Key takeaways
- Disorderly balancing alters all the flow rates with every adjustment of a damper or diffuser.
- The reference outlet is the one with the lowest ratio of measured flow to design flow.
- The proportional method fixes the airflow ratios of a branch before acting on the branch base.
- The fan is adjusted last to set the overall flow within the standard tolerance.
Identify the reference outlet and lock the airflow geometry
On a supply or return network, acting on a terminal unit in no set order instantly changes the overall pressure drop and upsets the previous settings. Adjusting a supply outlet in one office pushes air back towards the neighbouring rooms. The fitter moves from floor to floor without the setpoint values ever converging. To stabilise the distribution, the proportional method requires each subassembly to be treated as a series of constant ratios, regardless of the total flow delivered by the air handling unit.
- Reference outlet
- Diffuser or grille of a section that shows the lowest ratio between the measured flow and the design setpoint flow, with all branch dampers initially open at one hundred per cent.
Before any measurement with a flow hood or a Pitot tube, the air circuit must be completely cleared. The fire protection dampers are armed in the open position, the unit filters are clean and the balancing dampers or branch dampers are fully open. A first quick measurement sweep records the raw flows at each terminal. Calculating the balancing coefficient for each diffuser immediately guides the rest of the adjustment.
| Terminal unit | Design flow (m³/h) | Measured flow, open (m³/h) | Measured / design ratio | Component status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Diffuser B1 (branch base) | 250 | 340 | 1.36 | Favoured by pressure |
| Diffuser B2 (intermediate) | 200 | 220 | 1.10 | Intermediate |
| Diffuser B3 (intermediate) | 180 | 175 | 0.97 | Intermediate |
| Diffuser B4 (end of duct) | 300 | 210 | 0.70 | Reference outlet (lowest) |
Apply the proportional adjustment step by step and check the SIA 382/1 tolerance
The proportional method rests on a physical law of fluids: changing the overall resistance of a section changes the total flow, but preserves the ratio of flows between outlets that have previously been paired. Once two terminals show the same ratio between measured flow and theoretical flow, they remain synchronised. One therefore works step by step from the most disadvantaged component up to the damper at the base of the branch, never going back to outlets already dealt with.
- Positioning the instruments and assigning the two-person teamA first operator continuously monitors the reference outlet B4 with a calibrated flow meter. The second operator takes position at the unit immediately upstream, namely diffuser B3.
- Aligning the upstream flow ratioThe operator adjusts the damper of diffuser B3 so that its ratio of measured flow to setpoint becomes strictly identical to the one recorded at the same moment on B4. The knock-on effect slightly increases the flow at B4, which changes the raw value but stabilises the common ratio.
- Working step by step towards the origin of the networkThe second operator moves to diffuser B2, while monitoring continues on B4. They throttle B2 until the same shared ratio is obtained. The operation is repeated for terminal B1 at the base of the duct.
- Setting the branch flow at the floor damperOnce all the diffusers are set to the same proportional factor, the branch forms a rigid assembly. Adjusting the main balancing damper brings the whole branch to one hundred per cent of the required flow.
- Final adjustment of the fan with the variable speed driveWhen all the main branches are balanced against one another, the speed of the unit's fan is adjusted to its nominal setpoint while checking the minimum static pressure required.
The air balancing report records the final measured values, the angular position of the manual dampers and the electrical operating point of the motor-driven fan. These measurements provide formal proof that the adjustment was carried out in accordance with the rules of the trade, in line with the obligation of careful performance arising from the contract for work and services governed by the Code of Obligations (CO), in particular art. 364 CO on the contractor's general liability in carrying out the work.
From terminal to collector: setting the main branches using the proportional method
Once the outlets of a single riser have been balanced against one another, that section behaves as a rigid airflow block: any variation in the supply pressure changes the flow at each outlet in a strictly identical proportion. Trying to adjust a branch by reworking the terminal diffusers destroys the alignment achieved and forces the team to start all the rounds again. The flow setting must therefore change scale: the diffusers are no longer touched, and only the floor balancing dampers or the main branch dampers are used to balance the branches against one another on the distribution network.
The approach faithfully reproduces the logic applied to the terminal units. With all the branch dampers of the supply network first opened to 100 %, the operator measures the total flow passing through each branch. This measurement is taken in a straight duct, upstream of any branch-off, by traversing point by point with a Pitot tube or with calibrated measuring crosses. For each branch, the airflow ratio lambda is the measured overall flow divided by the nominal flow required by the design. The reference branch is necessarily the one with the lowest lambda ratio in the network: it is the circuit most disadvantaged by the linear and local pressure drops of the primary distribution.
| Branch designation | Design flow [m³/h] | Initial flow, damper open [m³/h] | Initial ratio λ | Action on balancing damper | Final ratio λ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Branch 1 (Floor 1 - close to AHU) | 1200 | 1620 | 1.35 | Progressive closing set against branch 2 | 0.84 |
| Branch 2 (Floor 2) | 1400 | 1610 | 1.15 | Progressive closing set against branch 3 | 0.84 |
| Branch 3 (Floor 3) | 1100 | 1045 | 0.95 | Progressive closing set against branch 4 | 0.84 |
| Branch 4 (Floor 4 - foot of riser) | 1500 | 1260 | 0.84 | Reference: damper kept at 100 % | 0.84 |
The damper of the reference branch stays wide open. Starting with the immediately neighbouring branch and working back towards the air handling unit, the technician operates the balancing damper of the active branch until its lambda ratio equals that of the reference branch. This operation is repeated in turn for each floor. While a damper is being closed, part of the air is pushed back towards the other sections, raising their flow at the same time but leaving the internal ratios already set intact. When all the branches show a uniform lambda ratio, the complete air distribution tree is proportionally balanced.
Extract network, pressure balance and checking the SIA 382/1 tolerances
The return and extract air network undergoes exactly the same proportional balancing sequence as the supply network. The return dampers are opened to 100 %, the most disadvantaged return outlet is designated as the reference outlet, then the dampers at the foot of the riser and at the branch-offs are adjusted branch by branch. Treating the extract side independently or by guesswork compromises the relative overpressure or negative pressure of the rooms, causing uncontrolled odour transfer or doors slamming in circulation areas.
Once proportional balance has been established on both the supply and the return, all the dampers in the building are locked mechanically with their locking screw or toothed quadrant. All that remains is to align the overall flow of the installation with the overall setpoint by varying the rotation speed of the fans in the packaged unit via the frequency converters. Raising the speed shifts all the flows uniformly: if the lambda ratios of every outlet and every branch were fixed at 0.84, increasing the fan setpoint will bring all the terminals to a ratio of 1.00 without any local rework.
The commissioning report CFC 244 records the method applied, the calibration certificates of the measuring instruments, the values measured at each diffuser and the angular position of the main dampers. This document demonstrates formally to the client that the installation meets the acoustic and thermal comfort requirements while optimising the electrical power absorbed by the motors.
Measurement drift and failure to converge: diagnosing the network fault
When the rigorous application of the proportional method does not stabilise the ratios, or when a diffuser remains consistently under-supplied despite its adjusting device being fully open, continuing to operate the dampers is pointless. This mechanical blockage points to a structural airflow fault on the section concerned: a flexible duct crushed behind a partition, a tee connection badly oriented and creating local turbulence, or early clogging of a terminal filter caused by construction site dust.
| Symptom on site | Probable airflow cause | Corrective action required |
|---|---|---|
| Ratio impossible to equalise on the most disadvantaged outlet | Excessive local airflow resistance or damaged duct | Remove the diffuser, inspect the duct with a mirror or camera, correct the bend radius. |
| Reference outlet changing illogically during setting | Upstream dampers not locked or major leak at the collector | Check the mechanical tightness of the linkages and check the tightness of the flexible connectors. |
| High-pitched air whistling at the outlets near the riser | Residual static pressure too high in the plenum | Reduce the fan speed at the variable speed drive before throttling the terminals. |
| Overall deviation greater than the flow tolerance per room | Total flow insufficient or wrong selection of pulley/motor | Measure the total pressure at the fan and recalibrate the overall operating point. |
Before any complete re-measurement, the technical team makes sure that the grilles are clean, that the balancing dampers move freely and that the fire doors or communicating doors are stable when closed. If a change of routing proves indispensable to remove an abnormal pressure drop, the initial reading is the reference for recording the physical impossibility of achieving balance without adaptation work on the network.
Frequently asked questions
Why must one always start with the most disadvantaged outlet?
The most disadvantaged outlet has the highest hydraulic resistance in the network. By choosing it as the first reference, its damper stays open at 100 %. By then progressively throttling the more favoured outlets located upstream, air is pushed towards this terminal without ever having to throttle it. Proceeding the other way round would force all the dampers of the installation to be closed, needlessly increasing the total pressure drop and the motor's consumption.
How should one react if the total extracted air flow does not match the supply?
The pressure balance of the building depends on this difference. Start by checking the condition of the extract and supply filters on the air handling unit, then the airtightness of the access doors. Next, check the rotation speed of the two fans using the frequency converters. The overall adjustment of the installation is always made on the main machines before refining the distribution room by room using the proportional method.
Is it necessary to remove the supply diffusers to measure the velocity in the duct?
No, the acceptance measurement is made directly on the terminals in place, so as to include their real pressure drop and their spatial air diffusion. A sealed measuring hood is used, combined with a differential manometer or a calibrated vane anemometer, sized to the geometry of the grille. Drilling for a Pitot tube in the rigid upstream duct is reserved for branch flows or inaccessible extract ducts.
What is the acoustic consequence of a balancing damper that is closed too far?
An excessively throttled damper creates a large local pressure drop that generates high-velocity air turbulence. These eddies produce a whistling or airflow regeneration noise transmitted directly into the adjacent room through the diffuser. If the dynamic pressure is too high near the riser, the fan pressure setpoint should be lowered rather than throttling the terminal dampers, in order to meet the sound comfort criteria.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 382/1Ventilation and air-conditioning installations - General principles and required performance for the distribution and tolerance of air flows
- norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work and procedures for the acceptance of works
