Key takeaways
- An overestimated airflow causes noisy turbulence and unbearable draughts at the diffusers.
- In winter, excess airflow accelerates moisture extraction and causes the humidity level to fall below acceptable thresholds.
- The power absorbed by the fan increases with the cube of the volumetric airflow injected into the system.
- Standard SIA 382/1 prohibits arbitrary coefficients in order to guarantee lasting acoustic and thermal comfort.
The reflex of adding excess airflow causes whistling, draughts and acoustic degradation
On ventilation installation construction sites, the temptation to apply cumulative uncertainty margins remains common between the design phase and the setting of the dampers. The designer increases the minimum airflows as a precaution, then the installer opens the balancing devices further to head off possible complaints. This practice distorts the overall airflow behaviour of the system. As soon as the airflow exceeds the set-point values calculated according to standard SIA 382/1, the air velocity in the duct and across the diffusers rises sharply. At the supply terminals, any exceedance of the recommended velocities generates vortex phenomena on the guide vanes or diffusion slots. This broadband aerodynamic noise, perceived as a whistle or a dull rumble, is produced directly by the forced passage of the air and cannot be attenuated by the silencers installed upstream in the air handling unit or the primary network.
| Terminal velocity | Acoustic consequence | Air jet throw | Occupant perception |
|---|---|---|---|
| Less than 2.0 m/s | Sound level compliant for rest areas | Controlled throw without early drop of the air stream | Imperceptible airflow in the occupied zone |
| 2.5 to 3.5 m/s | Whistling noise detectable at the slots | Longer trajectory and increased induction | Perceptible nuisance during quiet working periods |
| Greater than 4.0 m/s | Major turbulence and exceeded thresholds | Jet detachment and direct downdraught onto workstations | Permanent cold draught and rejection of the installation |
The increase in discharge velocity also destroys the intended air distribution pattern in the rooms. When the air jet leaves the terminal with overestimated kinetic energy, the Coanda effect along the ceiling may be broken prematurely or, conversely, may cause an excessive throw that hits the opposite walls and falls back in a cascade into the occupied zone. The residual air velocity at workstations or rest areas then far exceeds the 0.15 to 0.20 m/s allowed by Swiss good practice. Occupants then feel a permanent draught and an unpleasant chill on the neck or ankles. Faced with this mechanical discomfort and the continuous noise from the terminals, the user's usual reaction is to seal the grilles with adhesive tape or simply switch off the control panel of the ventilation unit.
Dry winter air and a surge in power drive the user to switch off the unit
The second direct effect of excessive ventilation appears as soon as severe cold arrives on the Swiss Plateau or in mountain areas. Low-temperature outdoor air has an extremely low absolute humidity, often below 2 or 3 grams of water per kilogram of dry air. When passing through the heat exchanger and then the heating coil to reach the room set-point temperature of 20 to 21 degrees, this air sees its relative humidity collapse mathematically if no water is added. In a normally occupied building, human breathing and indoor activities provide enough endogenous moisture to keep the indoor environment between 35% and 50% relative humidity with a strict hygienic air change rate. With excess airflow, the volume of fresh air injected literally washes out this indoor moisture. The rooms fall durably below the critical threshold of 25% relative humidity, causing severe drying of the respiratory mucous membranes, eye irritation and a permanent electrostatic charge on materials.
In energy and mechanical terms, maintaining an overestimated airflow heavily penalises the operating balance of the air handling unit. The fan affinity laws show that the pressure losses of a duct network vary with the square of the volumetric airflow, while the power absorbed at the fan shaft increases with the cube of the same airflow. An unjustified 25% increase in the overall airflow thus multiplies the electrical drive power by a factor approaching 1.95. This energy waste results in an immediate deterioration of the specific fan power, the SFP value defined by standard SIA 382/1, which then exceeds the prescribed energy efficiency classes.
Diagnosing a network with excess airflow: the three revealing measurements
When a balanced-flow controlled mechanical ventilation system is switched off by the occupants of an office or residential building, the field diagnosis almost always reveals a network pushed beyond its nominal operating point. Recurring complaints about continuous noise, draughts on the back of the neck or respiratory irritation must lead the installer to check three physical quantities on site: the actual discharge velocity at the diffusers using a hot-wire anemometer, the electrical power absorbed at the supply fan box and the relative humidity of the extract air measured with a capacitive probe.
| Measured parameter | Observed symptom | Direct consequence | Corrective action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Terminal velocity | Continuous whistling at the diffusers | Airflow noise that cannot be filtered | Reduce speed at the drive |
| Dynamic pressure | Draught in the occupied zone | Immediate thermal discomfort | Adjust the jet geometry |
| Extract humidity | Indoor air below 30% in winter | Mucous membrane irritation | Readjust the air change rate |
| Motor power | Electrical overheating of the fan box | Surge in energy costs | Lower the set point |
The air velocity at the terminal directly determines the noise induced by the flow passing through ceiling diffusers, supply nozzles and linear slots. When an excessive airflow passes through the terminal devices, the turbulence created by the shearing of the air streams generates broadband noise directly in the room, downstream of the distribution silencers. This discharge noise cannot be attenuated by the sound traps installed in the unit or in the technical shaft. Trying to restrict a noisy terminal by tightening its butterfly damper or adjustment cone aggravates the whistling: the mechanical throttling raises the local pressure loss and accelerates the air still further as it passes the slots, exciting the plenum sheet metal.
Fan consumption follows a cubic law with respect to the volumetric airflow. An arbitrary 20% increase in the volume of air moved raises the motor power by 73%, needlessly inflating the operating bill. At the same time, this excessive air movement dries out the air in the cold season. Winter outdoor air contains a very small absolute amount of water; once admitted and heated to 21 °C, it dilutes the ambient humidity until the relative humidity falls below 25%, making the atmosphere unbearable.
The right sizing margin and readjustment according to standard SIA 382/1
Chronic oversizing of networks often results from an uncontrolled accumulation of safety margins between planners, HVAC engineers and installers. Each adds their own contingency margin of 10 to 15%, resulting in an over-powered installation that operates outside its optimum efficiency range. Standard SIA 382/1 governs the hygienic volumetric airflows according to room use and requires strict limitation of the specific electrical ventilation power, designated by the SFP classes. The challenge on the construction site is to set the installation to the real needs of the occupants, without artificially inflating the set-point airflows at the expense of acoustic comfort and the humidity balance.
- Initial airflow measurementMeasure the overall airflow in a straight duct with a Pitot tube in order to identify precisely the deviation from the specifications.
- Reduction of the motor frequencyLower the set point on the unit's frequency drive until the nominal airflow required by standard SIA 382/1 is reached.
- Balancing of the terminal branchesAdjust the secondary dampers from the most disadvantaged branch to the nearest one, keeping the farthest terminal diffuser 100% open.
- Acoustic and humidity validationMeasure the sound pressure level in the living areas and monitor the recovery of the relative humidity over the following days.
The margin on an air handling installation must never apply to the continuously supplied airflow, but to the fan's pressure reserve and the cross-section of the main ducts, to allow for future expansion. The operating airflow must remain set to the hygienic design values. By respecting the ratios of standard SIA 382/1, the indoor relative humidity is naturally maintained between 35% and 50% in winter, the air velocities at the terminals remain below audible thresholds, and the installation operates without being rejected by its users.
Rectification protocol and clearing of reservations in the case of proven excess airflow
When the occupants switch off the balanced-flow air handling unit because of continuous whistling or a throat irritated by indoor air that has fallen below 25% relative humidity, the construction site slides into a technical dispute. The initial reflex is often to blame the terminal air diffusers, whereas the cause is an over-powered fan discharging into a network that is excessively throttled mechanically. To restore the situation and clear the reservations without compromising hygienic air quality, the installer applies a methodical remediation protocol:
- Overall airflow assessment and individual measurement at the terminalsRead the differential pressure at the measuring cross of the unit with a calibrated differential manometer. Then measure the actual airflow at each supply terminal with a flow-measuring hood fitted with a flow straightener. This operation precisely identifies air velocities above 2 m/s, the direct causes of regenerated noise and complaints about unpleasant draughts.
- Lowering of the fan rotational speedLower the frequency of the drive or the 0-10 V signal on EC motors before touching the dampers. According to the fan affinity laws, reducing the airflow by 20% lowers fan consumption by about 48%, while removing the acoustic overpressure at the machine's immediate discharge.
- Low-pressure air balancingOpen the adjustment damper on the most disadvantaged branch fully. Then readjust the intermediate balancing devices sparingly. This adjustment method avoids unnecessary singular pressure losses and prevents the appearance of airflow whistling directly perceptible in living areas or offices.
- Hygienic readjustment and humidity stabilisationCheck that the residual airflows strictly comply with the requirements of standard SIA 382/1. By limiting the air change to the strict physiological need of the occupants, excessive drying of the indoor environment in the cold season is curbed while the power demanded from the reheating coil is reduced.
In contractual terms, under art. 367 CO, the client checks the condition of the work and notifies the contractor of defects. Where persistent noise nuisance or severe dryness of the air disrupts the normal use of the premises, art. 368 CO provides for the client's rights in the event of defects in the work, including rectification. Readjusting the fan rotational speed and rebalancing the network in accordance with good practice settles the dispute without requiring any structural modification of the ducts.
Frequently asked questions
How can you quickly tell on a construction site whether a ventilation network suffers from excess airflow?
The first visual or tactile clue is the presence of perceptible draughts more than one metre from the diffusers. With an anemometer, an air velocity at the terminal above 2.5 m/s indicates excessive velocity causing airflow whistling. If the differential manometer measurement shows a static pressure at the fan well above the initial calculation sheet, the installation is clearly running with excess airflow and must be restricted at the drive.
Why does excess ventilation airflow dry out the indoor air in winter?
In the cold season, the incoming outdoor air contains very little water in absolute terms, often less than 3 g/kg of dry air. Once heated to 20 °C without active humidification, its relative humidity collapses. An excessive airflow renews this volume too quickly and removes the moisture produced by the occupants before it permeates the rooms. Reducing the airflows to the values of standard SIA 382/1 keeps the relative humidity above 30%.
What is the direct influence of excess airflow on the fans' electricity bill?
The power absorbed by the motor follows a cubic law with respect to the volume of air moved. Increasing the airflow by only 25% above real needs raises the electrical power drawn by almost 95%, nearly doubling the consumption of the fan box. Continuously oversizing a fan without adjustment at the drive heavily degrades the overall energy efficiency and prematurely increases mechanical wear of the bearings as well as clogging of the unit's filters.
Should you restrict the supply terminals or lower the drive to correct the airflow?
You must absolutely act first on the frequency drive or the fan control signal. Closing the terminal dampers needlessly increases the static pressure in the metal ducts, creating shrill whistling noises through air throttling. By lowering the rotational speed of the impeller, the overall network pressure is reduced, turbulence at the terminals is eliminated and the overall electricity consumption of the installation is instantly decreased.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 382/1Ventilation and air-conditioning installations - General principles and performance
- CO art. 367Inspection of the work and notice of defects
- CO art. 368Client's rights in the event of defects in the work
