Key takeaways
- Systematic hammer testing identifies unbonded tiles that compromise the stability of the assembly.
- Tiling that sounds hollow in diffuse areas requires complete removal of the floor covering.
- The bonded screed requires aggressive mechanical preparation and a specific dust-free bonding primer.
- The unbonded screed requires a greater minimum thickness, limiting its use under existing thresholds.
Hammer testing and diagnosis of existing tiling prior to any work
Working on old tiling is a high-risk situation for the screed layer. According to standard trade practice and the requirements of the SIA 251 standard, a substrate intended to receive a bonded screed must form a monolithic, clean, rough assembly free from any residual movement. Ceramic or vitrified porcelain tiles form a smooth, waterproof and glazed surface whose bond with the original bedding mortar has often degraded over decades. Before considering pouring a mortar or a self-levelling compound, diagnosing the adhesion of every square metre is essential.
The reference tool on the construction site remains the locksmith's hammer or light inspection hammer, supplemented by a wooden handle rubbed across the floor. The procedure involves systematically tapping each tile in a grid pattern across the room. A clear, dull sound indicates direct wave transmission into the underlying substrate, confirming a rigid bond. Conversely, a hollow or muffled sound indicates clear detachment between the tile and its adhesive, or between the bedding layer and the slab. When a tile sounds hollow, the underlying air layer prevents any proper load transfer and immediately creates a sagging or shearing point for the applied screed.
| Inspection finding | Mechanical risk under the screed | Corrective action required |
|---|---|---|
| Isolated hollow tiles (less than 5% of the surface) | Localized settlement and flexural cracking | Spot hacking out, fast-setting resin mortar patching |
| Clustered hollow areas (more than 10% of the surface) | Chain detachment under the effect of mortar shrinkage | Complete removal of the tiling and its bedding layer |
| Through-cracks visible in the tiling | Direct transmission of structural movements | Opening up cracks, resin bridging and staples |
| Surfaces contaminated with oils, waxes or greasy residues | Total breakdown of chemical adhesion | Alkaline degreasing and mechanical diamond grinding |
As soon as hollow-sounding areas exceed a critical threshold or are distributed heterogeneously across the room, the only sustainable decision is to record the defect in writing and require complete removal. This demolition must imperatively include the old tiling as well as the old adhesive layer or bedding slurry in order to reach the original bare substrate, which is the only one capable of offering measurable mechanical strength.
Choice of assembly according to the SIA 251 standard and management of available height
Once the integrity of the substrate has been validated or the defective tiling hacked out, the screed layer must determine the design of the work in accordance with the SIA 251 standard. Two technical principles oppose each other: the bonded screed and the unbonded screed on a separation membrane. This choice depends directly on the final quality of the laying substrate, but also on the major geometric constraint in renovation work: the available reserved height.
- Checking the reference level and thresholdsCheck the height under French doors, stair landings and interior doors using a laser level. The total extra thickness includes the thickness of the screed and that of the future floor covering with its adhesive.
- Bonded screed option on stripped tilingSelected when the reserved height is low (generally between 25 and 40 mm). It requires perfectly sound tiling, shot-blasting or diamond grinding to open up the surface, followed by an epoxy primer fully blinded with sand.
- Unbonded screed option on polyethylene filmMandatory if the tiling shows stabilized micro-cracks that are incompatible with direct adhesion. It requires a significantly higher minimum nominal thickness to withstand loads without cracking.
- Installation of perimeter edge insulation stripsInstall a compressible edge strip continuously along all walls and vertical elements to absorb thermal expansion and prevent rigid thermal bridges.
| Screed type | Standard minimum thickness | Required preparation of the tiling | Impact on door heights |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bonded cement screed | 25 to 30 mm | Heavy planing or sanding, bonding primer | Connection often possible without heavy planing |
| Bonded calcium sulphate screed | 20 to 25 mm | Mechanical roughening, barrier primer | Low elevation of existing thresholds |
| Unbonded cement screed | 45 to 50 mm | Polyethylene film laid with overlapping joints | Almost systematic conflict with existing doors |
| Unbonded calcium sulphate screed | 35 to 40 mm | Waterproof separation membrane, edge strips | Often requires trimming door frames |
In conclusion, pouring over existing tiling is never an easy economical solution without rigorous analysis. If the height under the lintel is insufficient or if the tiling comes off in slabs during trial chiselling, complete removal is technically essential. It allows work to restart from a stable concrete substrate, gain the precious centimetres required by insulation or modern floor coverings, and ensure the durability of the work without engaging the screed layer's liability on a poor substrate.
Technical decision: localized hacking out or complete removal of detached tiling
The acoustic diagnosis carried out during the hammer test unequivocally determines the fate of the existing ceramic tiling. Two scenarios face the screed site foreman. When the hollow-sounding tiles are strictly localized and represent a marginal surface area of less than approximately ten percent of the total room area, spot hacking out is feasible. Each detached slab is mechanically chipped away with a flat chisel down to sound underlying concrete or screed. On the other hand, as soon as the hollow resonances form continuous slabs or are diffusely distributed over more than a tenth of the room, the overall cohesion of the bedding layer is broken. Retaining these elements condemns any applied assembly: differential movements and service vibrations will inevitably lead to interface shear and premature cracking of the new floor.
After removing the hollow-sounding tiles, the residual cavities must be thoroughly vacuumed using an industrial vacuum cleaner. Leaving open depressions under a floating or unbonded screed would locally weaken the seating of the intermediate membrane and create thickness variations generating shrinkage stresses. These gaps are therefore patched using a rapid-setting, shrinkage-free mortar, levelled off flush with the top surface of adjacent tiles that are still perfectly bonded. If the decision for total removal is made, all the historical tile adhesive or bedding slurry must also be stripped by milling or shot-blasting to restore a bare, stable and flat surface in compliance with substrate tolerance requirements.
Execution trade-off: unbonded screed on membrane or bonded system
The technical alternative between an unbonded system and a bonded screed is dictated by the finished height level available below door thresholds and windows. According to the SIA 251 standard, an unbonded cement screed requires a nominal thickness of at least 40 mm, laid over a polyethylene film of at least 0.2 mm thickness with waterproof overlaps of 100 mm taped at the joints. This solution has the decisive technical advantage of eliminating any risk associated with the presence of retained old tiles: the new mortar slab works completely independently of the tiled substrate's stresses. However, incorporating this assembly requires having a height reservation between 50 and 60 mm including the future floor covering.
| Site criterion | Bonded screed with bridging | Unbonded screed on PE membrane |
|---|---|---|
| Required height reservation | Low to medium (25 to 35 mm) | High (minimum 40 mm excluding finish) |
| Required condition of existing tiling | Total adhesion, zero hollow-sounding areas | Stable tiles, localized hollows patched |
| Preparation of the ceramic | Diamond sanding and fully blinded primed surface | Simple cleaning and thorough vacuuming |
| Risk of cracking from the substrate | High in case of underlying detachment | Zero thanks to mechanical independence |
| Re-creation of control joints | Mandatory alignment with tile joints | Free layout according to SIA 251 rules |
When the residual height reservation prevents reaching the 40 mm threshold, pouring a bonded screed becomes the only alternative to avoid heavy joinery alterations. This variant requires flawless residual tiling. The surface glaze must be mechanically roughened by diamond disc sanding to remove vitrification, waxes and greasy maintenance products. After complete vacuuming, a two-component epoxy bonding resin is applied, immediately blinded to saturation with quartz sand of suitable particle size. This operation gives the old tiling a mineral roughness capable of taking up the shear stresses of the fresh mortar.
Regardless of the technique chosen, the installation of compressible perimeter strips against all vertical walls, door frames and pipe penetrations is mandatory. With a minimum thickness of 8 mm, these edge strips prevent rigid thermal bridges and absorb the dimensional shrinkage of the mortar during its hardening phase. Control joints must be scrupulously provided at room narrowing and doorways to respect the surface area ratios of the SIA 251 standard, guaranteeing the durability of the new work without crack transmission.
Handling unforeseen issues: widespread hollow sound, cracking and height reservation
On a renovation site, discovering tiling that sounds hollow over large areas after surface stripping or during hammer testing fundamentally changes the technical situation. When tiles detach from the original bedding layer, no slurry or adhesion primer can ensure the mechanical stability required by the SIA 251 standard. Attempting a bonded pour on a tiled surface with failing anchorage inevitably leads to the lifting of the new screed under the effect of hydraulic shrinkage or building live loads.
Faced with this instability, switching to an unbonded screed on a plastic membrane is the primary technical reflex to overcome the condition of the substrate. This solution neutralizes the differential movements of the existing tiling, but it requires a significantly higher vertical clearance. According to the SIA 251 standard, an unbonded cement mortar screed requires a minimum nominal extra thickness between 40 and 50 mm, a value that very often exceeds the height available under door frames and landings.
- Record altimetric incompatibility: measure finished levels with a laser level relative to thresholds and record the lack of thickness in a site report.
- Refuse high-risk bonded pouring: submit a reasoned written notice to site management explaining the impossibility of guaranteeing the stability of the work on unstable tiling.
- Stop work and demand removal: request the complete removal of the tiling and its laying mortar to reach the bare load-bearing element.
- Adapt the binder if levels require it: propose, after removal or if the height barely permits it, a calcium sulphate-based self-levelling screed to optimize the reserved millimetres.
If site management refuses global removal and demands an assembly that is too thin for compliant unbonded installation, the screed layer must suspend operations. Executing a screed outside standardized tolerances exposes the work to major structural defects, the complete repair of which proves much more costly than initially chipping out the existing tiling.
Frequently asked questions
What to do if only a few tiles sound hollow when hammered?
If less than 5% of the surface is affected in isolated areas, locally remove the hollow-sounding tiles. Clean the substrate, vacuum thoroughly, then fill the cavity using a fast-setting repair mortar compatible with the binder of the future screed. This intervention makes it possible to maintain the principle of a bonded screed, subject to general mechanical sanding and the application of a suitable primer.
Why is the unbonded screed not always suitable on old tiling?
The main obstacle lies in the available height after adding thickness. According to the SIA 251 standard, an unbonded screed on a synthetic membrane requires a minimum thickness of 40 to 50 mm in cement mortar, or 35 mm in fluid anhydrite screed. If the level of door thresholds, French doors or stairwells cannot be changed, this vertical clearance is missing and requires the complete removal of the existing tiling.
What is the exact risk of pouring a bonded screed on a floor that sounds hollow?
During its setting and hardening, the screed undergoes hydraulic shrinkage which generates significant tensile and shear stresses. If the lower tiling no longer adheres perfectly to its original substrate, these stresses will tear off the unstable tiles. The screed then lifts as a single unit, causing through-cracks, subsidence and premature destruction of the final floor covering to be laid on top.
How to check for the absence of rising damp under old tiling?
Before choosing the assembly, glue a one-square-metre waterproof plastic sheet to the floor with strong adhesive tape for forty-eight hours. The presence of condensed water droplets or darkening under the film indicates rising damp by capillarity. In this situation, a bonded assembly would suffer rapid interface degradation. It is essential to interpose a waterproof vapour barrier, which makes it necessary to adopt an unbonded screed.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 251Screeds in construction
