Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 244Smoke extraction and fire dampersChapter 6 of 10 in the section

Do not connect compartments: fire-stopping at each floor and common riser

This chapter details the vertical fire-stopping obligations for air-handling networks passing through several floors. You will be able to identify the compartmentation break points required by the VKF/AEAI fire protection regulations, choose between fire dampers and ducts with their own fire resistance, and carry out an approved fire-stopping seal ensuring tightness against smoke and hot gases where ducts pass through slabs.

Key takeaways

  • A common riser without a fire-stopping device links the apartments and destroys the compartmentation of the building.
  • The VKF/AEAI fire protection regulations require a fire resistance equivalent to that of the slab being passed through.
  • The choice between an individual damper and a fire-resistant shaft depends on access for maintenance.
  • Every annular seal must strictly comply with the equipment manufacturer's VKF/AEAI conformity certificate.

Heat transmission through vertical shafts and VKF/AEAI compartmentation rules

In multi-occupancy housing, each dwelling is an independent fire compartment designed to confine toxic smoke and flames. When a vertical ventilation collector extracts air from several levels without any isolating device, the air-handling network acts as a thermal stack drawing air upwards. In the event of a fire in a lower apartment, hot gases under pressure pass through the extraction grilles, rise in the uninsulated metal riser and enter the upper floors through a simple reversal of draught or thermal perforation of the sheet metal. The uncompartmented common riser thus cancels the physical separation intended by the fire protection concept.

The site error is to believe that the air-handling network forms a continuous protective enclosure. Conventional spiral-seam galvanised steel ductwork conducts heat within a few minutes and deforms quickly under thermal radiation, creating annular gaps in the concrete slabs. Stale air laden with acidic soot then spreads to adjacent dwellings through the floor branch connections. The VKF/AEAI fire protection regulations therefore impose two strict execution principles: installing an automatic shut-off device where the duct passes through the separation, or installing a duct with its own fire resistance with no intermediate damper on the main trunk.

Fire compartment
Volume of a building delimited by walls and floors with a standardised fire resistance, intended to prevent the spread of fire and smoke to other parts of the building for a defined period.

Floor fire damper or fire-resistant duct: implementation and justification

The choice between fitting fire dampers on each floor branch connection and building a riser with its own fire resistance depends on the geometry of the service shaft, access for maintenance and air-handling constraints.

Technical comparison of vertical fire-stopping solutions under CFC 244
Implementation criterionFire dampers on branch connectionsDuct with its own fire resistance
Spatial layoutRequires an individual damper at the compartment wallContinuous vertical section, clad or made of EI-certified boards
Access and servicingRequires a tight inspection hatch for each reset mechanismNo moving mechanical parts in the shaft; simplified maintenance checks
Sealing and fire-stoppingFull mortar fill or flexible sealing system approved by VKF/AEAI as per instructionsFire-stop collar or fire-stopping with rock wool and intumescent mastic
Acoustic constraintsEasy decoupling between main riser and terminal networkIncreased risk of direct sound transmission between levels via the common duct
  1. Checking openings and tolerancesCheck that the opening left in the concrete slab complies with the minimum annular gap prescribed by the VKF/AEAI declaration of conformity of the fire damper or fire-resistant duct.
  2. Fixing and suspension of the deviceSuspend the damper body or the protected riser from the load-bearing structure using threaded rods and clamps sized to withstand thermal loads without excessive deformation.
  3. Approved fire-stoppingFill the annular space between the duct and the concrete with non-shrink mortar or high-density mineral wool boards coated with certified ablative mastic.
  4. Shut-off check and inspection hatchesTrigger the fire blade mechanically or by motor, check the tightness of the intumescent seal and make sure the access hatch can be removed without destructive tools.

The justification of the chosen solution is based on the configuration of the building's service shafts. In heavy refurbishment with narrow shafts, fitting compliant inspection hatches is often impracticable; enclosing the riser in an EI 60 fire-resistant duct is the most rational answer. In new construction, the fire damper on the branch connection remains the preferred solution for isolating the dwelling immediately without burdening the vertical collector. Under art. 229 CP, anyone who, when managing or carrying out construction work, breaches the recognised rules of the trade and thereby endangers the life or physical integrity of persons is liable to a custodial sentence or a monetary penalty. The ventilation installer is liable for the conformity of the fire-stopping.

Compartmentation break: the trap of the common vertical riser

In multi-occupancy residential buildings in Switzerland, the fundamental principle of fire safety rests on dividing the building into separate volumes. The VKF/AEAI fire protection regulations define each dwelling as an independent fire compartment, intended to contain a fire and its smoke for at least thirty minutes. When a common balanced-ventilation or extraction riser serves several levels without fire-stopping at the slabs, the network acts as a continuous thermal chimney. Without a physical barrier, the metal ducts directly link the private spaces. A common riser that is not fire-stopped turns six separate superimposed apartments into a single thermal and air-handling compartment, neutralising the passive protection of the structural work.

A standard network of spiral-seam galvanised steel sheet has no fire resistance (EI 0). Exposed to the flames of a fire, the metal heats up by conduction and radiates intense heat towards the combustible materials of the upper floors. Thermal draught and pressure differences push carbon monoxide and hot soot back through the floor branch connections, even when the air handling unit is switched off. Fire-stopping the risers at each compartment is therefore essential: each floor penetration must restore the integrity of the fire separation so that the air distribution does not serve as a conduit for the spread of deadly gases.

Riser fire-stopping by compartment
Device preventing the passage of fire, heat and smoke along or inside a ventilation duct where it passes through a fire-rated slab, by means of dampers or a fire-resistant duct.

Floor dampers or duct with its own fire resistance: justifying the technical choice

To neutralise this risk of vertical connection, the ventilation installer applies two methods provided for by the VKF/AEAI fire protection regulations. The first variant uses a spiral-seam galvanised sheet riser fitted with a motorised fire damper, or one with a thermal release, at each slab penetration or at the entrance of each dwelling. The second variant uses a duct with its own fire resistance, built from calcium silicate boards or integrated into a masonry shaft classified EI 30 or EI 60 from the basement to the roof outlet. The shaft itself forms a tight vertical compartment, allowing a continuous air column to be kept without inserting any moving mechanism on the main trunk.

Comparison of vertical fire-stopping solutions in a service shaft
Evaluation criterionFire dampers at each levelDuct with its own fire resistance
Space taken in the shaftSmall: standard spiral-seam sheet networkLarge: extra thickness of the fire-rated walls
Periodic maintenanceDemanding: inspection hatches and compulsory annual testNone: no mechanical parts or fusible links
Overall tightnessDepends on ageing of the damper sealsContinuous and unalterable over the whole height
Access to dwellingsIntervention required in each apartmentNo access constraint in private areas

The justification of the chosen solution is established during spatial coordination with site management. Using a floor fire damper reduces the size of the service shaft and the purchase cost of the ducts. However, this solution shifts a heavy burden onto operation: the obligation to check the thermal release periodically requires a tight inspection hatch in each dwelling. Obtaining regular access from six separate co-owners or tenants is often a real logistical deadlock. Where this constraint is judged unacceptable, a duct with its own fire resistance is the most rational solution, despite a higher initial investment in passive protection boards.

At handover inspections, the fire protection authority checks the conformity of each penetration. Art. 229 CP punishes breaches of the recognised rules of construction that endanger the lives of persons, which directly engages the liability of the teams when installing fire-stopping systems. The ventilation installer archives the inspection records, the mastic data sheets and the certificates of conformity in the project file. This rigorous traceability demonstrates that the common riser is properly fire-stopped and that no risk of smoke spreading remains between the different dwellings of the building.

Handling compartmentation non-conformities and reworking penetrations

When a common riser passes through several levels without fire-stopping, each unprotected branch connection creates a direct thermal and air-handling bridge. In the event of a fire, hot gases and toxic smoke invade the upper apartments within minutes through negative pressure or thermal draught. As soon as such a defect is discovered on the construction site, the team leader suspends the secondary air-handling connections and reports the compartmentation break in writing to site management and to the person responsible for fire quality assurance.

  1. Record the exact configuration of the openingsMeasure the actual openings around the collector duct at each slab. Check whether the free space allows the insertion of a VKF/AEAI-approved fire damper with its regulation sealing thickness, or whether the geometry requires continuous treatment of the riser.
  2. Agree the remedial option with the designerChoose between fitting terminal fire dampers at each floor or fully cladding the metal riser with a duct with its own fire resistance (silicate or special fire-resistant plaster boards). The decision depends on access to the mechanisms for future maintenance.
  3. Carry out the fire-stopping according to the declaration of conformityRefill the slab opening with non-shrink mortar, concrete or high-density rock wool board coated with ablative paste. Observe the minimum thickness and peripheral gap validated by the manufacturer's Swiss approval report.
  4. Draw up the self-inspection recordDocument each penetration and each fire-stopping device: before/after photos of the fire-stopping, serial numbers, clearly visible VKF/AEAI labels, date of installation and name of the installer.

The justification of the chosen solution is based on the VKF/AEAI fire protection regulations: if the masonry shaft does not offer the fire resistance required to house an unprotected duct, the installer must reinstate the fire separation either at each slab penetration or at the boundary of each apartment compartment. The documentation file submitted for the occupancy permit must include the installation certificates from the ventilation installer and up-to-date schematic diagrams.

Frequently asked questions

Why does a common shaft without dampers cancel the compartmentation between apartments?

Without an automatic shut-off device at each level, the ventilation shaft acts as a chimney linking rooms that are supposed to be independent. Hot gases and toxic smoke generated in one dwelling are drawn by thermal draught and pushed straight into the apartments on the upper floors. This air-handling continuity removes the effectiveness of the fire-rated concrete slabs and turns all six floors into a single volume exposed to fire.

When should a duct with its own fire resistance be preferred to floor dampers?

A duct with its own fire resistance (silicate boards or certified plaster shaft) is chosen when the space in the service shaft prevents the installation and the regulatory maintenance of floor fire dampers. This solution is ideal when the inspection hatches are inaccessible once the suspended ceilings are fitted. It guarantees the integrity of the compartmentation over the whole height of the building without using moving mechanical parts subject to periodic inspection.

Which material should be used to fill the opening around a non-fire-resistant ventilation duct?

If the duct passes through the slab without a floor damper but remains confined in a continuous fire-rated service shaft, the opening is filled with non-shrink sealing mortar or with a high-density mineral wool board under an intumescent coating. However, if the riser opens directly into a compartment, a VKF/AEAI-approved fire damper must be inserted in the slab and sealed in strict accordance with its approval, using certified mortar or mastic.

How should the chosen solution be justified and documented to the cantonal fire authority?

The ventilation installer compiles in the project file the VKF/AEAI approval sheets of the dampers or fire-resistant ducts installed. They attach the component location plan, the fire-stopping records for each slab and the signed self-inspection certificates. This technical file proves to the cantonal building inspectors that the fire separation between compartments scrupulously complies with the VKF/AEAI fire protection regulations in force.

Texts and standards cited

  • Directives de protection incendie AEAISwiss fire protection requirements applicable to air-handling installations and fire compartmentation
  • Directive sur l'assurance qualité en protection incendie AEAIRequirements for proof of conformity, execution checks and the fire safety file

In the same section