Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 281Drying, heat-up and moisture measurementsChapter 9 of 10 in the section

Dampness returns: leak, waterproofing defect under the slab, or screed that never dried

After installing tiles or parquet, the reappearance of moisture pockets leads to complex disputes on the construction site. This chapter shows you how to carry out targeted core drilling and analyse water gradients at depth. You will know how to distinguish an improperly dried screed from a leak under a conduit or a defective waterproof barrier in order to rigorously defend your financial interests.

Key takeaways

  • Surface measurement can never prove the exact origin of a moisture defect.
  • Stepped core drilling with the carbide test determines the migration direction of residual water.
  • The SIA 251 standard serves as the technical reference for judging compliance before final installation.
  • The moisture gradient unambiguously identifies the party responsible for remediation costs on the construction site.

Core drilling and measuring moisture at depth according to SIA 251 standard

Parquet flooring lifts or tile joints turn white a few months after the acceptance of the work. Faced with this defect, the site management almost systematically blames the screed contractor, suspected of having rushed their inspection before handing over the substrate. However, a simple capacitive or dielectric surface check provides no conclusive evidence to settle a dispute. Visible surface moisture can stem from internal water retention in the mortar, a broken pipe, or continuous infiltration from the lower parts of the building. To establish an irrefutable diagnosis, the assembly must be opened and samples taken across the entire thickness of the mortar.

  1. Sampling by mechanical core drilling without overheatingCarry out dry extraction at low speed through the floor covering and the screed, taking scrupulous care not to add cooling water, which would distort the hygrometric measurements.
  2. Fractionation of the sample by thickness horizonsImmediately cut the extracted core into three distinct slices: the upper third, the central third, and the lower third in direct contact with the insulation or separation film.
  3. Calcium carbide measurement on each stratumCrush each fraction separately with a hammer in a sealed container, then carry out analyses using the carbide bomb in order to establish the residual moisture content curve.
Interpretation of moisture profiles measured by screed stratum
Measured hygrometric profileUpper thirdLower thirdTechnical origin of the defect
Marked upward gradientLow compliant valueVery high water contentAbsence of barrier under slab or external infiltration
High homogeneous moisture profileValue out of toleranceValue out of toleranceScreed never dried, covered prematurely
Localized saturation under screedModerate moistureComplete saturation with free waterLeak in embedded pipe or heating element

The SIA 251 standard defines the rules of good workmanship for the execution and control of floating screeds in French-speaking Switzerland. When the carbide measurement protocol carried out before installing the floor covering has been duly recorded, the comparison between these initial readings and the gradient measured on the core constitutes the centerpiece of the technical file. This vertical gradient unequivocally demonstrates whether water accumulated from above, became trapped right from the pouring stage, or arrived uninterruptedly from the infrastructure.

Embedded leak, defective barrier under slab, or un-dried screed: establishing who pays

Three radically different causes lead to the same visual manifestations of degradation on the finished floor. Combined analysis of the core drilling profile and the operation of the building systems allows the precise origin of the defect to be identified and the resulting costs to be assigned:

  • The embedded pipe leak: water comes from a pierced sanitary supply pipe, a disconnected drain, or a damaged underfloor heating network. Water flows directly into the levelling fill or acoustic insulation before wetting the underside of the screed. The pressure drop on the system pressure gauge confirms this diagnosis.
  • The absence of a barrier under the slab: on a foundation slab resting on natural ground or above a very damp unheated room, the lack of a bituminous vapour barrier or synthetic waterproofing under the slab causes a continuous migration of vapour by capillarity towards the floor assembly.
  • The screed that never dried: the mortar was sealed with a waterproof adhesive or plastic covering before having reached the limit thresholds set by the SIA 251 standard, often under the pressure of an unrealistic delivery schedule.

The final invoice includes the removal of the degraded floor covering, technical drying by overpressure under the screed, or complete hacking out of the assembly. If a pipe leak is present, the financial burden shifts to the sanitary installer or heating engineer, along with coverage by their business civil liability insurance. If core drilling reveals an absence of a barrier under the slab, the fault lies with the site management's planning or the structural work contractor who omitted the installation of the regulatory vapour barrier. The screed contractor is only held liable for remediation costs if the core drilling profile proves a screed uniformly saturated with residual water and no carbide measurement report was drawn up before releasing the construction site.

Reading the moisture gradient on the core: identifying the physical source

When resin blistering, tile debonding, or parquet warping appear a few weeks after acceptance, the diagnosis cannot be limited to a surface measurement. Residual moisture measured at the surface is often distorted by the vapour tightness of the floor covering itself. The destructive method of full core drilling of the floating screed assembly, prescribed according to the rules of good workmanship of the SIA 251 standard, makes it possible to extract the material and draw up a stepped moisture profile from top to bottom.

To formally distinguish the origin of the defect, the extracted sample must be fractionated immediately on site and sealed in airtight bags before being tested with the calcium carbide bomb (CM device). Sampling must strictly distinguish the surface crust, the core of the mortar, the bottom of the screed resting on the separation film, and the laying bed of the thermal or acoustic insulation.

Interpretation of CM moisture profiles according to the observed pathology
Suspected pathologyVertical moisture profile (screed)Condition of insulation and raw substrateCharacteristic physical finding
Screed never dried (evaporation defect)Maximum content at the core of the screed, decreasing towards both facesUnderside of insulation and load-bearing slab drySymmetrical moisture gradient typical of premature stopping of drying or incomplete heating up.
Embedded pipe leak (heating or sanitary)Total local saturation, very marked horizontal gradient from the leakFree water under polyethylene sheet, insulation waterloggedVisible pressure drop on system pressure gauge, highly localized moisture without correlation with the foundation slab.
Absence of barrier under slab (capillary rise)Increasing moisture from surface to bottom of screedSupporting concrete saturated with water, massive condensation under insulationContinuous inverted gradient: structural concrete exhibits mass moisture higher than that of the screed.

The distinction between unevaporated mixing water and an external source relies on the thermodynamics of the assembly. A screed poured and then covered too quickly redistributes its internal water homogeneously beneath a waterproof covering, without ever saturating the insulation placed below. Conversely, as soon as the underside of the insulation shows a film of liquid water or the concrete slab displays a higher moisture content than the screed mortar, the cause lies below the separation assembly.

Joint inspection record and cost allocation: preserving the artisan's rights

The laboratory or CM bottle measurement result directly determines the financial recourse chain. As soon as abnormal content is detected after floor covering installation, the screed contractor must demand a joint inspection record on site, bringing together the site management, floor layer, sanitary or heating installer, and civil engineer. The initial screed measurement protocol, signed during the transfer of the work prior to floor covering installation, constitutes the centerpiece of the file.

  1. Pressurization and thermal tracing of networksBefore any chipping, the heating or sanitary installer tests the tightness of circuits under test pressure. The use of a thermal camera coupled with restarting circulation makes it possible to isolate a diffuse hot spot or an abnormal pressure drop along an embedded pipe.
  2. Sampling on raw slabCore drilling through the insulation down to the concrete allows the presence of liquid water under the vapour barrier to be checked. Measuring the moisture of the raw substrate proves whether the slab is transmitting ground water by capillarity.
  3. Formal notification according to the Code of Obligations (CO)The joint expert assessment record is recorded in writing. The contractor forwards their reservations and technical conclusions to the site management to refuse the allocation of demolition and technical drying work.

When the absence of a waterproof barrier under ground-bearing slabs is confirmed, responsibility falls under building physics and structural engineering plans. Drying by adsorption dehumidifiers and complete repair of the floor covering cannot be imputed to the screed contractor who executed their work in accordance with the reservation plans approved by the site management. Only proof of an initial moisture content outside tolerances at the time of floor covering installation would make it possible to call into question the screed artisan's warranty.

Crisis management and technical arbitration during a moisture defect

When the floor covering detaches, blisters, or moulds a few weeks after delivery, the immediate reaction on site too often consists of designating the screed contractor as the default culprit. Accepting this position without instrumented investigation constitutes a serious error with financial consequences. Before any removal or emergency drying intervention, the physical state of the floor assembly must be frozen. Engaging dehumidification devices without prior readings destroys measurable moisture gradients and definitively prevents determining whether water comes from residual mixing, a pipe rupture, or external supply.

  1. Conservatory stop and formal summonsInterrupt work on the affected area. Send a written notice without delay to the site management requesting the organisation of a joint inspection record with the heating engineer, sanitary installer, and mason, under the rules of SIA 118.
  2. Execution of core drillings according to SIA 251 standardHave core drilling probes carried out across the entire thickness of the screed down to the insulating underlayer. Immediate fractionation of the core into strata and sealed packaging allow the vertical distribution of water to be analysed in a neutral laboratory.
  3. Pressurization of networks and substrate inspectionDemand pressure testing on embedded sanitary and heating circuits. In parallel, check the integrity of the moisture barrier beneath thermal insulation to confirm or exclude water ingress from the foundation slab.

If the dispute persists despite visual findings, the intervention of an independent technical expert is required before any legal action according to the Code of Obligations (CO). Investigation costs, including carbide method measurements, differential oven weightings, and destructive checks, must be advanced according to a written agreement or integrated into defect costs to be assigned to the defaulting party. The scientific proof provided by the vertical moisture profile remains the only means to compel the party actually responsible for the defect to take charge of repairs.

Frequently asked questions

Who advances the costs of core drilling and expert assessment during a moisture dispute?

The site management or contesting company commissions investigations to compile the file. According to SIA 118, the costs of probing and laboratory analysis are first advanced by the party requesting the expert assessment. Once the technical report is established, these disbursements are fully reinvoiced to the company whose work is recognized as defective: the sanitary or heating installer in case of a leak, the mason in case of infiltration, or the screed contractor if the screed was not dry.

How to differentiate an embedded leak from residual mixing moisture?

Fractionated core drilling according to SIA 251 standard provides the formal answer. An insufficiently dried screed shows a higher moisture content at the core of its thickness than at the surface, while remaining stable over time. A leak on an embedded pipe locally saturates the insulation and the base of the screed, creating a sharp upward gradient with a water content that continues to increase. The network pressure holding test immediately confirms the diagnosis.

What to do if site management refuses to open the tiling to probe the screed?

The artisan must immediately record their refusal via a reasoned written notice in accordance with the Code of Obligations (CO). Without direct destructive probing, no irrefutable material proof can be established. The contractor reiterates that surface dielectric methods do not allow moisture to be quantified at depth according to SIA 251 standard. Any refusal by the client releases the company from the presumption of defects as long as the required investigations remain blocked by site management.

Is the screed contractor liable if the absence of a vapour barrier under the slab causes the defect?

The design and installation of the vapour barrier or waterproofing film on the raw concrete slab fall under the general planning of the structural work. The screed contractor checks the visual presence of the separation film under their mortar according to SIA 251 standard, but is not liable for a structural waterproofing defect against rising groundwater or soil moisture. If vapour passes through concrete and saturates the insulation from below, liability lies with the designer.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work
  • SIA 251Screeds in buildings

In the same section