Key takeaways
- Permanent ventilation at maximum speed generates prohibitive and entirely unjustified electricity costs.
- The base flow rate ensures continuous air sweeping, while the peak flow rate removes critical emissions.
- Electrochemical carbon monoxide sensors control the variable-speed drives according to progressive concentration thresholds.
- The interlock test with calibration gas remains mandatory in order to record compliance in the acceptance report.
Definition of airflow modes and control of energy consumption
Running the extraction of an underground car park continuously at its maximum flow rate makes no economic or energy sense. On a shared installation of several dozen parking spaces, smoke-extraction or mechanical ventilation motors draw a considerable continuous electrical power if no staging is implemented. To meet hygiene and safety requirements without penalising the building's operating costs, the airflow design relies on dual-mode control as prescribed by standard SIA 382/1.
- Base air change rate
- Volume of fresh air supplied or extracted mechanically per hour and per square metre of parking area in the absence of traffic peaks, preventing the stratification of residual pollutants and keeping the room under controlled negative pressure.
The airflow of an underground garage is built around two strictly calibrated modes: the base flow rate and the peak flow rate. The base flow rate ensures background sweeping, eliminating fuel odours, residual humidity and the low emissions produced by isolated vehicle movements. It commonly corresponds to an air change value between 1.5 and 3 m³/(h·m²), depending on the geometric configuration of the slab and the clear height under the slab. As soon as traffic increases, this flow rate becomes insufficient to dilute the combustion gases.
| Operating mode | Trigger criterion | Indicative sweeping rate | Airflow behaviour |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base flow rate | Weekly timer or low CO threshold | 1.5 to 3.0 m³/(h·m²) | Reduced speed on EC fan or variable-speed drive |
| Peak flow rate | First CO threshold exceeded (30 ppm) | 6.0 to 12.0 m³/(h·m²) | Full speed of the extraction motor-fans |
| Alert mode | Prolonged exceedance of the high threshold (60 ppm) | Maximum peak flow rate | Forced hold and illuminated prohibition signage |
Switching to the peak flow rate multiplies the volume of air moved by a factor of three to four. The extraction fan, driven by a frequency converter or fitted with an electronically commutated motor, goes from its low speed to its rated speed. In application of art. 33 OTConst, the ambient air at workstations and in accessible areas must comply with the limit values for the concentration of harmful substances. This sustained mode remains active until the measured concentration has fallen back below a predefined hysteresis threshold, avoiding short start-up cycles of the motor-fan units.
Positioning of carbon monoxide detection and interlock test protocol
- Checking the physical connectionsCheck the wiring of the 4-20 mA measuring loop between the detection heads and the mechanical ventilation control panel, without interfering with the building management bus.
- Application of calibration gasInject a calibrated test gas using a calibration cup placed over the sensing chamber of the probe, to simulate a rise in CO content.
- Observation of the airflow changeoverCheck the controller's response as soon as the 30 ppm threshold is reached: effective switching of the frequency converter from low to high extraction speed.
- Validation of the time delayMeasure the time the peak flow rate is held after the calibration gas has disappeared and make sure there is no hunting on the air dampers.
- Drafting the test reportRecord the measured concentrations, the airflow response times and the differential pressures in the self-inspection register of the ventilation package.
The documented interlock test is the key item of the as-built file for the ventilation systems contractor. It proves that the drive chain responds faithfully to the control signals sent by the air-quality transmitters. This systematic protocol releases the installer from liability before the installation is handed over to the site management.
Flow rate sizing and control sequence according to standard SIA 382/1
Permanent operation of a smoke-extraction or air-renewal installation in an underground car park at maximum power generates disproportionate energy expenditure and premature wear of the motor-fan units. In Swiss construction, standard SIA 382/1 governs the requirements for mechanical ventilation by clearly distinguishing two operating modes: the base flow rate, intended to maintain a minimum sweep to dilute humidity and residual emissions when there is no traffic, and the peak flow rate, activated as soon as sustained traffic producing carbon monoxide appears.
The base mode generally corresponds to one third or one half of the calculated nominal flow rate, depending on the specifications of the airflow concept validated by the design office. This floor flow rate ensures sufficient air velocity in the duct network to prevent dust from settling and to guarantee constant negative pressure in the car park relative to the stairwells and the access lobbies to the dwellings. As soon as a vehicle manoeuvres or a queue forms on the access ramp, the concentration of pollutants rises rapidly, requiring a switch to the peak mode.
| Airflow mode | Indicative flow rate | CO detection setpoint | Behaviour of the airflow components |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standby / Base flow rate | 30% to 50% of the maximum flow rate | Below 30 ppm | Fans at reduced frequency, fresh-air and exhaust dampers in a regulated intermediate position. |
| Extraction / Peak flow rate | 100% of the nominal flow rate | Threshold exceeded at 30 ppm (time average) | Progressive acceleration via frequency converter, motorised dampers fully open. |
| Safety alert | 100% of the nominal flow rate | Critical threshold exceeded at 50 ppm instantaneous | Forced hold at full speed, fault signal to the control panel and cancellation of the shutdown time delay. |
To ensure a transition without airflow shock in the circular or rectangular galvanised sheet-metal duct network, the motor control uses frequency converters. The acceleration ramp setting must be calibrated between 15 and 30 seconds: a speed increase that is too abrupt creates a pressure-drop wave liable to slam the non-return dampers violently and to deform the panels of large ducts lacking adequate stiffeners.
Interlock test protocol, calibration and acceptance of the installation
Mechanical interlocking relies on the transfer of the signal emitted by the carbon monoxide probes distributed throughout the garage volume. Although the internal configuration of the communication buses is the responsibility of the switchboard electricians, the ventilation systems contractor is directly responsible for the airflow response of the installation. It is their duty to check that every dry contact or analogue signal from the detection control unit triggers the prescribed flow rate sequence without abnormal delay.
- Visual and mechanical check of the motorised dampersCheck the alignment of the linkages and the free travel of the fresh-air and extraction dampers before any energising of the actuators, in order to rule out any mechanical blockage under the effect of the airflow.
- Stimulation of the sensors with calibration gasFit a sealed calibration cell over the head of the most remote probe and inject a certified test gas mixture dosed at 50 ppm of carbon monoxide to simulate a pollution peak.
- Timing of the changeover sequenceMeasure the time elapsed between the threshold being crossed at the sensor, the control command and the extraction fan actually reaching its nominal rotational speed.
- Check of air velocities and negative pressureUsing a hot-wire anemometer or a Pitot tube, record the total flow rate extracted on the main duct in peak mode and confirm that an airflow directed towards the extraction grilles is maintained.
- Check of hysteresis and return to normalStop the gas injection, observe the hold time delay at high speed (generally 10 to 15 minutes after returning below 30 ppm) and check the stable return to the base flow rate.
All of these operations result in a joint airflow test report, signed together with the site management and the person responsible for electrical commissioning. This document records the flow rates measured at each speed, the dynamic pressures at the discharge, the response times of each detection zone and the confirmation of the calibration of the detection cells. This test file is an indispensable item at handover to prove the full compliance of the ventilation with the requirements for health and air hygiene.
CO interlock malfunctions and flow rate drifts: remedial measures
On underground garage construction sites, mechanical ventilation faults often appear during final adjustments: an installation stuck in permanent peak flow rate or, conversely, no reaction of the extractors when the gas concentration rises. Continuous operation at maximum speed generates excessive operating costs and premature mechanical wear of the motors, whereas a failure to switch on compromises the breathing safety of users. Art. 33 OTConst provides that the ambient air at workstations must contain between 19 and 21% oxygen by volume and that the limit values for hazardous substances must not be exceeded.
- Isolating the setpoint signalMeasure the analogue loop coming from the carbon monoxide detection control unit. A broken loop or a short circuit generally triggers a safety fallback forcing the frequency converters to 100%. Validate the transmission of the intermediate step and of the alarm threshold.
- Airflow check of the dampersCheck the physical position of the extract and fresh-air dampers. An actuator that is uncoupled or mechanically blocked distorts the airflow distribution and prevents the volumetric flow rate prescribed for sweeping the pockets of stagnant gas from being reached.
- Injecting calibration gas on the cellsTest each detector individually using a calibrated gas kit. Replace any electrochemical cell showing a measurement drift greater than the manufacturer's tolerances or a response time too slow to trigger the peak mode.
When the measured flow rates do not match the design values calculated according to standard SIA 382/1, the ventilation fitter rebalances the network using orifice plates or by adjusting the balancing dampers, without changing the basic airflow setpoints without the written agreement of the site management. Every successful interlock test is the subject of a signed measurement report, recording the actual flow rates measured at the collars as well as the simulated concentrations that triggered the changeover of the modes. This technical document is the key item for clearing reservations during acceptance operations.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if the fan remains stuck in peak flow rate with no carbon monoxide present?
Continuous operation at peak flow rate often comes from a measuring loop fault or a fail-safe setting. If the CO control unit loses communication with a probe or if a cable is severed, the system automatically forces the maximum mode as a safety measure. The loop resistance must be checked, the absence of abnormal residual voltage verified and the alarm history on the detection control unit reviewed before any return to service.
How often must car park carbon monoxide probes be calibrated?
Electrochemical CO detection probes gradually lose their sensitivity through chemical ageing and ambient pollutants. Calibration with test gas must be carried out at least once a year by a specialist company. During this operation, the cell is recalibrated for zero and sensitivity. After three to five years of service, according to the manufacturers' instructions, the measuring head must be replaced entirely.
How can the changeover between base flow rate and peak flow rate be physically verified at acceptance?
The installer applies a calibration gas directly to the probe head using a calibration cup. As soon as the measured content crosses the prescribed threshold, the opening time of the motorised dampers and the acceleration ramp of the frequency converter are timed. An anemometer or a differential pressure measurement on the extraction fan makes it possible to confirm visually and numerically the actual switch from base flow rate to peak flow rate.
Why is the peak flow rate not reached despite a drive command at 100%?
This problem frequently results from a constriction of the airstream or an unforeseen pressure loss in the duct network. A balancing damper left closed, flexible connectors sucked in, clogged filters or a tripped fire damper increase the overall airflow resistance. The fan speeds up but the flow rate plateaus. The condition of the dampers should be checked, the available static pressure measured and the tension of the drive belts verified.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 382/1Ventilation and air-conditioning installations - General principles and required performance
- OTConst art. 33Ambient air quality and limit values for hazardous substances at workstations
