Key takeaways
- The actual operating load includes the unit's own weight, the fluids and the foreseeable clogging of the filters.
- An incorrectly loaded anti-vibration mount changes its natural frequency and passes vibrations directly to the building.
- A textile connector fitted too taut short-circuits the decoupling and carries the vibration energy into the metal duct network.
- Wall penetrations require a resilient seal with no rigid point of contact between duct and masonry.
Calculating the actual operating load and shimming the anti-vibration mounts under the frame
To meet the noise limit values in sensitive rooms under SIA 181, the anti-vibration isolation of the monobloc unit must be treated as a global dynamic system. The most common mistake on the construction site is to select mounts on the basis of the empty weight alone, as stated on the manufacturer's data sheet. In operation, the mass distribution becomes strongly asymmetrical: the motor-fan unit concentrates a heavy mass on a small area, while the heat recovery and heat exchange coils add the volume of heat-transfer fluid and retained condensate. The build-up of dust in the filters at the end of the cycle also increases the total mass on board.
- Natural frequency of the suspended system
- Free oscillation frequency of the unit on its anti-vibration supports. To ensure effective attenuation, it must be clearly lower than the minimum disturbing frequency generated by the fan rotation speed.
The choice of isolator type depends directly on the fan rotation frequency and on the flexibility of the supporting slab. Helical steel spring mounts are required for low rotation frequencies and light floors, whereas elastomer or overmoulded resilient mounts suit higher speeds on a massive raft slab. Undersizing compresses the spring until its coils touch, creating steel-on-steel contact. Conversely, oversizing leaves the mount rigid, unable to enter useful compression: in both cases the isolation efficiency collapses and the vibrations pass directly into the concrete, contrary to art. 22 OLT 3 on the prevention of noise and vibrations.
| Applied load condition | Mechanical behaviour of the mount | Consequence for sound transmission |
|---|---|---|
| Load below the nominal range | Insufficient compression, dynamic stiffness too high | No filtering, resonance possible at low frequencies |
| Nominal operating load (with fluids) | Optimum static deflection according to the manufacturer's curve | Maximum attenuation in line with the requirements of SIA 181 |
| Overload compared with the calculation | Spring bottoming out or irreversible settlement of the elastomer | Total acoustic bridge, full transmission of vibrations to the structural work |
Fitting flexible connectors without tension and decoupling the network at wall penetrations
The flexible connector placed between the discharge or intake frame of the casing and the network of rigid ducts provides the mechanical break in the system. Its acoustic function is destroyed as soon as the fabric is installed taut. Under the positive or negative static air pressure generated by the fan, the membrane stiffens if it does not have enough slack. A restrained fabric behaves mechanically like a continuous metal duct: it transmits the pressure pulsations and the micro-movements of the monobloc unit to the whole air distribution system.
- Checking the spacing of the framesCheck that the clear distance between the AHU frame and the duct flange strictly respects the recommended spacing, generally 100 to 150 millimetres, with no angular misalignment greater than two degrees.
- Fixing with visible slackBolt the connector frames while keeping a loose textile band forming a slight fold inwards or outwards, with no start of axial twisting.
- Test pressurisationStart the system at nominal flow to check that the fabric does not reach its tensile limit under the fan's maximum static pressure.
The decoupling must absolutely continue along the air duct route in the plant room. The first duct section connected to the flexible connector must have its own independent suspension supports, fitted with anti-vibration washers or elastomer hangers. No weight of the network may rest on the flexible fabric. Finally, passing through party walls and slabs is the last critical point for compliance with the criteria of SIA 181.
Compression under hydraulic load and mechanical freedom of the connectors
The full decoupling of a monobloc unit is not validated empty when it is placed on the raft slab. An air handling unit in working order carries variable masses that change the balance of the frame: hot or chilled water coils filled with their heat-transfer fluid, full condensate trays and progressive clogging of the filter cells. Anti-vibration mounts sized only for the dry mass are overloaded as soon as the system is filled with water. The spring or elastomer block then reaches its mechanical stop, turning the flexible support into a rigid connection that transmits all the structure-borne noise to the concrete slabs.
Conversely, oversizing the springs prevents the nominal static deflection calculated by the acoustician from being reached. The natural frequency of the suspension then stays too close to the rotation speed of the free-running fans, causing destructive structural resonances. Checking on the construction site consists of measuring the compression travel under each support point with a rule after the heating installer has filled the coils with water, then adjusting the levelling rods to keep the frame perfectly square with no warping of the casing.
| Finding on the casing | Mechanical origin | Acoustic consequence | Corrective measure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anti-vibration spring with coils touching | Underestimated mass of water in the coil or distorted low point | Full transmission of structure-borne noise to the technical floor | Replacement of the set of mounts according to the actual weighed load |
| Flexible connector stretched like a drumskin | Downstream duct installed too short or air thrust not compensated | Short-circuit of the vibration isolation towards the air duct network | Loosening the frame, realigning the duct and creating a slack fold |
| Connector sucked inwards into the airflow | High negative pressure at the upstream discharge without an intermediate ring | Internal turbulence, whistling and premature wear of the fabric | Fitting a reinforced fabric with built-in anti-collapse rings |
| Elastomer twisted under the base | Lag screws tightened without holding the upper plate | Lateral dynamic stiffening and loss of attenuation efficiency | Loosening, returning to the neutral axis and locking the lock nut |
The behaviour of the connecting flexible connectors follows the same requirement for freedom of movement. A flexible connector installed slack must show a slight free fold when the system is stopped. If the metal end frames are fixed too far apart, the fabric becomes taut as soon as the fans start, under the combined effect of the static pressure and the shift of the monobloc unit on its mounts. As soon as the textile reaches its axial extension limit, the vibrations of the casing jump directly into the galvanised sheet-metal duct, which then acts as an acoustic transmitter throughout the building.
Decoupling the ducts and acoustic compliance with the requirements of SIA 181
The effort made to decouple the ventilation unit is pointless if the rigid ducts create rigid contacts as they leave the unit. The decoupling of ducts at wall penetrations is the critical point of the acceptance of the work. Penetrations through technical walls and slabs must never be sealed with mortar, plaster or standard rigid polyurethane foam. The installer provides an opening leaving a regular annular space of twenty to forty millimetres all around the duct.
- Filling the openingPack the peripheral space through the wall with a high-density mineral wool blanket, without compressing it excessively so as to preserve its damping elasticity.
- Fitting the decoupling stripsPlace a strip of cellular elastomer or polyethylene foam between the duct and the sealing material at the reinforced concrete wall.
- Flexible perimeter sealClose both faces of the wall with a continuous bead of neutral elastic sealant to stop air leaks without creating a rigid mechanical link.
- Suspension of the adjacent sectionsMount the first clamps and suspension rails of the network on brackets fitted with rubber dampers to absorb the residual energy before the penetration.
The final acceptance is based on the acoustic planning values defined in the execution design. To ensure compliance with the noise protection requirements in the adjacent sensitive rooms, SIA 181 imposes strict thresholds for the continuous sound level of technical installations. During commissioning tests at maximum flow, the site foreman carefully inspects every flexible connection, makes sure that no tool or transport wedge has been left jammed under the machine, and checks that the anti-vibration hangers of the ducts are working within their nominal elasticity range. Maintaining this acoustic seal without rigid contact protects the company against any dispute related to structure-borne noise.
Diagnosing acoustic bridges and clearing acoustic non-conformities
During technical acceptance, the measurement of structure-borne noise under SIA 181 penalises installation errors without mercy. If the sound level in the adjacent rooms exceeds the contractual requirements, the ventilation installer must immediately hunt down the invisible mechanical bridges rather than change the air flow settings. Under art. 22 OLT 3, noise and vibrations must be avoided or combated by construction measures and by isolating the sources.
- Checking the compression of the anti-vibration mountsCheck the deflection under each support with the machine filled with water and the filters clogged. A mount that is too compressed or at its mechanical stop transmits the fan's rotation frequencies directly to the concrete slab. Replace undersized elements if the actual operating weight exceeds the design load.
- Geometric inspection of the flexible connectorsMake sure that no flexible connector is held in tension by the air thrust. A fabric stretched like a drumskin loses all flexibility and carries the vibration wave into the rigid network. Readjust the connection frames to restore the required free fold.
- Examining masonry penetrationsCheck that the decoupling of the ducts at the wall penetration is complete. Remove any plaster, adhesive or mortar that has come into contact with the sheet metal. The penetration must be filled with a resilient mineral wool blanket closed by an uncompressed flexible elastomer joint.
In the event of a proven acoustic defect, art. 368 CO governs the client's rights in the event of defects in the work, including free repair to remedy the installation. On the construction site, the team leader records the measured deflections, the conformity of the fabric slack and the isolation of the ducts before any acoustic countermeasure.
Frequently asked questions
How can you visually spot an incorrectly installed flexible connector on an air handling unit?
Both when stopped and at maximum flow, the fabric must never be stiff or stretched flat. A flexible connector installed slack keeps a slight, supple transverse fold under the fingers. If the air thrust inflates the fabric to the point of removing all slack, or if the misalignment of the flanges pulls excessively on the fibre, the connector transmits the vibration energy to the adjacent duct like a rigid link.
Why do correctly sized anti-vibration mounts sometimes compress completely after commissioning?
The classic mistake comes from sizing based only on the empty weight of the monobloc unit. As soon as the exchange coil is filled with water, the condensate trays fill up and the filters clog, the operating mass increases markedly. The springs or elastomers reach their metal stop, lose their dynamic phase-shifting effect and feed all the low-frequency structure-borne noise back into the supporting floor.
How can you ensure the decoupling of ducts where they pass through a fire-rated wall?
The opening in the structural work must leave a regular peripheral clearance around the duct or the fire-rated sleeve. This gap receives a seal that complies with the fire classification while avoiding rigid bridges. Rock wool of suitable density is inserted under slight compression, protected at the ends by a flexible intumescent sealant, with no metal contact or direct hard sealing between the duct and the concrete.
What are the requirements of SIA 181 for the noise of ventilation systems?
SIA 181 sets the limit values for noise from technical installations perceptible in living and working rooms. The requirements distinguish between airborne noise transmitted by the outlets and structure-borne noise transmitted by the building structures. The ventilation installer is required to decouple all rotating elements in order to meet the permissible sound level in the nearest sensitive room.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 181Noise protection in buildings
- OLT 3 art. 22Noise and vibrations: they must be avoided or combated (construction measures, measures on operating installations, isolation or insulation of the sources, work organisation)
- CO art. 368Client's rights in the event of defects in the work: refusal, price reduction, repair, damages
