Key takeaways
- A thick screed stores heat and delays the drop in room temperature by several hours.
- Lowering the setpoint on underfloor heating rarely produces a usable temperature drop within eight hours.
- The extra power demanded for the morning recovery degrades the seasonal efficiency of the low-temperature thermodynamic generator.
- A comparative measurement over two consecutive weeks validates keeping a continuous setpoint for the heavy building.
Understanding emitter inertia and the energy trap of the morning recovery
On central heating systems connected to an underfloor heating network, lowering the setpoint temperature at night is a reflex inherited from radiator systems. Yet in a modern building meeting current insulation requirements or with a massive masonry envelope, this setting frequently gives an unfavourable energy balance. The dynamic behaviour of the emitter-building pair works against the rapid variations imposed by a standard programming timer.
- Thermal time constant
- Time needed for the indoor environment to lose 63 % of the difference between its initial setpoint temperature and the outdoor temperature, under the combined mass inertia of the structure and the slabs.
The inertia of the building and of the emitter dictates the response of the system. A flowing or traditional cement screed has an average thickness of 60 to 75 mm above the insulation. This mineral mass stores a considerable amount of energy. When the control system stops circulation or lowers the flow setpoint at 22:00, the floor keeps releasing its heat into the room for three to five hours. The room temperature only starts to drop around 03:00 in the morning, often by less than 0.5 to 1.0 °C if the surface heat losses of the envelope are low.
As regards the duration and depth of the setback, a shutdown of six to eight hours with a setpoint reduction of more than 2 °C disturbs the thermal regime without producing real savings. The floor takes several hours to warm up. If the generator output is sized as tightly as possible according to the heat-loss calculations of standard SIA 384.201, the system lacks the reserve to catch up without switching on an energy-hungry electric backup. Under art. 364 CO, the installer carries out the work with care; this technical duty means calibrating the controls to the real physics of the building rather than applying unsuitable theoretical charts.
Managing the controls: optimising recovery or documented abandonment
To decide whether to keep a setback or run the network continuously, the foreman must analyse the structural characteristics of the project. The choice is between two very different operating strategies depending on the overall thermal mass.
| Construction feature | Emitters installed | Recommended strategy | Impact on the generator |
|---|---|---|---|
| Timber frame, thin dry screed | Pipes on aluminium diffusers | Setback of 1.5 to 2 °C effective | Measurable thermal gain without recovery overheating |
| Cast-in-place concrete, heavy 70 mm screed | Coils embedded in slab | Setpoint maintained 24 h / 24 | Stable operating regime, maximum and continuous COP |
| Mixed brick-concrete, refurbishment | Underfloor heating on ground floor, radiators upstairs | Setback differentiated by group | Requires two independent heating curves |
| Very highly insulated building | Low-temperature underfloor heating | Maintain without lowering | Negligible night losses, recovery pointless |
When recovery optimisation is chosen on an installation with moderate inertia, the slope of the heating curve must not be artificially increased. The installer activates the adaptive anticipation function of the controller. This algorithm calculates the exact start time by combining the outdoor temperature with the room temperature measured by the pilot room sensor. Recovery is thus achieved by a progressive time advance and not by a sudden peak in the water flow temperature.
- Preparing the measuring instrumentationInstall two autonomous room temperature loggers in the reference rooms and read the thermal energy meter and the electricity meter dedicated to the compressor.
- Week 1: continuous operationLock the controls on a constant setpoint day and night for seven consecutive days. Record the degree-days and cumulative consumption daily on the dashboard.
- Week 2: operation with night setbackProgramme a setback of 1.5 °C from 22:00 to 06:00 for seven days with comparable outdoor weather conditions, reading the same meters.
- Comparative analysis and final decisionRelate the energy consumed to the actual degree-days of each period. If the weekly consumption normalised with setback is equal to or higher than in continuous operation, permanently deactivate the time programme.
This comparative measurement over two weeks gives the client an irrefutable technical justification. On a substantial thermal mass, the figures almost systematically show that the setback is neutral or costs more. Maintaining a very low water temperature, stable over 24 hours, ensures the longevity of the refrigeration unit by avoiding short cycles and condensing pressure peaks.
Practical settings: duration, setback depth and time shift
For low-temperature generators coupled to underfloor heating, the night setback is not managed like a traditional radiator circuit. The thermal inertia of the distribution slab and the time constant of the building impose a phase shift that makes any short shutdown completely invisible in the indoor temperature, while causing excess consumption on restart.
When the operator keeps a setback setpoint on underfloor heating in a 7 to 10 cm concrete slab, the requested temperature drop must not exceed 1 to 1.5 K. A more pronounced setback drains the thermal buffer of the structure without producing measurable savings on the overall balance. In addition, the time programme must include a shift of at least two to three hours relative to actual occupancy hours: the setback is switched on from 20:00 for an end of activity at 22:00, while recovery starts around 03:00 for effective thermal wake-up at 06:00.
| Type of structure | Emission system | Thermal behaviour | Recommended setpoint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cast-in-place concrete, external insulation | Wet underfloor heating | Very high inertia (constant > 40 h) | Maintain without setback or setback limited to 0.5 K |
| Timber frame, standard cement screed | Thin underfloor heating | Medium inertia (constant 15 to 25 h) | Setback of 1.0 to 1.5 K with recovery anticipated by 3 h |
| Old uninsulated building | Cast-iron or steel radiators | Low overall inertia | Setback of 2.0 to 3.0 K with night shutdown possible |
| Minergie-P / passive standard | Underfloor or ceiling heating | Dominant inertia, minimal losses | Permanent continuous operation (fixed setpoint) |
Two-week comparative measurement protocol and decision
To show the client the benefit of giving up the night setback or to set the most economical setting, the installer carries out an instrumented measurement campaign. This protocol eliminates subjective judgements and provides real data from the thermal and electrical energy meters of the boiler room.
- Choice of period and matching outdoor conditionsThe measurement is carried out in the heart of the heating season over two consecutive weeks with comparable average outdoor temperatures (ideally between 0 °C and 5 °C, without exceptional solar gains).
- Week 1: operation with programmed setbackThe controller applies the programme requested by the client (for example 21 °C from 06:00 to 22:00 and 19 °C from 22:00 to 06:00). The volume flows at the manifolds stay fixed according to the hydraulic balancing calculation.
- Week 2: continuous operation at constant setpointThe system runs 24 hours a day at a fixed setpoint temperature (20 °C or 20.5 °C to ensure the same perceived comfort). The heating curve is fine-tuned as low as possible to balance the thermal losses exactly.
- Recording the physical quantities and comparisonAt the end of each seven-day cycle, the installer records the electrical consumption of the compressor (kWh), the thermal output measured by the heat meter (kWh) and the room temperature recorded by autonomous loggers placed in two reference rooms.
Where the client insists on keeping a setback despite the measured data, the professional limits the action of the recovery optimisation algorithm. The temperature ramp-up must be limited to 0.5 K per hour on the water flow setpoint, ruling out the use of auxiliary heating stages and sparing the compressors the mechanical stress caused by repeated full-power starts in the early morning.
Resolving discomfort disputes and technical decision
When the user reports a feeling of morning cold or an abnormal electricity bill following activation of a night setback, the installer must avoid intuitive changes to the heating curve. On a high-inertia screed, raising the slope to compensate for an isolated complaint at 07:00 almost systematically leads to overheating in the afternoon, disturbing the self-regulation of the building and masking the initial control malfunction.
The approach requires a methodical diagnosis based on the control histories. Analysis of the flow temperature, water return temperature and room temperature curves identifies the exact origin of the problem: unsuitable hysteresis, insufficient time shift to absorb the phase shift of the slab, or parasitic switching on of the electric backup heater during recovery. In accordance with art. 364 CO, the contractor carries out the work with care and professional diligence; this means checking that the settings delivered faithfully match the real dynamic behaviour of the building.
- Data extractionRecord the compressor operating cycles, the running time of any backup heaters and the actual flow temperatures over the last seven days.
- Neutralising the setbackSwitch the controls to permanent comfort mode for forty-eight hours in order to isolate the thermal impact of the slab phase shift alone.
- Adjustment or removalIf keeping a fixed setpoint stabilises the indoor environment and reduces the peak power demand, formalise the abandonment of the setback in writing.
Faced with a client convinced that lowering the setpoint at night automatically saves energy, factual data are the only admissible technical argument. Presenting the two-week comparative balance, which shows the cost of a violent recovery against the stability of continuous operation at low flow temperature, allows the dispute to be closed calmly while preserving the seasonal coefficient of performance of the heat pump.
Frequently asked questions
Why does the heat pump switch on its electric elements at 06:00 despite a mild outdoor temperature?
When switching from night setback to comfort mode, the controller detects a large temperature gap between the room setpoint and the actual measurement. To make up this deficit quickly, the controller interprets this demand as an exceptional power need and activates the built-in electric backup heater. To correct this fault, bring the recovery time forward by several hours or limit by software the use of the electric backup to strictly supporting the compressor in severe cold.
How do you justify to a client keeping a continuous setpoint of 20 °C with no night setback at all?
Explain that the inertia of a 70 mm screed delays the temperature drop during the night and requires warmer flow water in the morning to reheat the concrete mass. This temporary rise in temperature strongly degrades the seasonal coefficient of performance of the heat pump. Maintaining a constant and as low as possible distribution temperature ensures linear compressor operation, protects the machine and guarantees the best overall efficiency.
What should be done if the occupants close the manifolds by hand every evening to force a temperature drop?
This reflex causes a thermal collapse of the slab, which will take six to eight hours to recover the next day. During this reheating phase, the circulators run at maximum flow and the controls make up the shortfall by ramping up inefficiently. Inform the user about the thermal phase shift specific to underfloor heating and remind them that the inertia of the building does not allow the same responsiveness as old water radiators.
What drop in indoor temperature really validates the relevance of a night setback on underfloor heating?
A night setback only offers measurable energy benefit if the room loses at least 2.5 to 3 kelvins during the shutdown period, without needing extra power to return to the setpoint. In recent buildings meeting current Swiss standards, the night heat loss rarely exceeds 1 to 1.5 kelvin. This small drop confirms that the energy saved at night is fully offset by the cost of the morning recovery, making the setback completely ineffective.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 384/1Heating installations in buildings - Heat requirements
- CO art. 364Obligations of the contractor: liability subject to the same rules as that of the employee; execution of the work in person or under personal direction; provision at his own expense of the necessary means, equipment and tools.
