Key takeaways
- Octave-band measurement distinguishes fan noise from the whistling of terminal units.
- Reducing the flow velocity below two metres per second eliminates regenerated noise from the dampers.
- A compact sound attenuator can be fitted through the access hatches without destroying the ceilings.
- The client applies art. 368 CO to demand rectification of work that does not comply with the tolerances.
Spectral diagnosis and airflow corrections without demolition
During the acoustic acceptance measurements of a penthouse apartment, an exceedance of seven decibels over the requirements of SIA 181 holds up the acceptance of the work. Before touching the linings or the finished suspended ceilings, the ventilation installer must characterise the physical nature of the noise using a class 1 integrating sound level meter. A low-frequency emergence, between 125 Hz and 250 Hz, directly indicates transmission from the floor or roof fan through the sheet-metal duct network. Conversely, a whistling or broadband hiss above 1000 Hz almost always results from excessive air velocity at a control device or at the terminal diffuser.
- Pressure readings and set-point checkConnect a differential manometer to the pressure taps of the air handling unit. Excessive residual static pressure in the riser overloads the terminal branches of the penthouse. Lowering the set point of the electronically commutated fan often brings the velocity in the ducts back below the critical limits.
- Anemometer measurement and branch rebalancingCheck the airflow at each supply and extract terminal using a calibrated measuring hood. Excessive throttling at the balancing dampers creates major local turbulence. Reopen the local damper and compensate for the excess airflow upstream, directly on the main branch damper located in an accessible service shaft.
- Replacing or reorienting the terminal diffusersIf the ceiling air diffuser generates an audible local pressure loss, remove its grille to measure the noise level with the terminal bare. If the difference exceeds four decibels, replace the unit with a model with a larger free passage area or a helical geometry that creates less aeraulic friction.
Reducing both the overall airflow and the passage velocity is the most economical and entirely non-destructive solution. By lowering the air velocity from 3.5 m/s to 2.1 m/s in the terminal duct serving the penthouse, the regenerated sound power level drops by about six decibels. However, this change can only be validated if the minimum hygienic airflows required for the air renewal of the apartment remain strictly met at the terminals.
Fitting a secondary sound attenuator and contractual management
When airflow adjustments are not enough to make up the seven decibels of excess without impairing the required air renewal, an acoustic component must be installed. In a penthouse, the direct proximity of the rooftop unit or the short length of network between the service shaft and the diffusers means very high-efficiency solutions with minimal bulk must be chosen.
- Exploring the plenum by endoscopeInsert an inspection camera through the access hatch or through the existing cut-out of a supply terminal. The aim is to identify an accessible straight duct section in the false ceiling without having to tear out the painted plasterboard.
- Fitting a compact circular attenuatorRemove a section of existing helical circular duct between the riser and the distribution box. In its place, fit a compact circular silencer with baffles or absorption lining, 600 mm to 900 mm long, connected with lipped couplings fitted with elastomer gaskets to preserve class C airtightness.
- Fitting an in-line acoustic cartridgeIf it is completely impossible to slip in a rigid attenuator, insert a cylindrical open-cell foam cartridge directly inside the rigid duct through the terminal opening. This device provides targeted attenuation of three to six decibels in the mid frequencies without any metalwork or masonry work.
| Corrective action | Average acoustic gain | Level of site intervention | Impact on the installation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fan speed reduction | -3 to -5 dB(A) | None (programming on the drive) | Overall reduction in airflows |
| Low-loss diffuser replacement | -2 to -4 dB(A) | Low (replacement of the terminal grille) | Change in the throw of the jet |
| Foam cartridge in duct | -3 to -6 dB(A) | Low (insertion through the collar) | Moderate increase in pressure loss |
| Circular absorption silencer | -6 to -10 dB(A) | Medium (partial removal through hatch) | Space taken up in the plenum |
Hierarchy of corrective measures in a penthouse: from adjustment to opening the false ceiling
An acoustic exceedance of seven decibels in a penthouse is a major non-conformity. In building acoustics, an increase of this size corresponds to more than a doubling of the acoustic energy perceived by the occupant. Faced with this finding from the final tests of a controlled mechanical ventilation or air-handling installation, the installation team must act according to a strict protocol, graded from the least destructive to the most invasive for the finishing work.
The first action is to work on the airflow itself by reducing flow and velocity. If the installation has an oversizing margin relative to the hygiene requirements, the frequency drive of the compact unit allows the impeller speed to be lowered. According to the fan affinity laws, the overall noise generated by a fan decreases by about fifty times the logarithm of the ratio of the rotational speeds. A speed reduction of ten to fifteen per cent lowers the emitted sound power by three to four decibels at the source, without touching the structure of the network.
Where the minimum hygienic airflow tolerates no overall reduction, the adjustment turns to the distribution of pressure losses in the terminal network. If a balancing damper or floor damper placed immediately upstream of the penthouse is too heavily closed to compensate for riser overpressure, it generates a turbulence whistle that is transmitted directly to the supply terminals. Opening this damper, combined with redistributing the throttling to the lower branches or at the immediate outlet of the unit, relaxes the airflow upstream and brings local velocities below two metres per second.
| Type of intervention | Specific technical action | Target attenuation | Impact on interior finishes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Airflow adjustment at the source | Reducing fan speed and readjusting the set-point curves | 2 to 4 dB(A) | None (work confined to the ventilation plant room) |
| Optimisation of terminal units | Replacing diffusers with wide-passage models or sound-insulated plenums | 2 to 3 dB(A) | Very low (simple removal of grilles and diffusers without breakage) |
| Secondary circular silencer | Fitting an absorption sound attenuator on the horizontal floor duct | 4 to 8 dB(A) | Moderate (creating an inspection hatch or a surgical opening in the false ceiling) |
| Major duct modification | Replacing the main section with an additional acoustic baffle | 8 to 12 dB(A) | High (demolition of plasterboard, repainting and insulation repairs) |
If the airflow adjustment and the replacement of grilles with terminals with a lower outlet velocity prove insufficient to make up the seven decibels, a supplementary silencer must be fitted. To limit demolition in an apartment with completed finishes, the fitter locates a corridor or a circulation false ceiling where a surgical removal remains possible. The tradesman cuts a plasterboard panel to the exact dimensions of a standard inspection hatch, removes a straight section of spiral duct and inserts a rigid circular silencer with absorbent baffles and no exposed mineral wool. This supplementary component must have a minimal pressure loss so as not to force the fan to work harder, which would cancel out the acoustic benefit obtained.
Classification of the acoustic defect, applicable standards and management of the retention
Under Swiss regulations, SIA 181 sets the requirements applicable to noise generated by the technical installations of the building in noise-sensitive rooms. The permissible rating sound levels differ depending on whether minimum requirements or the enhanced requirements common in high-standard penthouse apartments apply. A difference of seven decibels far exceeds measurement uncertainties and in no case falls within an admissible tolerance.
The minimum requirements must be met in all cases to protect users against harmful or nuisance effects due to noise from technical installations. The enhanced requirements apply where the contract or the specifications expressly stipulate them in order to guarantee superior acoustic comfort.
Norme SIA 181
As soon as the acoustic report drawn up by the acoustician of the consulting engineer is notified, site management classifies this difference as a defect in the work. In accordance with art. 367 CO, the client checks the condition of the work as soon as it is able to and notifies the contractor of any defects. This written complaint blocks the final validation of the ventilation installations and triggers the legal remedies provided by the Code of Obligations (CO) as well as the rectification regime established by SIA 118 where the latter is incorporated into the works contract.
The exercise of the client's rights falls within art. 368 CO, which opens the possibility of demanding rectification of the work free of charge if the work does not require excessive expense. In practice, the client applies a substantial financial retention on the final account or on the payment certificates of the CFC 244 package. The amount withheld generally corresponds to the estimated cost of the complete rectification work, including supply of the new sound attenuator and duct connections, but also the cost of making good the false ceilings, joints and paintwork carried out by the finishing work trades.
The financial retention is only released after the documented execution of the corrective measures and an official acoustic counter-measurement. The ventilation installer then presents a joint measurement record confirming that the target values have been reached, together with airflow sheets certifying that the air volumes required at the penthouse terminals are scrupulously met.
Arbitration protocol and remedial measures in a penthouse
When acoustic measurements reveal a persistent difference of seven decibels from the requirements of SIA 181 in an attic or penthouse apartment, the site foreman must lead a methodical escalation of solutions. If simple airflow adjustment on the motorised dampers or reducing the fan set-point speed does not make up the shortfall without degrading the hygienic air change rates, physical intervention on the network becomes unavoidable before the client blocks payments.
- Adjusting airflows and checking pressuresThe first action is to measure each supply diffuser with a flow hood. In written agreement with the ventilation engineer, the residual air velocities at the terminals are lowered below two metres per second, while maintaining the pressure needed at the terminals. This airflow reduction frequently gains two to three decibels without any hardware changes.
- Fitting a secondary silencer without major demolitionTo make up the remaining decibels, the team locates a straight section between the main network and the diffusers of the penthouse bedroom. Instead of tearing out the whole false ceiling, a targeted opening is carefully cut to fit a circular acoustic silencer with baffles or an acoustic absorption cartridge with low pressure loss. An airtight acoustic inspection hatch is fitted as a finish to preserve access.
- Classification of the defect and framing of the retentionIf the exceedance persists despite the remedial work, site management requires an independent joint expert assessment. Under SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations (CO), the client may issue a notice of defects and set aside retention money proportional to the cost of restoring compliance. The ventilation fitter demonstrates his tests by record in order to confine the dispute to the loss of value in use alone.
Frequently asked questions
Can the fan speed be throttled to comply with SIA 181?
Lowering the speed immediately reduces the sound power generated by the fan. However, this action must not reduce the air volumes below the regulatory hygiene thresholds provided for the apartment. The foreman checks that the residual airflow at the diffusers scrupulously complies with the contractual airflow balance. Any permanent change to the frequency drive settings requires the formal, countersigned agreement of the engineer appointed for the installation.
Where can a supplementary sound attenuator be fitted when the false ceiling is already closed?
The work is carried out as close as possible to the diffusers of the affected room. The fitter cuts a clean access opening beneath the terminal duct in order to replace a straight section with a flexible double-wall silencer or a rigid absorption silencer. The cut in the plasterboard is then closed with a sealed inspection frame fitted with an airtight gasket, ensuring the overall sound insulation of the ceiling.
How to respond to an overall financial retention following a non-compliant test?
Site management cannot block an entire invoice for a localised defect. The contractor asks for the rules of SIA 118 to be applied in order to limit the retention to the actual estimated cost of the remedial work in the penthouse. At the same time, the company promptly arranges joint acoustic measurements with a calibrated sound level meter in order to document precisely the actual impact of the corrections made to the duct network.
Can a throttling damper itself cause the acoustic exceedance found?
Yes. When a manual balancing damper located too close to a supply terminal is heavily closed to reduce an excessive airflow, it generates a very audible aeraulic whistle. To avoid this regenerated flow noise in the room, the fitter must open the terminal damper and move the pressure throttling to an upstream damper, or insert an acoustic plenum lined with mineral wool between the damper and the grille.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 181Noise protection in buildings: acoustic requirements for technical installations
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work: management of defects and retentions
- code des obligationsRules governing the works contract and the client's rights in the event of a defect in the work
