of its millimetric extent or exact surface area.
- Evaluation of technical repairabilityThe contractor checks whether a localised mechanical intervention can restore tolerances without weakening the screed. Crack bridging using corrugated metal staples and epoxy resin is the priority solution for clean cracks.
- Arbitration between remediation and price reductionIf the defect does not generate any risk of evolution over time but requires minor preparatory work by the subsequent trade, the parties negotiate a lump-sum compensatory allowance to cover this adaptation.
- Written record in the minutesThe concluded agreement is the subject of an addendum or an explicit mention in the construction site minutes, releasing the screed layer from any subsequent warranty obligation on the compensated area.
Repair remains the guiding principle as soon as the integrity of the screed can be restored in accordance with professional standards. A stabilised crack does not depreciate the value of the substrate if it is stitched using transverse chases spaced twenty to thirty centimetres apart, reinforced with steel bars and refilled with a shrink-free synthetic resin. This operation makes the screed monolithic and immediately authorises the installation of the floor covering without the risk of transmitting surface stresses.
The negotiated price reduction mainly applies to aesthetic defects or minor tolerances impacting neither safety nor the service life of the floor assembly. When the targeted grinding of a screed crest risks breaching the minimum embedment of the heating pipes, replacing a destructive intervention with the application of a thin smoothing screed financed by the screed layer represents the most rational technical solution. This amicable settlement fully aligns with the collaborative spirit of standard SIA 118.
Joint inspection record and physical qualification in accordance with standard SIA 251
On the construction site, the discovery of an anomaly on an anhydrite or cement screed immediately sparks tensions between the screed layer, the site management and the flooring installer. To defuse the conflict, the qualification of the flaw must be based on an impeccable geometric and mechanical survey, recorded jointly in a joint inspection record before any intervention by the subsequent trade. According to professional standards and the requirements of standard SIA 251, each deviation must be measured using calibrated tools, distinguishing stable surface deformation from the structural instability of the floating assembly.
- Differential curling
- Temporary or permanent geometric deformation of the edges and corners of a floating screed, caused by an evaporation gradient or a thermal difference between the underside and the surface of the mortar.
Flatness control is carried out using a rigid two-metre straightedge placed on the high points and a bevelled rule or a graduated measurement wedge. The point deviation under the straightedge characterises the hollow or the high spot. For a screed receiving a thin bonded floor covering, standard SIA 251 sets strict tolerances. When the sag exceeds the contractual threshold, it is necessary to check whether the defect results from a settlement of the acoustic insulation or simple surface shrinkage. Inspection at door openings and along movement joints constitutes a critical point: a height difference between two spans immediately blocks the tiling or parquet trade, as mechanical and aesthetic continuity cannot be guaranteed without abnormal stress on the future floor covering.
Acoustic auscultation using a steel ball or a light hammer makes it possible to map the areas of hollow sound. This acoustic phenomenon does not systematically indicate destructive delamination. On a floating screed, installed by definition on a separation membrane and compressible thermal or acoustic insulation, a dull resonance is normal in the centre of rooms. Conversely, a sharp clicking sound accompanied by vertical movement underfoot at the room edges indicates acute curling or a loss of support on the compressible perimeter strip. In this case, the defect formally prevents the installation of a rigid floor covering because the cantilever would break the tiles under operational load.
Arbitration between technical repair and price reduction in accordance with standard SIA 118
As soon as an established defect is recorded in the verification minutes, the site management and the contractor must decide on the method of resolution in application of the contractual framework defined by standard SIA 118. The defective work does not automatically imply the complete demolition of the poured surface. The principle of proportionality governs the order: if complete remediation requires costs and time disproportionate to the actual loss of value or the intended use of the building, a targeted remedial measure or financial compensation in the form of a negotiated price reduction must be prioritized.
- Written notification of the notice of defectsThe site management draws up a precise survey of the flaws with location on a plan and joint measurement, then transmits the formal notice to the screed layer granting them a reasonable response time.
- Evaluation of technical repairabilityThe screed layer analyses whether the application of a self-levelling smoothing compound, the grinding of a high spot or the stitching of a crack allows the tolerances required by standard SIA 251 to be restored without altering the compatibility of the future floor covering.
- Negotiation of the retention or price reductionIf the defect affects neither the durability nor the fitness for purpose of the work, the client and the contractor agree in writing on a definitive price reduction, settling the dispute without destructive physical rework.
| Nature of the anomaly | Impact on the subsequent trade | Recommended technical measure | Usual contractual outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Local sag out of tolerance (> 4 mm under 2 m straightedge) | Impossibility of bonding large-format tiling without the risk of voids under the tile. | Self-levelling levelling smoothing compound after grinding and bonding primer. | Repair at the screed layer's expense or taking charge of the smoothing compound executed by the tiler. |
| Corner height difference due to stabilised curling (< 2 mm) | Minor hindrance for the installation of an acoustic underlay beneath floating parquet. | Planer routing or diamond grinding of the protruding area to restore flatness. | Simple technical repair accepted or tolerance with minor lump-sum price reduction. |
| Through-crack without altimetric difference | Risk of transmitting shrinkage stress to the tiling or natural stone. | Opening of the crack with an angle grinder, installation of metal brackets and epoxy resin. | Immediate lifting of the reservation after drying; no price reduction applicable after compliant treatment. |
| Superficial crazing without detachment | No mechanical obstacle for bonded parquet or screed intended to remain covered. | Thorough vacuuming and application of a mineral pore-sealer primer if necessary. | Negotiated residual aesthetic price reduction if the screed remains exposed, none if covered. |
In summary, classifying a defect as a blocking obstacle or an admissible imperfection conditions the schedule of the finishing work. Standard SIA 118 offers the legal levers necessary to avoid sterile site blockage: when a sustainable technical solution exists for a moderate cost, it takes precedence over the complete dismantling of the floating screed. Financial retention, for its part, only compensates for stabilized defects that generate no subsequent degradation for the operator of the work.
Escalation procedure in case of disagreement on the qualification of the defect
When technical negotiation fails, the major risk for the screed company lies in unilateral financial retention on the invoice or arbitrary interruption of the schedule by the flooring installer. As soon as the parquet layer or tiler refuses the substrate by citing standard SIA 251, while the identified defect remains repairable without altering the intended destination of the work, the site manager must quickly frame the dispute through a written and rigorous procedure.
- Formal joint inspection recordSummoning the site management and the floor covering applicator on site under the regime of standard SIA 118. The joint inventory of fixtures records the physical measurements: deflection under the two-metre straightedge, exact layout of inert cracks, residual moisture measurement using the calcium carbide device, and mapping of areas exhibiting a hollow sound.
- Formal notice and technical proposalNotifying in writing a remediation protocol compliant with trade rules: bridging cracks using steel stitching and epoxy resin, grinding a raised area or compensatory smoothing compound. Accompanying this proposal with a reasonable response time to prevent overall schedule delays from being blamed on the screed company.
- Recourse to neutral technical expertiseIf the site management refuses the repair and unjustifiably demands the complete demolition of the screed, requesting a neutral technical expert in accordance with the mechanisms of standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations. The arbitral expertise rules on the mechanical compatibility of the substrate with the installation of the planned floor covering.
When the client refuses local repair and imposes complete replacement at the price of exorbitant additional costs, manifest disproportion protects the screed layer against abusive remediation. The contractor records their reservations by registered mail. The subsequent installation of the floor covering by a second trade corps, without validation of the corrective measures, transfers the responsibility for the screed's behaviour to the subsequent trade.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if the parquet layer refuses the screed due to flatness out of tolerance?
The screed layer must jointly verify the deviations using a two-metre straightedge and a bevelled rule in accordance with standard SIA 251. If the height difference exceeds the tolerances allowed for bonded parquet but remains localised, the solution consists of grinding the high spots or applying a self-levelling smoothing compound with appropriate adhesion. This technical treatment remedies the blockage without justifying the complete remediation of the screed.
Does a localised hollow sound systematically require demolition?
No, a hollow sound on a floating screed is not a structural defect because the work rests on compressible thermal or acoustic insulation. If the phenomenon occurs on a bonded screed, it reveals localised debonding from the substrate. The injection of a fluid epoxy resin under low pressure makes it possible to restore mechanical cohesion and adhesion without demolition, authorizing the installation of the floor covering in complete safety under the control of standard SIA 118.
How to treat a crack to allow the installation of large-format tiling?
A stabilised crack does not block installation if it is mechanically bridged before the tiler's intervention. Repair requires chases perpendicular to the crack line, the installation of corrugated metal staples and filling by pouring a two-component synthetic resin sanded to refusal. This bonding neutralises horizontal and vertical differential movements, guaranteeing the substrate compliance prescribed by standard SIA 251 for sealed or bonded ceramic floor coverings.
When is a price reduction preferable to remediation according to standard SIA 118?
The negotiated price reduction is required when the observed defect is purely aesthetic or does not hinder the normal use of the screed, and its demolition would entail disproportionate expenses. If a minor altimetry defect does not prevent the adjustment of doors or the implementation of floor coverings, the parties agree on a fair price reduction under the aegis of standard SIA 118, thus avoiding critical schedule delays for the entire construction site.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction works
- SIA 251Screeds inside buildings
