Key takeaways
- The rotary exchanger achieves 75 to 85 % thermal efficiency while transferring moisture from the extract air.
- The plate heat recovery unit provides an ideal tight physical separation against cross-contamination of air.
- Standard SIA 382/1 prohibits the wheel for professional kitchens and heavily polluted air.
- The arrangement of the fans determines the pressure cascade that prevents recirculation in the rotor.
Thermal efficiencies, enthalpy and condensate: the mechanisms compared
The choice between a heat wheel and a plate block directly determines the overall energy performance of the air handling unit and the spatial layout of its casings. The rotary exchanger can achieve, on the outdoor air, a sensible thermal effectiveness commonly between 75 % and 85 %, compared with 70 % to 80 % for a modern counter-flow plate heat recovery unit of equivalent size. The major operating difference lies in latent heat transfer. A standard aluminium wheel already transmits a fraction of moisture by surface condensation in winter, whereas a wheel fitted with an enthalpy or sorption rotor, coated with a molecular sieve, actively returns the water vapour from the extract air to the supply airflow. This passive contribution regulates the humidity of administrative offices without requiring an energy-intensive electric steam humidifier.
| Technical criterion | Rotary heat recovery unit | Plate heat recovery unit |
|---|---|---|
| Sensible thermal efficiency | 75 % to 85 % | 70 % to 80 % |
| Moisture transfer (latent) | High (up to 70 % with sorption) | None (except permeable membrane) |
| Management of winter frost | Defrosting by speed reduction | Bypass damper or preheater |
| Condensate drainage | Very rare in normal conditions | Tray and water-seal trap mandatory |
| Casing length required | Small (reduced casing width) | Large (large counter-flow casing) |
Conversely, the standard aluminium plate exchanger provides only sensible exchange: the fresh air remains dry and the moisture contained in the extract air condenses massively on the cold walls as soon as the outdoor air temperature drops below the dew point. The liquid water then runs into a lower collecting tray. On the construction site, the ventilation installer must connect this tray to a tight trap suited to the actual negative pressure in the casing, otherwise bad odours from the sanitary piping will be drawn in or the gravity drainage of the water will be physically blocked. In Swiss winter conditions, the plate block requires a rigorous anti-frost strategy: the automatic opening of a bypass damper (by-pass) or the switching on of an electric preheating coil severely reduces the seasonal efficiency of the installation, whereas the rotor adapts its rotation speed to manage frosting without interrupting recovery.
Pressure cascades, internal leakage and rooms where the wheel is prohibited
The rotary exchanger never provides absolute physical separation between the fresh air and exhaust air streams. The continuous mechanical movement of the wheel inevitably carries a residual volume of polluted air, trapped in the cells of the metal storage mass, directly into the supply air compartment. To contain this unwanted aeraulic recirculation, manufacturers incorporate a purge sector swept by clean outdoor air, combined with adjustable brush or lip seals around the casing periphery. However, the real effectiveness of this device depends entirely on the position of the fans in the unit. The supply fan must imperatively be located downstream of the wheel and the extract fan upstream, in order to keep the fresh air stream at a higher pressure than the polluted air stream. If this pressure cascade is reversed, the polluted air inevitably passes through the seals and contaminates all the rooms served.
- Professional kitchens and restaurants (ETA 4): grease aerosols and vapours irreparably clog the rotary matrix and transfer persistent odours into the supply ducts.
- Analysis laboratories and chemical handling rooms (ETA 4): the potential presence of solvent vapours or toxic substances rules out any risk of leakage into the hygienic air.
- High-traffic sanitary rooms and sports changing rooms (ETA 3): high risk of redistributing ammonia odours and excessive humidity to adjacent offices.
- Medical isolation rooms and mortuary rooms (ETA 4): absolute sanitary requirement of containment with no possibility of recirculating bacteria, germs or pathogenic particles.
In these critical configurations, only the aluminium or epoxy resin plate heat recovery unit guarantees the required physical tightness, provided a tight casing without internal leakage is used. On the construction site, the foreman ensures that the exchange block is handled without twisting, that the peripheral seal is compressed evenly on its frame and that the actual negative pressures measured with a differential manometer confirm the theoretical leakage direction foreseen in the design.
Hygroscopic transfer and enthalpy balance: sorption versus plates
The choice between a counter-flow plate exchanger and a rotary heat recovery unit is not limited to thermal efficiency on dry air. In the Swiss climate, characterised by prolonged winter periods where outdoor air has a very low absolute humidity, enthalpy management becomes decisive. A standard aluminium plate exchanger provides only sensible transfer: the water vapour contained in the extract air condenses on the cold walls on the exhaust side, without ever rehumidifying the supplied fresh air. This condensation requires systematic connection to a drainage network via a non-return water-seal trap of calculated seal depth, while accentuating the drying out of occupied rooms, where relative humidity frequently falls below the comfort threshold of 30 %.
Conversely, the enthalpy or sorption rotary exchanger actively transfers water vapour. The matrix of a condensation wheel recovers water by simple phase change when the metal surface falls below the dew point of the extract air, then returns it to the fresh air. Sorption wheels use a molecular hygroscopic coating (silica gel or zeolite-type molecular sieve) that captures moisture without prior liquid condensation. This process makes it possible to maintain a hygienic humidity level in the building without using an electric or steam humidification unit, which is very energy-intensive. In summer, the mechanism is reversed: the wheel dehumidifies the hot, heavy air before it enters the cooling coil, reducing the thermal load on the refrigeration units.
For plate exchangers, the enthalpy alternative relies on semi-permeable polymer membranes with a dense structure. These membranes allow water vapour to diffuse through partial pressure difference while blocking the physical passage of gases, bacteria and solid particles. While this solution eliminates the risk of mechanical carry-over inherent to motorised rotors, its moisture recovery efficiency generally peaks at around 55 to 60 %, compared with over 75 % for an optimised zeolite rotor, and its resistance to repeated freeze-thaw cycles at altitude requires rigorous monitoring of the differential pressures on either side of the membrane.
Decision matrix and room types subject to strict exclusion
Standard SIA 382/1 strictly structures the choice of energy recovery systems according to the quality of the extract air (categories ETA 1 to ETA 4). The fundamental principle requires that the fresh air carrier (SUP) receives no unacceptable contamination from the polluted air. Although a rotary heat recovery unit offers higher dry thermal efficiency (often 78 to 85 % compared with 72 to 80 % for counter-flow plates) and a significantly shorter axial footprint that eases installation in a boiler room or on a roof, its intrinsic porosity and the risk of leakage at the peripheral seals rule out its use in several operating profiles.
| Selection criterion | Standard rotary exchanger | Sorption rotary exchanger | Counter-flow plates | Enthalpy plates |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sensible thermal efficiency | 75 to 85 % | 75 to 82 % | 75 to 85 % | 70 to 78 % |
| Moisture transfer | Low (condensation only) | High (65 to 80 %) | None | Medium (50 to 65 %) |
| Pollutant transfer risk | Moderate (leakage and carry-over) | High (molecular adsorption) | None (physical separation) | None to negligible |
| Extract air classes permitted (SIA 382/1) | ETA 1 and ETA 2 only | ETA 1 only | ETA 1, ETA 2, ETA 3, ETA 4 | ETA 1 and ETA 2 |
| On-site mechanical maintenance | Belt, motor, sealing brushes | Belt, motor, sealing brushes | None (static, periodic washing) | Low (gentle rinsing, tightness check) |
Rooms classified ETA 3 (heavily polluted air: high-traffic communal sanitary rooms, catering kitchens, sports changing rooms, waste storage areas, printing workshops) and ETA 4 (air containing toxic, harmful or explosive substances: chemistry laboratory fume cupboards, battery charging rooms, dry-cleaning premises, solvent rooms) are formally excluded from the rotary system within the meaning of standard SIA 382/1. Even with a purge sector set to the millimetre and fans arranged to keep the fresh air at overpressure, the transfer of residual volume trapped in the wheel cells is unavoidable during rotation. In these configurations, the installer must fit a tight plate exchanger or move the recovery to an intermediate-fluid circuit with separate coils.
- Professional kitchens and food laboratories: greasy vapours and oil residues irreversibly clog the fine flutes of the rotary wheel, making washing impossible and creating a combustible load prohibited by fire protection directives.
- Operating theatres, isolation rooms and clean rooms: microbial or particulate cross-contamination is strictly prohibited; only a complete separation of the airflows by tight plates or by glycol-liquid circulation exchangers is tolerated.
- High-density sanitary facilities and communal shower rooms: the transfer of odours and saturated vapour to offices or school classrooms rules out the sorption rotary unit in favour of standard plates fitted with a stainless steel condensate tray.
- Chemical storage rooms and industrial workshops: corrosive fumes damage the zeolite film and the mechanical drive bearings of the rotary drum.
Remediation on the construction site: managing contamination and aeraulic non-conformities
On the construction site, the discovery of exhaust, solvent or kitchen odours at the supply outlets signals an internal seal failure or an unsuitable choice of exchanger. In a balanced-ventilation installation compliant with standard SIA 382/1, polluted air laden with harmful or foul-smelling substances must never contaminate the hygienic fresh air. If an AHU fitted with a rotary heat recovery unit has been connected by mistake to rooms producing critical pollutants, the installer must intervene methodically to identify the transfer path and correct the installation before any final commissioning.
- Checking the pressure cascadesMeasure with a differential manometer the pressure difference between the extract air casing and the supply air casing at the wheel. The supply side must imperatively show a relative overpressure compared with the extract side. If the extract fan is placed downstream of the exchanger and puts the extract side at overpressure, leaks at the sealing brushes pass directly into the fresh air.
- Adjusting the purge sector and the sealsCheck the geometric alignment of the purge sector. Adjust the peripheral brushes and lips to reduce the clearance below the value prescribed by the AHU manufacturer. Clean off greasy deposits that block the scraper profiles and disturb rotation.
- Protective measure and written notificationWhen the nature of the effluents falls into categories incompatible with recirculation, simply adjusting the purge no longer guarantees air quality. In accordance with art. 365 para. 3 CO, the contractor informs the client when a circumstance compromises the proper execution of the work. Stopping the rotor drive is then the first protective measure to cut the mass transfer of polluted air, pending requalification of the unit with a tight plate exchanger.
Switching to a plate exchanger often requires recalculating the pressure losses on the duct network and checking the gravity flow of the condensate tray. This work ensures absolute physical tightness between the airstreams, guaranteeing compliance with hygiene requirements and acceptance of the installation by the site management.
Frequently asked questions
Can an odour transfer be corrected simply by reversing the fans on the AHU?
Moving the supply fan downstream of the wheel creates an overpressure on the fresh air side, which limits leakage at the seals towards the supply and activates the purge sector. However, this arrangement never eliminates the transfer of air trapped in the rotating cells, nor the adsorption of volatile compounds on the matrix. For heavily polluted rooms, this aeraulic modification remains insufficient and does not comply with hygiene requirements.
How do you check the tightness and leakage rate of a rotary heat recovery unit on site?
The check is carried out using the tracer gas method or by calculating the internal extract air leakage rate from flow measurements and static differential pressures. The installer records the pressure between each compartment of the AHU with a micromanometer. If the negative pressure on the extract side draws air towards the supply despite the purge sector, the peripheral seals must be readjusted or replaced.
Why do laundries and sports changing rooms often require the plate exchanger?
The extract air from these rooms contains very high relative humidity and persistent body odours. A recovery wheel, especially of the enthalpy or sorption type, transfers part of the moisture and odorous molecules to the supplied fresh air. The plate exchanger ensures complete physical separation of the airstreams. It prevents the redistribution of odours while allowing the safe drainage of the abundant condensate through its dedicated trap.
How does a wheel behave in frost compared with a plate exchanger?
The rotary wheel naturally resists frost better, because each sector of the matrix turns continuously between the warm extract air and the cold fresh air, which delays ice formation down to very low outdoor temperatures. Conversely, the plate exchanger requires an early active anti-frost strategy, such as air preheating or an automatic bypass damper, to prevent immediate clogging of the channels by frozen condensate.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 382/1Ventilation and air-conditioning installations - General principles and performance
- CO art. 365Material and ground: the contractor is liable for the good quality of the material he supplies; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by him is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, he must inform the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3)
