Key takeaways
- Compliance with SIA 181 requires targeted attenuation starting at the low frequency of 125 Hertz.
- Placing the silencer immediately at the air handling unit outlet prevents noise from travelling into the distribution ducts.
- Baffle thickness and free airway width determine the overall pressure drop of the ventilation network.
- Retrofitting a forgotten silencer after the false ceiling has been installed multiplies the initial cost by five for the remedial work.
Baffle sizing and acoustic tuning at the air handling unit outlet
Sizing a baffle silencer starts with analysing the acoustic spectrum emitted by the supply or extract fan unit. The fan generates sound power distributed over eight standardised octave bands, from 63 Hz to 8000 Hz. The required attenuation is calculated by subtracting from the raw sound level the natural attenuation of the network, such as changes of direction, branches and the linear attenuation of the ducts, in order to reach the sound level permissible in the room according to SIA 181. The low frequencies, in particular 125 Hz and 250 Hz, systematically determine the baffle thickness. An absorbent splitter 100 mm thick works effectively on the mid and high frequencies, but is insufficient to contain the dull hum of a fan wheel. To treat frequencies below 250 Hz properly without multiplying the total duct length, the ventilation installer selects 200 mm thick baffles, made of mineral wool faced with a glass tissue that prevents fibre shedding up to an air velocity of 20 m/s.
- Effective length of a silencer
- Axial length of the absorbent section of the baffles, excluding the aerodynamic entry and exit profiles. This is the dimension that governs the real acoustic attenuation through friction and resonance in the airflow.
| Frequency (Hz) | 100 mm baffle (L = 1000 mm) | 200 mm baffle (L = 1000 mm) | 200 mm baffle (L = 1500 mm) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 125 | 4 dB | 8 dB | 13 dB |
| 250 | 9 dB | 16 dB | 24 dB |
| 500 | 18 dB | 28 dB | 39 dB |
| 1000 | 27 dB | 36 dB | 48 dB |
| 2000 | 22 dB | 25 dB | 35 dB |
The internal geometry dictates the aeraulic pressure drop and the self-generated noise. Reducing the free space between the baffles to less than 80 mm artificially increases the acoustic attenuation, but squeezes the air passage section. The velocity between the baffles then climbs above 5.5 m/s, generating trailing-edge turbulence that feeds noise back into the airstream while sending the dynamic pressure soaring. To keep the pressure drop below 40 Pa on a straight casing, a maximum face velocity of 2.5 m/s and half-round profiled leading edges are preferred. The physical position of the casing in the plant room is just as decisive. The silencer must be installed at the immediate discharge of the air handling unit, before any slab or fire-wall penetration. Installing the casing three metres away leaves the bare sheet-metal duct to radiate acoustic energy directly into the plant room, contaminating adjoining rooms by indirect transmission through the neighbouring structures.
Omission at the costing stage: false-ceiling removal and the extra cost of catching up
Leaving out a distribution silencer when the quote or the technical coordination is prepared is a classic trap on commercial-building networks. When a compact air handling unit serves offices or conference rooms through a shared corridor, the absence of an attenuator in the false ceiling inevitably leads to failure in the acceptance acoustic measurements. The client can then assert the rights of the client in case of defects under art. 368 CO, demanding rectification of the work to meet the mandatory requirements of SIA 181. The ventilation installation, already connected, balanced and concealed behind a removable suspended ceiling or a plasterboard ceiling, must be modified in full on a live site.
- Careful removal of the false ceilingRemoving the panels or cutting out the plasterboard, dismantling the metal framework and protecting the floors beneath the duct section concerned.
- Removal of the existing networkRemoving the connecting sleeves, detaching the anti-vibration hangers and nibbling out the galvanised ducts that have become redundant.
- Installation and connection of the silencerFixing the new support rails on elastomer pads, lifting the baffle casing into place and making a sealed connection with flanged frames and gaskets.
- Making good and rebalancingRebuilding the false ceiling by the finishing work trades, paint touch-ups, readjusting the damper settings to compensate for the added pressure drop and a new round of sound level measurements.
The economic impact of such a catch-up is out of all proportion to the purchase of a standard attenuator casing at the initial order stage. Whereas a manufactured silencer can be incorporated for an amount in the order of CHF 400 to 900 depending on its section, the complete corrective operation in a false ceiling generates an overall expense that can reach in the order of CHF 3,000 to 6,000 per added unit. This amount includes work during night hours or on an occupied site, removal and refitting labour, the intervention of the plasterer-painter, the recycling of the removed sheet metal and the redoing of the airflow balancing. On top of this direct shortfall comes the extension of the final delivery date, which may block the release of the warranty retentions when the final account of the work is settled.
Spectral tuning of the baffles and airflow control
Compliance with the noise protection requirements set by SIA 181 demands a rigorous selection of absorption silencers. The acoustic emission spectrum of an air-handling fan concentrates its energy in the low and medium frequencies, more particularly in the 125 Hz and 250 Hz octave bands. A global selection based solely on dBA almost always leads to underestimating the space needed. Acoustic baffles of mineral wool faced with a glass tissue work by mechanical dissipation of the sound wave. To effectively reduce the sound emergence at 125 Hz, the splitter thickness must be increased to 200 mm, with an air passage gap of between 100 and 150 mm. Reducing this thickness to 100 mm in order to limit the space required shifts the attenuation peak towards the high frequencies of 1000 to 4000 Hz, while letting the low frequencies through without any appreciable reduction.
| Frequency (Hz) | Attenuation L = 1000 mm (dB) | Attenuation L = 1500 mm (dB) | Attenuation L = 2000 mm (dB) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 63 | 3 | 4 | 6 |
| 125 | 7 | 11 | 15 |
| 250 | 13 | 20 | 27 |
| 500 | 22 | 33 | 42 |
| 1000 | 30 | 44 | 50 |
| 2000 | 24 | 36 | 45 |
| 4000 | 16 | 24 | 31 |
The overall acoustic efficiency increases with the effective length of the splitters, but this length inevitably increases the resistance to airflow. The flow velocity between the baffles governs the dynamic pressure drop and the self-generated noise. When the velocity between the baffles exceeds 5 m/s, the turbulence creates its own flow noise that degrades the silence achieved, while also increasing the fan's electrical consumption. The casing must therefore be enlarged relative to the standard duct by means of gradual transition pieces, with an angle not exceeding 15° to prevent air separation.
Location in the network and overall cost of rework
The physical location of the silencer relative to the air handling unit determines its performance. Placing the unit directly against the fan discharge flange subjects the splitters to an asymmetric, turbulent airflow, which generates parasitic whistling and doubles the calculated pressure drop. A straight stabilisation section, of at least one hydraulic diameter, must separate the machine outlet from the silencer inlet. Conversely, installing the sound trap too far downstream in the building creates a destructive phenomenon: the noise present in the sheet-metal duct radiates through the metal walls and enters the rooms it passes through before the flow reaches the baffles.
Leaving a silencer out of the quote, or underestimating the space required at the design stage, causes serious damage at acceptance. Under art. 368 CO, the client may demand rectification of the work in case of defects. In technical execution, the late integration of a silencer is not limited to inserting an element into the planned route. Since the silencer requires a doubled passage section to maintain the air velocities, its footprint collides head-on with the electrical cable bundles, gravity drainage lines and fire-suppression pipes already installed.
Rework carried out after the suspended ceilings have been installed causes complete disruption of the finishing work. It requires removing the acoustic tiles, cutting the drywall rails, modifying the duct hangers, diverting the adjacent services of other trades and repainting. Whereas the supply and installation of a silencer in the initial phase represents a cost in the order of CHF 1,200 to 2,600 on a standard commercial network (details and pricing under /soumissions/), reworking it in a finished building generates costs in the order of CHF 8,500 to 16,000 spread between the various trades. Integrating these geometric constraints from the preliminary design stage is the only way to avoid this dead loss.
Remedial protocol when an acoustic limit is exceeded at acceptance
When the acceptance measurements reveal non-compliance with the limit values of SIA 181, opening up the false ceilings immediately is a tactical mistake. A global reduction in fan power solves nothing without altering the hygienic airflow rates validated by the planning application file. The installation team and the site manager must carry out a rigorous technical sequence to correct the situation without unnecessary demolition.
- In-situ spectral characterisationMeasure the noise per frequency band with a sound level meter in the receiving room in order to identify the exact origin of the deviation. A marked emergence at 125 Hz or 250 Hz betrays a casing that is too short or baffles that are too thin at the air handling unit outlet. An emergence above 1000 Hz reveals flow noise or turbulent regeneration at a poorly profiled damper slot.
- Airflow balance and pressure drop checkRecord the static pressure available at the fan terminals. Any modification of the silencer affects the network: fitting a longer casing or narrowing the air passages between baffles increases the local pressure drop. It must be checked on the manufacturer's curve whether the motor can accept this extra load without crossing its stall point.
- Choice of location in the plant roomAlways give priority to working in the plant room rather than in the occupied area. If there is not enough axial space to lengthen the main silencer in a straight line, consider installing an elbow silencer with absorbent baffles or integrating a sound trap housed directly in the discharge plenum of the air handling unit.
- Acoustic splitting and secondary silencersIf the plant room is full, split the attenuation. Install secondary cylindrical or rectangular silencers immediately upstream of the terminal diffusers. This solution places the access hatch openings in circulation corridors and avoids removing the ceiling tiles or plasterboard in full in offices and dwellings.
Frequently asked questions
How should a high-pitched whistle appearing immediately at the outlet of a silencer be dealt with?
This whistle indicates regenerated aero-acoustic noise caused by excessive air velocity in the free airways of the silencer. If the velocity between the baffles exceeds 5 metres per second, friction produces its own noise. The correction requires enlarging the cross-section of the casing to reduce the flow velocity, or fitting baffles equipped with aerodynamic deflector noses at the inlet and outlet.
Why does acoustic attenuation below 250 Hz require such long silencers?
Low-frequency sound waves have long wavelengths, reaching nearly three metres at 125 Hz. To dissipate this energy through porosity, the mineral wool must provide a minimum thickness of 200 millimetres and a considerable effective length of travel, often more than 1.50 metres. A standard compact casing only absorbs the mid and high frequencies, letting through the dull rumble characteristic of air handling units.
Can a silencer that is too short be compensated for by narrowing the space between the baffles?
Narrowing the air passages improves the overall acoustic attenuation, but this change makes the local pressure drop of the network soar. The increased resistance forces the fan to run faster to maintain the specified airflow rates, which generates additional sound power at the source. Any narrowing of the air passages must be followed by a precise recalculation of the aeraulic operating point, otherwise the fan will be overloaded.
What distance should be kept between the fan of the air handling unit and the first silencer?
A straight distance equivalent to at least three hydraulic diameters should be maintained after the fan before reaching the silencer. Installing baffles directly on the discharge without an expansion box produces an uneven distribution of the airstream. This asymmetric profile causes excessive local velocities, saturates part of the absorbent material and severely degrades the spectral attenuation calculated by the manufacturer according to the rules of the art.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 181Noise protection in buildings
- norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work
