Key takeaways
- A winter fresh-air duct causes immediate condensation of the warm, humid garage air.
- SIA 382/1 requires complete thermal insulation of any duct passing through an unheated space.
- The vapour barrier must always be placed on the warm outer face of the insulation layer.
- Hangers and joints sealed with pure aluminium adhesive tape eliminate residual thermal bridges.
Understanding the dew point on fresh air passing through an unheated garage
In winter, fresh air taken in at roof level or at the façade frequently drops to sub-zero temperatures, ranging for example between -5 °C and 2 °C on the Swiss Plateau. When this airflow passes through a bare metal spiral duct located in a shared basement, the galvanised steel wall takes on almost the temperature of the air flowing inside. At the same time, the underground car park, although unheated, remains warmed by the ground and the vehicles to a temperature of 10 °C to 14 °C, with a relative humidity often above 70 % generated by run-off water and snowmelt under the vehicle bodies.
This temperature contrast abruptly lowers the temperature of the ambient air in direct contact with the duct below its saturation temperature, known as the dew point. The absolute humidity of the garage air then liquefies on the steel. Droplets accumulate along the longitudinal seams of the duct and end up dripping continuously. When a parking space is located beneath this route, the water, laden with dust and oxides, runs directly onto the parked vehicles, causing paint damage and a direct dispute with the co-owners.
| Air duct section | Temperature of the air conveyed | Physical risk | Insulation requirement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outdoor fresh-air intake | -5 °C to 5 °C | Heavy external surface condensation on the sheet metal | Thermal insulation with vapour barrier on the garage side |
| Exhaust air discharge | 0 °C to 6 °C (after heat exchanger) | External surface condensation on the duct | Thermal insulation with vapour barrier on the garage side |
| Supply of heated fresh air | 18 °C to 21 °C | Heat loss to the car park | Thermal insulation, vapour barrier not mandatory |
| Indoor extract air | 20 °C to 22 °C | Cooling of the air before heat recovery | Thermal insulation for energy conservation |
Apply SIA 382/1 and install insulation with a continuous vapour barrier
SIA 382/1 defines the thermal and condensation protection requirements for ventilation and air-conditioning installations. The insulation of ducts in unheated rooms must meet a minimum thermal resistance performance, while blocking the migration of water vapour towards the cold wall. Under art. 364 CO, the contractor carries out the work with care and is responsible for its proper execution in accordance with the rules of the trade.
- Continuity of the vapour barrier
- A barrier impermeable to vapour diffusion placed on the warm side of the insulation, sealed without any discontinuity at the overlaps, at support penetrations and at wall connections, in order to prevent humid air from reaching the cold sheet metal.
- Cleaning the circular or rectangular ductRemove dust from and degrease the galvanised sheet metal with a cleaning solvent to ensure the adhesion of the tapes and mechanical fixings.
- Selecting the insulation materialUse closed-cell extruded elastomer at least 25 mm thick or a mineral wool mat at least 40 mm thick, factory-fitted with an aluminium foil reinforced by a glass mesh acting as the vapour barrier.
- Fitting shells or isolators on the hangersInsert insulated clamps or strips of rigid elastomer foam between the duct and the suspension clamps to avoid a metallic thermal bridge between the system and the threaded rod fixed to the ceiling.
- Closing the longitudinal and circumferential jointsFold down the vapour barrier flap with a minimum overlap of 50 mm. Press down a pure aluminium adhesive tape with a minimum width of 75 mm using a rigid spatula to squeeze out air bubbles.
- Airtight connection to masonry wallsExtend the insulation up to the inner face of the fire wall or slab, then seal the perimeter with an airtight sealant compatible with the vapour barrier in order to prevent garage air from infiltrating behind the insulation.
Treatment of singular points: clamps, flanges and wall penetrations
When an uninsulated fresh-air duct passes through an underground car park, surface condensation is not limited to the smooth walls of the sheet metal. The winter outdoor air, which can fall below zero degrees, cools the galvanised steel massively. In contact with the warmer, humid atmosphere of the garage (often between 8 °C and 12 °C with a relative humidity above 70 %), the water vapour liquefies immediately. Droplets accumulate along the duct, run towards the low point and drip directly onto the bodywork of the parked vehicles. If insulation is applied without treating the mechanical fixings, the problem is displaced without disappearing: water then condenses on the suspension clamps and penetrates the vapour barrier by gravity.
To eliminate any risk of condensation on a cold duct in an unheated garage, the installation of the insulation must enclose or thermally decouple each supporting element. A metal hanger fixed directly onto bare sheet metal constitutes a linear thermal bridge: the cold of the duct is conducted to the threaded rod, causing localised condensation above the insulation mat. The water seeps into the mineral wool, saturates the fibres, destroys the thermal resistance of the insulation and ends up piercing the vapour barrier system, creating a pocket of water.
| Insulation | Associated vapour barrier | Handling of flanges and joints | Fire behaviour (VKF/AEAI) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rock wool (lamella with upright fibres) | Pure aluminium foil reinforced with a glass mesh (thickness ≥ 50 µm) | 75 mm wide pure aluminium adhesive tape pressed down with a squeegee | A2-s1, d0 (non-combustible, suitable for escape routes and car parks) |
| Flexible closed-cell elastomer foam | Integrated in the cellular structure (diffusion resistance µ ≥ 10,000) | Full-surface bonding of the joints with dedicated neoprene adhesive and overlap tape | B-s3, d0 (check installation compliance with the VKF/AEAI requirements of the fire compartment) |
| Flexible glass wool mat | Reinforced kraft aluminium | Stapling of the flaps, then systematic bridging with aluminium tape | A2-s1, d0 (requires mechanical protection if accessible below 2.50 m) |
Refurbishment method on an existing duct and continuity of the vapour barrier
Refurbishing an air duct system that is dripping in operation requires a rigorous sequence of work. Insulation cannot be applied to a damp surface or one fouled by exhaust deposits: the adhesion of the vapour barrier tapes would be compromised within a few weeks. In accordance with the contractor's obligations set out in art. 364 CO, the work must be carried out in accordance with the rules of the trade to ensure the durability of the works and to protect the property of third parties located below the ducts.
- Shutdown and complete dryingTemporarily switch off the air handling unit to stop the icy fresh-air flow. Clean and degrease the galvanised sheet metal with a suitable solvent to remove greasy soot from the garage. Dry the surface thoroughly before starting bonding or mechanical installation.
- Fitting the insulation on the underside and the sidesCut the insulation boards or mats leaving sufficient overhang to cover the flange frames (METU profiles). When using upright-fibre mineral wool, hold the insulation in place with weld pins or adhesive clips, providing at least 6 fixings per square metre under wide rectangular ducts.
- Airtight closure and bridging of the jointsFold down the aluminium flaps of the vapour barrier. Apply a pure aluminium adhesive tape at least 75 mm wide over all longitudinal and circumferential joints. Press down firmly every centimetre of tape with a rigid plastic spatula to eliminate air bubbles and activate the acrylic adhesive.
- Treatment of the partition or slab penetrationExtend the insulation and its vapour barrier through the wall opening to the heated room or to the outer face. If the duct passes through a fire wall separating the garage from the building, the vapour-barrier thermal insulation must be interrupted at the approved fire seal, then resumed immediately on both sides with an elastomer sealing bead to prevent garage air from infiltrating under the wool.
Handling the damage: active condensation, damage to third parties and rework
When an uninsulated fresh-air duct drips above a parking space, the direct risk is damage to vehicles from water laden with garage dust and mill scale. The first action on site is to stop the dripping by installing a temporary collecting channel or a sheet directed towards a floor drain. The installer records the condition on site in a precise report: measurement of the fresh-air transport temperature, dry ambient temperature of the garage and relative humidity measured with a calibrated thermo-hygrometer. These values make it possible to locate the dew point formally on the Mollier diagram and to document the air-handling origin of the phenomenon.
Contractually, if the absence of insulation results from an omission in the tender specification or on the engineer's drawings, the installer reminds the client of his duty to notify under the Code of Obligations. On the other hand, if the duct was delivered uninsulated in contradiction with SIA 382/1 or if the vapour barrier shows discontinuities in execution, the company's liability is engaged. In accordance with art. 368 CO, the client may demand rectification of the work in the event of defects. The rework allows no compromise on the method: soaked fibrous insulation irreversibly loses its thermal resistance and must be removed from the construction site.
- Remediation of the substrateRemove the soaked insulation, dry the galvanised steel sheet with a heat gun and treat the initial signs of oxidation on the seams or staples with a zinc primer.
- Installing the new insulation systemFit shells or boards of closed-cell expanded elastomer at least 30 mm thick, or high-density mineral wool faced with reinforced aluminium at 40 mm, in accordance with SIA 382/1.
- Absolute continuity of the vapour sealJoin the sheets with a minimum overlap of 50 mm, press down the pure aluminium adhesive tapes and seal the support clamps and the wall penetrations with a dedicated elastomer vapour-barrier sealant.
Frequently asked questions
Why does a fresh-air duct condense on the outside when passing through an underground garage?
In winter or during humid mid-season spells, the outdoor air drawn in by the air handling unit is cold, often between -5 °C and 5 °C. The galvanised steel wall adopts this temperature. The atmosphere of the underground garage, tempered by the slabs and the vehicles, contains warmer, more humid air. On contact with the uninsulated sheet metal, this ambient air reaches its dew point: the moisture condenses and runs off.
Which vapour barrier should be chosen to insulate a fresh-air duct in an unheated basement?
Use either a closed-cell extruded elastomer, which is vapour-tight by its structure, or a mineral wool mat faced with a gridded pure aluminium foil. The vapour barrier must have an Sd value greater than 100 m. The joints between sheets must always be closed with an aluminium adhesive tape at least 75 mm wide, carefully pressed down with a flat spatula on a dust-free substrate.
Should the clamps and hanger rods of the ventilation duct be insulated?
Yes, metal clamps constitute major thermal bridges. If a clamp encircles the sheet metal under the insulation, the cold travels to the threaded rod exposed to the car park atmosphere: water beads and runs down the iron. Rigid incompressible shells are inserted under the clamp, or the flange and the clamping are completely enclosed in the insulation mat with a continuous vapour barrier.
What insulation thickness does SIA 382/1 prescribe in an unheated garage?
SIA 382/1 sizes the thicknesses according to the temperature difference between the air conveyed and the surrounding atmosphere. For a fresh-air duct in an unheated room, the required thickness is commonly 40 mm to 50 mm of mineral wool, or 30 mm of elastomer foam. A smaller thickness leaves the outer surface too cold, so that the dew point is crossed during peaks of garage humidity.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 382/1Ventilation and air-conditioning installations - General principles and performance
- CO art. 368client's rights in the event of defects in the work: refusal, price reduction, rectification, damages; any clause agreed in advance that restricts or excludes the right to have defects remedied is void if the defect concerns a building (para. 2bis, since 1 January 2026)
