Key takeaways
- An overall acoustic value with no indication of operating mode is a major source of disputes.
- The distinction between continuous airflow noise and operating noise must appear on the quote.
- On-site adjustment compensates for pressure losses but never eliminates residual noise emission.
- Any special acoustic requirement of the client requires written confirmation before the works contract is signed.
Defining the acoustic framework from the tender stage: background noise, air velocity and switching
In finishing work in French-speaking Switzerland, absolute silence does not exist in building services. Yet an end client often imagines that a new controlled mechanical ventilation system will be perfectly inaudible in bedrooms. From the preparation of the quote, the ventilation fitter must state in writing what acoustic environment the installation produces in normal operation. Without this, the client will regard every breath of air or every damper click as a workmanship defect, opening the way to payment retentions at acceptance of the work under standard SIA 118.
The tender must divide the acoustic behaviour into two distinct categories: the steady noise linked to airflow and the intermittent noise caused by changes of state in the air network. Continuous noise corresponds to the operation of the fan units and the passage of the air stream through rigid ducts, sound attenuators and supply diffusers. Conversely, switching noise results from occasional motorised components: opening of a pressure relief damper, reversal of a bypass damper for night cooling, or a flow change triggered by a CO2 air quality sensor.
| Type of noise | Main airflow source | Perception by the occupant | Preventive measure in the tender |
|---|---|---|---|
| Continuous (air flow) | Supply fan and air friction in the ducts | Linear, broadband hum at the diffusers | State the design sound level at nominal air flow rate |
| Mechanical transient | Travel of an actuator on a zone damper or control damper | Slight whistle or brief click on restart | Contractually exclude total inaudibility during operating movements |
| Residual pressure | Excessive throttling of a poorly positioned terminal outlet | High-pitched whistling localised at the diffusion cone | Remind that a balanced network upstream is necessary |
Setting the real limits of adjustment and recording the agreement in writing
Aeraulic balancing of a supply or extract network cannot correct an unfavourable design or an architectural space that is too tight. When the velocity in a duct exceeds 3 metres per second in the immediate vicinity of a noble room, manual adjustment of a throttling damper converts pressure energy into whistling noise. It is therefore essential to warn the client that setting the promised flow rates at commissioning can never lower the sound level below the physical limits of the baffle silencers or circular attenuators specified in the execution documents.
- Inserting the standard acoustic clauseAdd to the quote a sentence specifying that the sound levels stated apply to the nominal hygienic air flow rates, with doors and windows closed, excluding programmed boost ventilation cycles or forced kitchen extraction.
- Detailing normal residual noisesNotify in writing that the noise of electrical relays in the air handling unit, the slight crackling of electronically commutated motors and air noise at the terminals are inherent to the operation of the system.
- Flagging ducting constraintsIf the architect imposes narrow passages that force the use of reduced-diameter ducts, send without delay a written notice flagging the mechanical increase in pressure losses and in the airflow noise generated.
Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, if another circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences. In the ventilation trade, placing a double-flow monobloc air unit against the party wall of a bedroom without a technical lobby is precisely such a critical circumstance. The written duty to notify, sent before ordering the equipment and installing the flexible connectors, relieves the installer of responsibility for acoustic coupling with lightweight partitions.
Drafting the technical tender: formalising the acoustic commitment and its boundaries
In finishing work in French-speaking Switzerland, the gap between the sound level a client expects and the reality of an air distribution system is the first reason for complaints at handover. For the ventilation fitter, leaving an acoustic expectation without a written definition amounts to accepting in advance that it will be classed as a defect in the work under the Code of Obligations. A CFC 244 technical tender must never be limited to naming a make of air handling unit with an overall flow rate in cubic metres per hour. It must include an acoustic precision clause setting out what the installation guarantees continuously and what it generates during transient sequences.
The tender must state explicitly the physical distinction between the stabilised continuous mode and switching noise. The first corresponds to the regular mechanical air sweep at the calculated nominal flow rate, damped by the splitter or circular silencers sized upstream of the diffusers. The second covers the transients inherent to the control systems: motorised opening of an on/off zone damper, the click of a non-return damper under a variation of static pressure, or a forced ventilation pulse triggered by a humidity sensor in a wet room. A terminal silencer attenuates the linear spectrum of the air passage, but it does not eliminate the airflow shock wave linked to the sudden switching of a motorised damper.
| Nature of the air noise | Origin in the CFC 244 network | Possible contractual commitment | Technical limit not guaranteed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Continuous air flow in a noble room | Turbulence at the diffusion cone and noise radiated by the duct | Controlled sound level at base nominal flow rate | Total silence or inaudibility in an unfurnished room |
| Speed transition (forced operation) | Fan run-up and pressure rise | Attenuation ceiling defined for maximum flow rate | Equivalence of noise between reduced speed and high speed |
| Impact or damper noise | Travel of an actuator or switching of a pressure relief damper | Positioning away from adjoining lightweight partitions | Complete disappearance of the dry noise of the mechanical end stop |
| Throttling whistle | Excessive pressure loss on a closed control damper | Aeraulic balancing limiting the differential pressure | Compensation for insufficient cross-section in the downstream network |
Balancing limits and evidence protocols in the face of disputes
After a few nights of occupation, the end client frequently demands that the sound level of a diffuser be lowered by a simple turn of the dial on the collar or by limiting the frequency converter. The installer must set out in writing the technical limits of the adjustment promised. Aeraulic balancing of a ventilation network obeys the laws of conservation of mass. Unilaterally reducing the rotation speed below a minimum threshold causes aerodynamic stall of the free-running fan impeller, generates low-frequency resonances in the rigid ducts and prevents the hygienic air sweep of the dwelling. Likewise, throttling a supply valve to silence the air pushes the pressure back to neighbouring rooms, creating a high-pitched whistle at the adjacent diffusers.
Art. 1 CO provides that a contract is concluded when the parties have mutually and consistently expressed their intention. When the fitter records the operating ranges of balancing from the outset, the client can no longer claim afterwards that the residual whisper of the installation amounts to a breach of contract.
- 1. Joint inspection record of the surfaces at commissioningRecord the condition of the rooms at the time of the airflow tests. If the floor is a bare screed without parquet and the walls have no absorbent elements, note in the record that the reverberation of the room artificially increases the perceived noise.
- 2. Simultaneous measurement of flow rate and dynamic pressureRecord the actual volumetric air flow at the measuring cone or Pitot tube on each diffuser, against the mechanical opening position of the control damper.
- 3. Recording of background noise with the machine stoppedMeasure the residual background noise of the building with the air handling unit switched off at the isolator to demonstrate the impact of outside noise or of structure-borne transmission unrelated to the network.
- 4. Signing the acoustic balancing recordHave the test sheet countersigned by the project manager or the owner, confirming that the contractual air change rates are reached without abnormal throttling of the terminals.
Art. 365 CO provides that if a circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences. Applying this principle to ventilation installation means notifying site management without delay of any absence of a floating screed under the air handling unit, any direct penetration without a flexible sleeve or any insufficiently thick lining partition prescribed by the design, so as to relieve the ventilation installer of responsibility for any structure-borne transmission induced by the structural work.
Handling acoustic disputes and crisis protocol after installation
When the occupant contests the sound level after commissioning, the first step is to compare the complaint with the contract documents. The installer retrieves the countersigned tender and the acoustic notice sent before the works. This document is authoritative: it establishes the guaranteed continuous sound level for the base flow rate, while excluding absolute silence during peak forced modes or mechanical switching. Without this prior written record, the client's subjective expectation automatically becomes a presumption of defect under the rules of standard SIA 118.
- Characterising the nature of the nuisanceRun the installation in the presence of the client to identify whether it is continuous air-supply noise or discontinuous damper switching noise.
- Measuring with a class 1 sound level meterPlace the instrument in the centre of the receiving room, with doors and windows closed, then record the sound pressure level in dB(A) in accordance with standard SIA 181.
- Checking the aeraulic operating pointsCheck the air velocity at the measuring cone, the pressure loss at the diffusers and the position of the balancing dampers on the network.
If the measured level complies with the values agreed in the tender but the nuisance persists, the installer has reached the contractual limit of the adjustment promised. Aeraulic balancing cannot absorb an unforeseen personal sensitivity without degrading the minimum hygienic flow rates. Any additional corrective work, such as adding a baffle sound trap, replacing diffusers with models having a larger free cross-section or acoustic lining of the plenums, must then be the subject of a priced written addendum. Conversely, if the measurement reveals a whistle caused by a damper pinched excessively to compensate for a poorly calibrated network, the readjustment and balancing of the pressure losses is entirely the responsibility of the ventilation company.
Frequently asked questions
How can the increase in noise during extraction in the kitchen or bathroom be justified in the tender?
The tender must formally distinguish continuous noise in normal operation from the intermittent noise of boost ventilation. State explicitly that switching to peak speed removes humidity and odours but generates a temporary rise in noise. This contractual wording prevents the occupant from mistaking the drone of a forced switch-over for a malfunction of the air control.
What should be said to a client demanding a totally inaudible installation in a bedroom?
Absolute silence does not exist in mechanical ventilation. Remind the client in writing that any movement of air creates residual friction and that the target values meet the requirements of standard SIA 181 for night-time rest. If the client maintains the demand, provide from the outset for grille velocities below two metres per second and additional silencers with an appropriate quote.
Is the acoustic acceptance measurement valid in a completely empty room?
A bare room without curtains or furniture has excessive reverberation that distorts perception and artificially raises the measured level. Standard SIA 181 requires the raw measurement to be corrected according to the reverberation time of the room to restore the reference absorption. Record this condition in the record to rule out any dispute based on listening in an unfitted space.
Who bears the cost of adding a silencer requested afterwards by the client?
If the sound level measured on the construction site remains compliant with the commitments of the initial tender and with Swiss standard thresholds, the installation is deemed free of defects. The addition of a secondary silencer is a change to the order requested by the client. The costs of supply, duct connection and additional labour are therefore invoiced to the client in full by addendum.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work and handling of defects in the work
- norme SIA 181Protection against noise in buildings and limit values for technical installations
