Key takeaways
- A damper throttled by more than fifty per cent generates direct whistling that is very difficult to attenuate.
- The velocity in the terminal duct must absolutely remain low to preserve acoustic comfort in the rooms.
- Airflow balancing is achieved primarily through a methodical hierarchy of cross-sections and pressure losses.
- Differential measurement and adjustment at the fan avoid needlessly restricting the terminal units.
Understanding how airflow whistling originates at dampers and diffusers
On a ventilation construction site, the high-pitched whistling that appears at commissioning only very rarely comes from the fan itself. In the great majority of cases, this aerodynamic noise originates at a balancing device or an air diffuser. When a fitter or commissioning technician tries to correct an excess flow on an over-favoured branch by closing a butterfly damper or a balancing damper beyond half of its travel, the free cross-section is drastically reduced. The air accelerates violently there, causing flow separation, intense turbulence and the emission of a piercing pure tone at medium and high frequencies.
The SIA 382/1 standard defines the calculation bases and comfort criteria for ventilation and air-conditioning installations. It warns against flow noise caused by poorly designed singularities. The noise generated by a restriction increases with a very high power of the relative velocity of the fluid. Doubling the local velocity at a metal edge can increase the emitted sound power by more than fifteen to eighteen decibels. This is why a damper closed by two thirds to dissipate an overpressure systematically whistles much louder than the supply outlet at its end.
| Duct section | Recommended velocity | Consequence of exceeding it |
|---|---|---|
| Main duct in plant room | 6.0 to 7.5 m/s | High pressure losses, noise transmitted to the walls |
| Distribution duct in corridor | 4.0 to 5.0 m/s | Risk of regenerated noise at bends and branch connections |
| Terminal connection duct | 2.0 to 3.0 m/s | Audible whistling appears in the rooms |
| Effective air passage at the outlet | 1.5 to 2.5 m/s | Perceptible air rush and direct acoustic discomfort |
When the effective velocity through the slots of a diffuser or a return grille exceeds the permissible values, the geometry of the vanes acts like a whistle. If the upstream dynamic pressure has not been calmed in an insulated plenum or by a gradual diverging section, the air jet strikes the deflectors with maximum turbulence. Treating this defect requires reviewing the flow well upstream of the grille.
Applying clean balancing through sizing and pressure management
Real prevention of throttling noise begins on the layout drawings and is put into practice during installation through strict compliance with the diameters. To deliver a quiet installation, the network must be balanced naturally by calculating the cross-sections rather than by mechanical braking at the ends. If a branch close to the air handling unit has too high a residual pressure compared with the most disadvantaged branch, this energy must be absorbed upstream, away from occupied areas, or prevented by a branched network with staged pressure losses.
- Adjusting the machine set pointBefore touching the terminal dampers, adjust the overall fan speed at the frequency drive. If all the dampers in the network end up restricted to fifty per cent, the unit is blowing with excessive static pressure.
- Attenuation upstream of the silencersPlace the zone balancing dampers in technical corridors or immediately at the outlet of the risers, systematically upstream of the secondary duct silencers.
- Methodical balancing branch by branchFirst adjust the main branch damper to set the branch pressure, keeping the terminal units near sensitive rooms open to the maximum.
- Checking effective velocities at the outletsMeasure the actual outlet velocity at the diffuser with a flow hood or hot-wire anemometer to make sure it remains below the critical background-noise threshold of the room.
- Balancing by sizing
- Design and installation method that adapts the duct diameters and the profile of the transition pieces to equalise the pressure losses of each branch at nominal flow, without resorting to excessive mechanical restriction by a damper.
On new construction sites or when converting office buildings, art. 364 CO recalls the contractor's obligation to perform diligently, implementing works that comply with the rules of the trade. If the design office has specified undersized ducts connected directly to narrow terminals, the team leader or site foreman must report the acoustic risk before the false ceilings are closed. Installing fixed perforated diaphragms in galvanised sheet steel, calculated to dissipate the pressure in a distributed way, often gives a much quieter flow than a single-blade damper set askew in the airstream.
Limit flow velocities according to SIA 382/1 and network acoustics
The initial sizing of the ducts dictates the final sound environment of an office or residential building. When the fitter tries to compensate for an excess flow by closing a terminal control damper, the free cross-section contracts abruptly. This localised restriction raises the passage velocity well above the permitted values, causing turbulent vortices and high-frequency whistling noise (above 1000 Hz). According to SIA 382/1, controlling acoustic comfort in sensitive rooms relies on a rigorous reduction of air velocities from the air handling unit to the diffusers, and prohibits terminal throttling to absorb excess static pressure.
| Network section | Maximum velocity | Dynamic pressure | Acoustic impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main collector in service shaft | 4.5 to 5.5 m/s | 12 to 18 Pa | Low-frequency noise handled by central silencer |
| Secondary branch in corridor false ceiling | 3.0 to 3.5 m/s | 5 to 8 Pa | Moderate turbulence in circulation area |
| Terminal branch connection to plenum | 2.0 to 2.5 m/s | 2 to 4 Pa | Flow without regenerated whistling |
| Effective passage at the supply outlet | 1.5 to 2.0 m/s | 1 to 2 Pa | Residual noise level compliant with requirements |
The discharge velocity through the slots or perforations of the diffuser determines the sound power emitted into the room. As soon as the effective face velocity exceeds 2.2 m/s, the turbulent wake formed around the metal blades produces a continuous rush of air that the plenum cannot attenuate. This self-generated noise originates from the outlet itself. If the upstream network has excessive pressure, the damper built into the collar acts like a nozzle: its partial throttling generates a sound power level often 10 to 15 dB(A) higher than that of a fully open outlet receiving the correct nominal flow.
Site methodology: balance through the layout rather than through throttling
On the ventilation construction site, balancing must never consist of restricting the dampers located immediately next to the diffusers. To prevent noise nuisance, art. 22 OLT 3 provides that noise and vibrations must be avoided or combated, in particular through construction measures and on operating installations. The ventilation tradesperson has concrete methods to harmonise the network pressure losses without throttling the terminal cross-sections.
- Adjusting the overall pressure at the fanBefore touching the branch dampers, measure the static pressure at the outlet of the air handling unit. If all the rooms of a branch are overpressurised, adjust the set point of the frequency drive. Reducing the rotation speed lowers the available pressure and removes the need to throttle the diffusers.
- Shifting the balancing to the secondary branchesClose first the dampers located upstream in the service shafts or corridors, where the noise generated remains tolerable and can be absorbed by a secondary silencer. Leave the terminal damper only a fine flow adjustment not exceeding 10 % closure.
- Adapting the sections of favoured ductsOn a short branch connection near the riser, replace an abrupt reduction with a duct of suitable cross-section or insert a circular acoustic silencer. This distributed pressure loss reduces the pressure without creating a sharp edge that generates turbulence.
- Replacing simple dampers with calibrated elementsReplace an over-pinched butterfly damper with a fixed multi-perforated diaphragm or a self-regulating cartridge installed upstream. Splitting the flow into multiple micro-jets avoids the concentrated whistling of a single strongly inclined blade.
A correctly balanced network emits no whistling, because its pressure losses are absorbed by the progressive sizing of the sections rather than by last-minute mechanical pinching. At the acceptance stage, measuring flow rates with an anemometer hood and checking pressures with a Pitot tube ensure that flow tolerances are met while preserving the acoustic comfort of the occupants.
Rectification protocol for a whistling network and bringing it into compliance
When the acoustic acceptance of an office or residential building fails because of high-pitched whistling on a balanced-flow ventilation installation, the mistaken reflex is commonly to tighten the vanes of the outlet or to line the plenum with mineral wool. This empirical attempt increases the effective air velocity and shifts the noise towards very high frequencies that are highly perceptible to the building's users. Faced with a balancing damper that whistles because of excessive overpressure, the installation team must intervene on the overall airflow dynamics of the circuit rather than create additional air throttling.
- Diagnosis and differential pressure measurementMeasure the pressure loss precisely on either side of the device with a digital differential manometer. Any damper generating a localised pressure loss greater than fifty pascals on a terminal branch produces violent vortex shedding, the immediate cause of a pure whistling that the smooth walls of the duct can hardly absorb.
- Reopening the damper and resetting the fanFully reopen the offending damper and check the overall flow of the branch. If the network shows generalised overpressure, lower the fan rotation frequency at the drive of the air handling unit rather than needlessly wasting drive energy through mechanical throttling at the branch connections.
- Spreading the resistance and acoustic attenuationOn a short, strongly favoured branch, replace the rectangular or butterfly damper with an iris damper providing a centred circular restriction. Systematically insert a flexible or rigid absorptive acoustic silencer between the balancing device and the air diffuser to trap the residual sound spectrum.
According to SIA 382/1, clean balancing relies on the proportional method, which requires the damper of the most disadvantaged branch to remain one hundred per cent open. Air velocities must be scrupulously checked: less than five metres per second in the main collector, less than three metres per second in the terminal duct and at most two metres per second over the effective area of the supply outlets. A sound-level survey in octave bands validates the attenuation of the tonal spectrum before the acceptance report is signed.
Frequently asked questions
Why does a damper closed to 70 % whistle even though the airflow complies with the drawings?
When the blade of a butterfly damper is strongly closed, the air passage cross-section is reduced abruptly. The local flow velocity then accelerates considerably, creating a shear wave and unstable vortices against the metal walls. This turbulence generates a pure-tone noise, perceived as a piercing whistle. Even if the volumetric flow in cubic metres per hour complies with the drawings, the dissipated pressure energy is entirely converted into noise nuisance.
What is the maximum recommended velocity at the diffuser outlet to avoid any noise in an open-plan office?
In an open-plan office or a conference room, the flow velocity over the free area of the air diffuser must not exceed two metres per second. Beyond this critical value, the diffusion slots and vanes tear the air stream and produce a disturbing continuous rush of air. If the dynamic pressure at the plenum inlet remains too high, the size of the grille should be increased rather than attempting to throttle upstream.
Can the balancing damper be omitted if the airflow network has been correctly calculated?
In theory, a network balanced naturally by geometric pressure losses and progressive diameter reductions needs very few adjustment devices. However, installation tolerances, duct roughness and real construction-site singularities always require minor adjustments. Keeping iris dampers or balancing dampers remains essential, but they must work within opening ranges between fifty and one hundred per cent to preserve acoustic comfort.
What should be done if the unit's fan is already running at its minimum speed and the outlets still whistle?
If the frequency drive of the air handling unit is already at its minimum and the overpressure makes the terminals whistle, the ventilation unit is oversized. Two emergency measures are required on the construction site: install a relief damper with silencer to divert the surplus flow to the return, or fit a secondary sound trap with thick baffles directly at the unit outlet to dissipate the excess dynamic pressure.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 382/1Ventilation and air-conditioning installations - General principles and required performance (acoustic criteria and flow velocities)
