Key takeaways
- SIA 181 sets the requirements applicable to continuous noise from indoor building services installations.
- The nominal airflow mode must be recorded in writing and stabilised before the sound level meter is switched on.
- Excessive background noise distorts the result and requires a correction or a postponement.
- The joint record signed on site protects the installer against disputes relating to subsequent finishing work.
Define the test mode and lock down the condition of the room before measuring
Carrying out a sound level check on an installation that has not stabilised exposes the contractor to unjustified reservations. Too often, the site management demands a reading while the building is still open to the elements or the balancing of the networks has not been locked. For the procedure to be unassailable at handover, the airflow parameters and the physical conditions of the rooms where noise is emitted must be fixed contractually.
The agreed measurement mode must correspond to the maximum operating point foreseen for standard use of the room. It is prohibited to throttle airflows or reduce motor speeds without the knowledge of the site management, on pain of invalidity of the acceptance under the Code of Obligations (CO). Likewise, the agent cannot demand an acoustic measurement while the air-handling unit is running in emergency smoke-extraction mode, unless explicitly stipulated in the tender.
- Checking airflows at the outlets with a calibrated measuring hood before any acoustic work.
- Locking of motorised dampers and VAV controllers in the nominal occupancy position.
- Strict closure of all windows, landing doors and access lobbies of the test zone.
- Checking that interior finishes are complete (screed poured, partitions closed, suspended ceilings installed).
Check the residual noise and draw up the joint record
The measuring instrument must be a class 1 integrating sound level meter, fitted with its wind screen and checked with an acoustic calibrator before and after each series of tests. Taking the equipment out without checking the immediate sound environment is a waste of time. The residual background noise of the neighbourhood or the construction site frequently masks the share actually attributable to the air-handling network.
| Difference (installation running - switched off) | Validity of the measurement | Correction to apply to the raw result |
|---|---|---|
| Greater than 10 dB(A) | Fully usable measurement | No correction (negligible influence) |
| Between 6 and 10 dB(A) | Usable measurement with calculation | Deduction of 1 to 2 dB(A) according to chart |
| Between 3 and 5 dB(A) | Indicative measurement only | Maximum deduction of 3 dB(A), high uncertainty |
| Less than 3 dB(A) | Measurement not admissible | Stop the reading, residual noise dominant |
Art. 367 CO provides that the client must check the condition of the work as soon as is practicable in the ordinary course of business. In ventilation, this obligation translates into organising a joint session on site. If the client's acoustician acts alone, the installer is exposed to late disputes based on readings distorted by temporary outside traffic or finishing work on the floor above.
- Recording of full shutdownSwitch off the ventilation system and measure the residual sound level in the room over a representative period in order to fix the background noise.
- Bringing to stabilised operationStart the air-handling unit at the contractual setpoints and wait at least ten minutes to stabilise the pressure in the ducts.
- Acoustic acquisitionMeasure the sound spectrum at the points prescribed by SIA 181, with the microphone aimed at the diffusers without standing in the direct axis of the air jet.
- Drawing up and signing the recordComplete the record on the spot, stating the sound level meter reference, the operating mode and the background noise, and obtain the signatures of the parties.
On-site acoustic metrology: measurement chain and corrections according to SIA 181
Acoustic instrumentation tolerates no approximation on the construction site. The acceptance reading requires an approved class 1 integrating sound level meter, equipped with octave-band and third-octave-band filters covering the range from 63 Hz to 4000 Hz. Before and after each campaign, the operator checks the sensitivity of the chain with a class 1 calibrator. The drift observed must not exceed 0.3 dB; otherwise the measurements are void and must be repeated. Fine spectral analysis by third octaves makes it possible to isolate specific tonal noises, such as the whistling of a throttled balancing damper or the humming linked to the fan blade-passing frequency.
The positioning of the microphone strictly follows the geometric rules defined by SIA 181. The sensor is mounted on a tripod fitted with an anti-vibration mount, at a height between 1.20 m and 1.50 m above the finished floor. It must be more than 0.50 m from walls and heavy furniture, and more than 1.00 m from corners where low-frequency standing waves accumulate. The technician never places the microphone directly in the airstream of a supply outlet. Even protected by a foam wind screen, the dynamic pressure of the air would generate turbulence noise that completely distorts the measurement of the diffuse sound field.
| Measured difference (total noise - residual noise) | Correction applied to the total level | Validity of the on-site reading |
|---|---|---|
| Less than 3 dB(A) | No correction permitted | Measurement not admissible (background noise too disruptive) |
| 3 to 5 dB(A) | -3 dB(A) | Usable measurement after flat-rate deduction |
| 6 to 9 dB(A) | -1 to -2 dB(A) | Usable measurement with precise logarithmic correction |
| 10 dB(A) or more | 0 dB(A) | Valid measurement without correction (residual noise negligible) |
The contractual requirements derived from SIA 181 are expressed as a standardised sound level of the building services installation. The raw value measured in dB(A) with the sound level meter must necessarily be corrected according to the equivalent sound absorption of the room. In a shell room with no partitions, textile coverings or furniture, the reverberation time is abnormally long compared with the reference value of 0.5 second used for living rooms. Without this normalisation bringing the sound level back to the furnished reference room, the installer would be blamed for something attributable solely to the reverberation of the bare walls.
Locking the test mode and validating the joint record
Measuring an installation running at low speed or regulated by automatic controls produces a misleading and void result. Before switching on the sound level meter, the parties set down in writing the agreed measurement mode. On air-handling units controlled by frequency converters, the control by CO2, humidity or presence sensors must be deactivated. The supply and extract fans are locked at 100% of their nominal design airflow. The motorised mixing dampers and variable-airflow control boxes are locked in the test position. Airflow and static pressure measurements are carried out beforehand to prove that the network is running at the design conditions.
Signing the joint record on the spot gives the technical check its full legal value. If a dispute arises during the inspection of the work, art. 367 para. 2 CO provides that each party may request an examination by experts. The signed document will then serve as evidence to settle the dispute. Where an actual exceedance is found, this joint reading makes it possible to undertake the necessary corrective measures without dispute over the test conditions: reworking of flexible connectors, adding acoustic attenuators or rebalancing the airflow of a noisy section.
- Measurement chain: make, model, serial numbers of the sound level meter and the calibrator, with the date of the calibration certificate.
- Air-handling parameters: fan frequencies, measured supply and extract airflows, and the fixed position of the adjustment dampers.
- Room conditions: plan of the measurement points, microphone height, checked closure of openings and furnishing state.
- Numerical results: residual background noise level, total level in operation, third-octave spectra and signatures of all parties.
Procedure in case of acoustic non-conformity and settlement of the dispute
When a sound level exceedance appears during the joint check, the professional reflex is to rigorously verify the methodology before considering a costly rework of the duct network. An acceptance record is never validated on a mere finding of failure: the installer requires the full recording of the test conditions, including the fan setpoint, the actual static pressure, the airflows measured at the diffusers and the residual noise level captured with the installation switched off. In application of the requirements of SIA 181, any measurement carried out under outside disturbances or in a room with uncorrected bare acoustics justifies the immediate entry of detailed reservations within the framework of SIA 118.
- Investigating airborne and structure-borne causesThe team leader checks the balancing of the network: a balancing damper closed too far upstream of a diffuser generates a violent localised whistling. He also inspects the duct hangers, the decoupling connectors of the air-handling unit and the partition penetrations in order to eliminate any rigid sound bridge transmitting structure-borne vibrations to the walls of the room.
- Formal notification and calling in the acousticianIf the contractual acoustic requirements are not met although the installation complies with the tender drawings, the ventilation contractor has the dispute recorded on the joint form. The agent or the client then appoints an independent acoustician to measure the actual absorption of the room and to determine whether it is a design error by the engineer or an execution defect on the construction site.
- Remediation plan and new acceptanceThe corrective actions agreed between the parties are carried out: readjusting the overall airflows to lower the air velocity in the duct, fitting a secondary sound trap, inserting anti-vibration mounts under the frames or replacing the grilles. A second joint measurement protocol is then carried out under the initial terms previously recorded.
Frequently asked questions
Who must attend the acoustic acceptance measurement?
The measurement requires the joint presence of the ventilation technician responsible for commissioning, the site manager and the site management representing the client. If the contract so prescribes, the project acoustician directs the readings. Carrying out these measurements unilaterally deprives the operation of its joint nature under SIA 118. Each participant initials the measurement sheet as soon as the readings are complete in order to validate the operating conditions.
How should the acoustic measurement be corrected if the room is completely empty?
SIA 181 requires the sound pressure level to be normalised according to the reverberation time of the room or its equivalent absorption area. In a shell room without furniture or carpets, the echo increases the perceived level. The acoustician measures the sound decay using a calibrated source, then applies the required correction term. Without this mathematical normalisation, the record cannot serve as a legal basis for establishing a non-conformity.
What should be done when neighbourhood background noise disturbs the sound level meter?
If the outside residual noise exceeds the threshold set relative to the noise of the installation, the measurement becomes unusable. The team must stop the fans to measure this ambient noise precisely, with windows closed. If the difference between the installation running and switched off is insufficient, the joint tests should be postponed to a quieter time slot, generally in the evening or at the weekend, to guarantee the metrological validity of the acceptance of the work.
Why does an over-throttled balancing damper distort the acceptance?
A balancing damper closed beyond air-handling tolerances to compensate for a poorly balanced network generates strong turbulence and a direct whistling noise at the diffuser. This balancing error carries regenerated noises that the silencers located upstream cannot stop. Before blaming the overall acoustic design, consistent pressure losses must be restored, the overall fan speed readjusted at the frequency converter and the terminal dampers reopened.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 181Noise protection in buildings: requirements and acoustic testing methods
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work: inspection of the work and notification of defects
