Key takeaways
- An individual deviation of ten per cent remains tolerated if it offsets other outlets in the network.
- A systematic drift of the same sign on all diffusers is a major setting defect.
- The ratio between supply airflow and extract airflow determines the pressurisation of the building.
- The compliance of an installation requires that the local airflows and the overall balance are met at the same time.
Permissible tolerance per diffuser and statistical scatter according to SIA 382/1
When commissioning an air distribution network, achieving a perfect match between the airflows in the execution documents and the airflows measured on site is a theoretical illusion. The accuracy of a terminal measurement depends on the turbulence created by upstream bends, on the accuracy of the vane anemometers or flow-measuring hoods, and on the position of the control damper built into the plenum. SIA 382/1 accepts that a relative deviation not exceeding ten per cent on an individual supply or extract outlet does not call into question the effectiveness of the ventilation of the room.
This tolerance margin on each terminal unit assumes, however, that the deviations are distributed on both sides of the set value. On a commercial branch serving six individual offices, each designed for sixty cubic metres per hour, finding two rooms measured at sixty-six cubic metres per hour, two rooms measured at fifty-four cubic metres per hour and two rooms exactly compliant corresponds to a healthy statistical scatter. The airflow behaviour of the section remains stable, the cumulative airflow of the branch remains strictly equal to the design nominal airflow, and the acoustic behaviour of the throttling devices does not generate any abnormal overpressure in the main duct.
| Configuration | Maximum individual deviation | Algebraic sum of deviations | Technical verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Centred random scatter | ± 10 % per outlet | 0 % on the section | Compliant: proportional balancing successful |
| Positive one-sided drift | + 10 % per outlet | + 10 % on the section | Non-compliant: excess overall airflow and overpressure |
| Negative one-sided drift | - 10 % per outlet | - 10 % on the section | Non-compliant: overall under-ventilation |
Overall air balance and contractual classification of a systematic drift
The real risk of a poorly carried-out adjustment lies in the accumulation of errors of the same sign. If twenty outlets on a floor each show an excess of eight to ten per cent, the network suffers from a systematic drift. This phenomenon points either to an erroneous overall measurement at the fan, to a wrong setting of the frequency converter, or to the absence of balancing of the main floor dampers. The consequences for the installation are critical: the velocity in the main ducts increases, the sound power level rises at excessively throttled balancing dampers, and the specific electrical consumption of the motors exceeds the energy indices prescribed by SIA 382/1.
This anomaly seriously disturbs the air balance between supply and extract. A balanced-ventilation installation in an office building or a school relies on a strict balance of air masses to ensure that fire doors stay closed, to avoid whistling joinery and to prevent indoor humidity from penetrating the thermal envelope of the building. If the supply systematically shows a ten per cent excess while the extract is set exactly to its set value, the building ends up under permanent overpressure. In freezing weather, warm and humid air infiltrates through the slightest flaws in the airtight envelope, causing destructive condensation in the walls.
- Reading the operating point at the air handling unitCheck the available static pressure and the overall airflow by differential pressure at the measuring orifices or at the intake probes of the supply and extract fans before any adjustment of outlets.
- Adjusting the fan to the required overall airflowSet the motor speed setpoint via the converter so as to set the overall airflow of the unit to within plus or minus three per cent of the value prescribed in the specifications.
- Methodical balancing by the proportional methodCalibrate the floor and branch dampers, working from the most disadvantaged outlet towards the main branch, in order to bring the mean of the local deviations back to a neutral value.
Regarding the installer's liability, art. 368 CO governs the client's rights in the event of defects in the work, opening the way to rectification of imperfect services or to a reduction of the price. If the measurement report reveals a systematic drift distorting the balance of the building, the client's representative is entitled to refuse the technical acceptance of the ventilation package in accordance with the rules of SIA 118. The company must then repeat the entire measurement and balancing campaign at its own expense to demonstrate that the air balance has been restored.
Analysing test reports: distinguishing statistical scatter from directional drift
When terminal airflows are accepted, going through a balancing record line by line can mislead the technician. A supply outlet set to 92 m³/h for a prescribed set value of 100 m³/h shows a relative deviation of -8 %. Taken in isolation, this measurement meets the tolerance range accepted by SIA 382/1 for an individual room, usually accepted at ±10 % of the set airflows. The inaccuracies inherent in field instruments (hood balometer, vane anemometer or Pitot tube) as well as the flow disturbances in the connection plenums make it illusory to obtain a mathematically exact value on each diffuser. However, the compliance of an air-handling installation is not assessed solely by the absence of exceeded maximum thresholds on each terminal unit considered individually.
| Diffuser | Set value (m³/h) | Branch 1: Random scatter (m³/h) | Branch 2: Systematic drift (m³/h) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diffuser 1 | 100 | 93 (-7 %) | 91 (-9 %) |
| Diffuser 2 | 100 | 106 (+6 %) | 92 (-8 %) |
| Diffuser 3 | 100 | 102 (+2 %) | 93 (-7 %) |
| Diffuser 4 | 100 | 97 (-3 %) | 90 (-10 %) |
| Diffuser 5 | 100 | 108 (+8 %) | 92 (-8 %) |
| Diffuser 6 | 100 | 94 (-6 %) | 91 (-9 %) |
| Diffuser 7 | 100 | 101 (+1 %) | 93 (-7 %) |
| Diffuser 8 | 100 | 98 (-2 %) | 92 (-8 %) |
| Total measured | 800 | 799 (-0.1 %) | 734 (-8.25 %) |
On the first branch, the airflows fluctuate naturally around the nominal value. The over-flows offset the under-flows: the total airflow supplied matches the design of the section and preserves the overall energy balance. On the second branch, each diffuser individually respects the ten per cent tolerance, but all the airflows deviate in the same direction. This systematic deviation can no longer be attributed to measurement uncertainty or to the geometry of the grilles. It reveals an upstream defect in the network: an uncalculated local pressure loss, an excessively closed floor damper, or an insufficient fan pressure set point.
Air-handling verdict, break in the floor balance and contractual classification
The major consequence of a directional drift is the break in the overall balance between supply and extract. If an office branch accumulates an average negative drift of -8 % on supply while the extract network operates at its set value or shows a positive drift of +5 %, the balance of indoor pressures collapses. The room or floor tips into excessive negative pressure relative to the peripheral zones. This anomaly generates unwanted air inflow through the joinery, disturbs occupants' comfort through cold draughts, causes landing doors to slam and sometimes reverses the airflow cascades by drawing stale air from sanitary rooms or storage areas towards the main spaces.
When a report shows an accumulation of deviations of the same sign, the technical verdict cannot conclude that the work is compliant, even if no diffuser exceeds the individual limits. Art. 368 CO governs the client's rights in the event of defects in the work: it allows the site management to demand rectification of the defective service at no additional cost. The tolerance of ten per cent per room applies to the statistical variability of a successful balancing, not to the validation of an overall inadequacy of air transport.
- Checking the upstream airflow by measurement in a straight ductMeasure the mean velocity and the dynamic pressure in the main duct with a Pitot tube or a thermal anemometer, on a stabilised straight section away from bends and reductions, in order to verify the overall airflow actually delivered by the fan.
- Examining the position of the zone balancing dampersRecord the angular position of the manual or motorised adjustment dampers located on the duct take-offs. A damper excessively throttled upstream of a deficient branch must be reopened before any intervention on the diffusers.
- Adjusting the set value and validating the pressure balanceIf necessary, change the fan speed via the frequency converter control, then carry out a complete re-measurement to verify the neutrality, or the slight overpressure intended, between supply and extract.
Procedure for handling non-conformities and eliminating systematic drifts
When a measurement report reveals a directional drift, technical acceptance cannot be granted without corrective action. A tolerance per room of plus or minus ten per cent remains perfectly admissible as long as it reflects a normal statistical scatter around the set value. If, however, the sum of the supply deviations tips entirely to the positive side while the extract is deficient, the overall balance of the building is broken. Within the meaning of SIA 382/1, this phenomenon is not a measurement tolerance but qualifies as a systematic balancing defect that disturbs airtightness and the transfer of airflows between zones.
- Checking the operating point at the air handling unitBefore modifying the terminal diffusers, measure the differential pressure at the measuring cross of the unit and check the actual rotational speed of the fan. A wrong set value on the frequency converter or an asymmetric clogging of the filters immediately distorts all the branches of the network.
- Balancing the section dampersMeasure the overall airflow on each main branch with a Pitot tube or by multi-point anemometry in a straight duct. Adjust the floor balancing dampers to distribute the air according to the proportional method, without trying to compensate for terminal drifts from the air handling unit.
- Terminal adjustment and joint validationReadjust the throttling devices on each terminal box using a suitable measuring hood. Record the measured values in a new test report, checking that the sum of the terminal airflows matches the branch airflow measured in the duct.
Classifying a deviation as systematic requires demonstrating the impact on overall operation. A one-sided drift of ten per cent over a whole floor breaks the air balance and disturbs the pressure cascade between main rooms and sanitary rooms. The remediation ends with a joint measurement with the representative of the site management, formalised by a final balancing report confirming that the nominal airflows are met.
Frequently asked questions
Why does a deviation of ten per cent on each outlet become unacceptable if it is in the same direction?
An isolated deviation of ten per cent is absorbed by the airflow dynamics of the room without penalising the installation. If, however, all the supply outlets show an over-flow of ten per cent while the extract remains nominal, the sum of the deviations creates an uncontrolled overall overpressure. This systematic drift pushes warm, humid air into the walls of the building and distorts the heat recovery on the ventilation unit.
What tolerance does SIA 382/1 accept for the airflow of an individual room?
SIA 382/1 usually accepts a tolerance of plus or minus ten per cent on the airflow of a room or of an individual diffuser, provided that the mean of the measurements on the network tends towards zero. This margin compensates for the calibration uncertainties of portable instruments and local flow instabilities. It does not apply to the overall balance of the unit, whose contractual tolerance is considerably tighter.
How can you prove that the break in the air balance comes from a duct leak and not from the adjustment?
To distinguish a setting defect from a leak, compare the sum of the airflows measured at the outlets with the traverse measurement taken in the upstream duct with a Pitot tube. If the airflow in the main duct complies with the design but the total recorded at the diffusers shows a systematic shortfall of fifteen per cent, air is escaping from the network. An airtightness test according to SIA 382/1 must then be carried out.
Which instrument should be used for a joint re-measurement on a ceiling diffuser?
A calibrated measuring hood fitted with a flow straightener, or a balometer with pressure-loss compensation, is essential. A vane or hot-wire anemometer held by hand under the diffuser produces too many integration errors due to diffusion turbulence. Only the funnel capturing the entire air stream guarantees a repeatable reading that both parties can rely on when the balancing reservations are cleared.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 382/1Ventilation and air-conditioning installations - General principles and performance
