Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 244Commissioning, measurement and air flow balancingChapter 8 of 10 in the section

Qualifying the defect: insufficient airflow, excessive noise, major defect

Faced with insufficient fresh-air flow or a persistent whistling at the air terminals, the ventilation fitter must be able to qualify the anomaly legally and technically. You will learn to distinguish a simple adjustment from a major defect affecting habitability under SIA 118, to formalise measurement records and to frame the schedule of remedial work before any unjustified financial retention.

Key takeaways

  • A thirty per cent airflow deviation directly compromises the hygienic air change required.
  • The qualification of the defect under SIA 118 determines whether a financial retention is admissible.
  • The formal notice requires a realistic technical deadline to be set for the remedial work.
  • The joint expert assessment on site records the actual airflows using calibrated and certified instruments.

Qualifying the airflow deviation: minor defect or impairment of the intended use

During the final inspection of a balanced-flow (supply and extract) installation in a dwelling, an isolated 5 to 10 % deviation on a supply terminal is resolved by adjusting the balancing dampers or changing the fan curve. By contrast, finding a 30 % airflow shortfall in a bedroom turns what seemed to be a finishing operation into a genuine functional non-conformity. Hygienic fresh air is no longer distributed in accordance with the airflow balance requirements, which causes a rapid build-up of carbon dioxide and humidity during the night.

Impairment of the intended use
Technical situation in which the work does not fulfil the basic functions defined in the works contract or by the recognised rules of the trade, making the space unfit for healthy and comfortable occupation.

Within the acceptance of the work governed by SIA 118, defects found are classified according to their seriousness. An airflow reduced by one third is neither a cosmetic imperfection nor a minor defect without consequence. It is a defect that hinders the normal use of the premises. If the air distributed does not allow the intended indoor conditions to be maintained, site management is entitled to refuse acceptance of the part of the work concerned or to grant acceptance with substantial reservations.

Classification of ventilation anomalies at acceptance
Finding on siteTechnical classificationImpact under SIA 118Consequence for acceptance
Airflow deviation below 10 % with accessible damperMinor balancing defectUse preserved without measurable nuisanceAcceptance granted with an obligation to adjust
Supply airflow 30 % short in a bedroomMajor defect in the air changeEstablished impairment of the intended useAcceptance postponed or accompanied by targeted retentions
Airflow noise above permissible valuesFunctional acoustic defectDisturbance to night-time habitabilityAcceptance of the room refused until corrected
Reversal of flow between supply and extractCritical error in the installation of the air systemHealth risk and total non-conformityOverall refusal of the ventilation installation

The ventilation installer must therefore immediately investigate the air-distribution chain. He measures the static pressure available at the floor manifold, inspects the section in question with a flexible endoscope and checks the tightness of the connections. It is the rigorous identification of the source of the problem that makes it possible to argue technically against the client and to prevent the dispute from extending to the whole account for the installation.

Managing the formal notice, the remedial deadline and the joint expert assessment

Once the defect has been formally qualified as an impairment of the intended use, the client initiates the notice of defects procedure. Under the Code of Obligations (CO), the debtor of an imperfect performance is put in default by the creditor's demand, in accordance with art. 102 CO. This formal notice must necessarily set a reasonable period for remedying the anomalies reported on the air network.

Faced with a financial retention applied by site management on the advance payments for the installation, the ventilation tradesman must check the proportionality of the sum withheld. Under art. 368 CO, the client may require the work to be remedied free of charge if the repair does not entail excessive expense. However, the monetary retention may not exceed the foreseeable cost of the work needed to restore the contractual airflows plus a customary safety margin.

  1. Receipt of the notice of defectsExamine point by point the complaints made in writing and check them against the initial commissioning report.
  2. Verification of the measurement conditionsCheck that the joint measurements were carried out with doors closed, filters clean and fans stabilised at nominal speed.
  3. Organisation of the joint expert assessmentSummon on site the site management, the consulting engineer and the measurement technician equipped with a calibrated anemometer or a certified flow hood.
  4. Drawing up the agreement recordRecord the airflows measured by mutual agreement in a single document signed at the meeting, stating the action plan and the deadline agreed.

The joint expert assessment is the only technical safeguard against exaggerated claims. If the missing airflow results from an unforeseen pressure loss caused by route changes dictated by other trades during the works, the ventilation contractor is relieved of liability. The joint record makes it possible to document these material facts and to open the way to an addendum for additional work rather than a penalty for non-performance.

Qualification of the airflow deviation and substantial impairment of use

A supplied fresh-air flow 30 % below the set value in a bedroom is not a mere adjustment imperfection. In a controlled mechanical ventilation installation with balanced flow, such a drop directly alters the hygienic air change of the sleeping area. The rate at which indoor pollutants and water vapour are removed falls, which leads to an excessive build-up of carbon dioxide during sleep. In light of SIA 118, such a drop in performance is a defect that compromises the agreed use of the premises.

The impact of a volume deficit of this order goes beyond the under-ventilated room alone. In an air network balanced in cascade, the air supplied to the bedrooms must pass through the internal circulation areas to be extracted in wet rooms such as the kitchen, toilets and bathrooms. When a supply terminal suffers a 30 % deficit, the sweeping transfer is broken and the overall balance of the dwelling is disrupted. This imbalance induces parasitic air transfers under the doors and distorts the undercut gaps of the door leaves. For the client, the room loses its guaranteed habitability, which justifies a formal qualification as a major defect at acceptance.

Qualification grid for airflow and acoustic deviations at acceptance
Measured findingTechnical origin identifiedQualification of the disorderEffect on acceptance
Supply deficit above 25 %Crushed semi-rigid duct or poorly connected branchImpairment of use (serious defect)Acceptance of the branch concerned refused
Supply deficit between 10 % and 20 %Setting drift on damper or balancing deviceRemediable defect in the workAcceptance with technical reservation
High-pitched whistling at supply terminalExcessive pressure loss due to throttling of the butterfly damperEstablished acoustic non-conformityAcceptance refused for noise nuisance
Airflow deviation below 10 % without noiseNormal measurement fluctuation and minimal pressure lossesTolerance accepted on the networkAcceptance without airflow reservation

Joint expert assessment, setting the deadline and framing the retention

To provide a technical basis for the refusal or the retention, the deviation cannot be measured by rough estimate. The ventilation company and site management must carry out a joint expert assessment on the construction site. The airflows at the diffusers and supply terminals are measured with a flow hood fitted with a sealed cover adapted to the dimensions of the grilles, incorporating a back-pressure compensation device so as not to alter the operating point of the diffuser. To remove any ambiguity about an upstream leak or a failure of the air-handling unit, additional measurements with a hot-wire thermo-anemometer are taken on straight sections of the main ducts.

The record drawn up at the end of the assessment sets out the contractual airflows, the values measured and the instrument uncertainties. Once the technical defect is established, the client's rights under art. 368 CO come into play, allowing the remedying of the defective branch to be required. Site management formalises the claim by a written notice of defects with a precise schedule. If the ventilation contractor does not remedy the problem, the formal notice relies on CO, which allows a reasonable period to be set for performance before remedying by a third party at the contractor's expense is considered.

The financial retention applied on the progress statements or on the final account must correspond precisely to the material reality of the remedial work required. In the case of an inaccessible duct hidden by a suspended ceiling or embedded in a slab opening, the remedy involves removing the finishes, replacing the rigid or semi-rigid ducts, plasterwork repairs and a new complete air-balancing campaign. The amount remains held until the non-conformity is cleared. The release of the funds takes place only after a final joint record has been drawn up certifying that the required nominal airflows have been achieved, without any rise in the noise level in the sleeping area.

Course of action when an airflow defect is disputed

When an airflow deviation reaches thirty per cent on a bedroom supply, the installation no longer meets the required hygienic air change. Within the meaning of SIA 118, such a shortcoming is a defect that prevents the normal use of the room, not a mere cosmetic touch-up. The client then validly refuses acceptance of the part of the work concerned, suspending payment of the corresponding balance. In this situation, the ventilation installer must structure his technical and contractual approach methodically to avoid legal escalation and substitute performance at his company's expense.

  1. Check the measurement chain and calibrationBefore any dispute, repeat the joint measurement on the diffuser in question in the presence of site management. Use a calibrated pressure-compensated measuring hood or a thermal anemometer whose calibration certificate is less than one year old. Record the upstream static pressure with a differential manometer to isolate an unforeseen localised pressure loss.
  2. Audit the section and diagnose the originInspect the route from the manifold: jammed balancing damper, semi-rigid duct crushed in the screed, faulty seal at the plenum connection or excessive pressure loss in the acoustic silencer. If the cause stems from a change of layout imposed by the structural work or from a design sizing error, issue a reasoned technical opinion.
  3. Frame the remedial deadline and the formal noticeIn reply to the formal notice served by site management under SIA 118, acknowledge receipt and propose a realistic intervention schedule. If access in the slab or technical shaft requires investigations, refuse in writing an arbitrary deadline of a few days and give reasons based on the lead time for the components needed.
  4. Have recourse to the joint expert assessmentIn the event of persistent disagreement on the origin of the airflow shortfall or the effectiveness of the corrective measures, require the joint involvement of an independent third-party engineering firm. This joint expert assessment fixes the airflow readings, determines responsibilities and prevents a disproportionate financial retention on the final account.

Frequently asked questions

Does a thirty per cent airflow deficit entitle the client to refuse acceptance of the whole installation?

No. A thirty per cent airflow deficit on one diffuser is a localised major defect that impairs the intended use of the room concerned, justifying refusal of acceptance of that specific room. However, under SIA 118, this isolated shortcoming does not allow acceptance of the entire air installation to be blocked if the other networks operate in accordance with the technical specifications and the prescribed airflows.

How should the amount of a financial retention applied for insufficient airflow be limited?

Under SIA 118, the amount of the retention must be fair and correspond to the actual foreseeable costs of remedying the defect. It covers investigations on the duct, sealing repairs, rebalancing of the section and final checking measurements. A lump-sum retention blocking the entire installation invoice is contrary to Swiss contractual rules and must be formally contested in writing by the ventilation company.

What should be done if site management imposes an unrealistic forty-eight-hour remedial deadline?

The company must reject this schedule without delay by registered letter or by a formal entry in the site meeting minutes. SIA 118 provides that the remedial period granted to the contractor must be reasonable and technically feasible. The installer must propose a precise counter-deadline, detailing the time needed for any destructive investigations, the ordering of adjustment accessories, installation and new joint measurements on the air network.

Who must commission and fund the joint expert assessment in the event of persistent disagreement?

When the parties disagree on the cause of a missing airflow or on the calibration of the measuring instruments, the joint expert assessment is agreed by mutual consent between the client and the installer. An independent building-services expert carries out the airflow checks. The assessment costs are generally advanced by the requesting party, then finally charged to the losing party according to the conclusions of the technical expert report.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work (acceptance of the work, notice of defects, remedial period and warranty)

In the same section