Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 244Smoke extraction and fire dampersChapter 9 of 10 in the section

Do not drill afterwards: fire-resistant duct, repair void and restoration to compliance

This chapter details the technical and administrative rules that apply when a fire-resistant duct has been altered without authorisation. You will learn to identify unlawful penetrations, to assert the loss of approval under the VKF fire protection regulations, to refuse interventions by third-party trades and to apply the restoration procedure validated by the manufacturer to ensure the installation remains compliant.

Key takeaways

  • Screwing a third-party support or clamp into a fire-resistant duct destroys its approved fire resistance.
  • Any untested penetration voids the conformity report submitted to the fire protection authorities.
  • The ventilation contractor must formally refuse any foreign fixing on its smoke extraction systems.
  • Restoration requires strict application of the approved manufacturer's protocol and a recorded inspection report.

Damage to the integrity of the fire-resistant duct and its regulatory consequences

On Swiss construction sites, smoke extraction ducts and fire-resistant ventilation ducts must meet strict requirements set by the VKF fire protection regulations. Whether they are self-supporting ducts made of calcium silicate boards or sheet steel ducts protected by a specific insulating casing, the work is a complete system tested in a laboratory. Any penetration made afterwards, even with a simple self-drilling screw intended to fix a cable tray or a plumbing clamp, creates a thermal bridge and mechanically weakens the wall. Hot gases and toxic smoke can then enter or escape through the opening created.

Consequences of unauthorised interventions on fire-resistant ducts
Intervention observedImpact on the fire-resistant systemConsequence for VKF compliance
Fitting of a pipe clamp with a self-tapping screwCreation of a thermal bridge and perforation of the insulating coreLoss of validity of the installation report and refusal of acceptance
Penetration for the passage of an electrical cable through the ductBreach of smoke tightness and structural weakeningMajor non-conformity requiring complete rework of the section
Direct fixing of a support rail without a resilient stripTransfer of uncalculated mechanical forces in the event of expansionCancellation of the overall approval of the tested system

As soon as a covert or uncoordinated fixing is installed, the declaration of conformity issued by the ventilation installer becomes void. The installation report submitted to the fire protection quality assurance manager or the cantonal authority covers only configurations strictly identical to the VKF approval certificate. The ventilation system contractor cannot take responsibility for a duct altered by a third party. The whole section concerned loses its fire resistance classification, which suspends the issue of the occupancy permit or the building's certificate of conformity.

Inspection on site, refusal to take over and compliance restoration protocol

Faced with a perforated duct, the ventilation site foreman must formalise a refusal without delay. Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, if a circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, failing which it bears the consequences. The record must include clear photographs, the exact location on the ventilation coordination plans and the identification of the responsible company. No makeshift tolerance applies: applying standard silicone sealant or aluminium adhesive tape to plug a perforation in a fire-resistant duct is strictly prohibited by the VKF fire protection regulations.

In the case of a mechanical smoke extraction duct, the constraints are even stricter than for comfort ventilation. The system operates under significant negative or positive pressure when evacuating high-temperature smoke. A screw protruding inside the duct disturbs the airflow, encourages soot to build up and risks causing a tear under extreme thermal stresses. In addition, the vibrations generated by the extraction fans can loosen an improvised fixing and create a major leak along the evacuation path.

  1. Notification and recording of the damageIssue a written notice to the contracted designer and to site management reporting the perforation of the duct, with its location on the ventilation plan and dated photographs.
  2. Consulting the manufacturer's installation manualConsult the manufacturer of the approved fire-resistant system to obtain the official repair method authorised by its VKF test report.
  3. Preparing and cutting out the damaged areaCarefully clear the perimeter of the hole without cracking the surrounding boards or detaching the adjacent insulation mats, following the template prescribed by the manufacturer.
  4. Fitting the certified repair pieceInstall a cover piece of the same original material, fixed with approved fire-resistant bonding and specific fasteners according to the required approval thickness.
  5. Drawing up the addendum to the reportDraw up a documented repair sheet, including the references of the products used, countersigned by the project's fire protection quality assurance manager.

Common alterations by secondary trades and grounds for refusal

On ventilation and smoke extraction installation sites, sharing technical shafts and false ceilings generates recurring layout conflicts. It is common for an electrician to fix a cable tray with self-tapping screws directly into the wall of a horizontal smoke extraction duct, or for a plumber to anchor a hanger clamp for a drainage pipe to a calcium silicate fire-resistant duct. Although other trades may regard these isolated interventions as minor, they are destructive mechanical damage to the safety function of the air distribution system.

The VKF fire protection regulations require smoke extraction ducts and fire-resistant ventilation ducts to keep their smoke tightness and thermal insulation throughout the required classification period, for example EI 30, EI 60 or EI 90. When a screw passes through the thickness of the approved material, it creates a direct metal thermal bridge that transfers heat to the outer wall in the event of an internal fire, or to the airflow in the event of an external fire. Moreover, under the effect of thermal expansion and the extreme temperature gradients generated in a fire, the metal of the screw expands faster than the mineral matrix of the duct, causing localised spalling, through-cracking and loss of containment of hot gases.

Types of unauthorised penetrations and impacts on the validity of the work
Nature of the intervention observedPhysical consequence for the ductImpact on the VKF certificateDecision of the ventilation contractor
Self-drilling screw for an electrical conduit clampCreation of a local thermal bridge and breach of hot-gas tightnessImmediate loss of validity of the approval reportFormal refusal to certify the work, notice of damage to the contracted designer
Plastic or metal plug for plumbing suspensionStructural weakening under mechanical stress, risk of failure at 600 °CLoss of mechanical strength and of the fire stability classStop work on the section, demand that the responsible party carry out the repair
Circular penetration for the passage of a vent pipeTearing of the section and free passage for carbon monoxide and flamesComplete cancellation of the conformity of the fire compartmentComplete removal of the section or an approved connecting sleeve
Pop rivet fixed to hold a retaining strapCracking of the calcium silicate board and loosening under negative pressureNon-compliance with the manufacturer's installation requirementsRefusal to sign the certificate of conformity for the fire protection authority

The prohibition on penetrating an approved duct is absolute: no element foreign to the air distribution system may use the duct casing as a load-bearing support, or pass through its walls without a sealing or bypass device provided for and tested in the initial tests. As soon as a parasitic fixing is spotted, the ventilation system contractor incurs liability if it agrees to sign the VKF declaration of conformity. The whole section concerned immediately loses its status as certified fire-resistant work, obliging the ventilation company to refuse acceptance until the situation is regularised.

Compliant restoration protocol and documentary reinstatement

Restoring a fire-resistant duct must never be a makeshift job with generic products found on site. The use of universal silicone sealants, filling plaster or expanding polyurethane foams, even if tinted pink, is prohibited. Under the VKF fire protection regulations, any repair must strictly restore the original fire resistance performance by a documented method certified as compliant with the technical data of the approval holder.

  1. Removal of third-party elements and joint inspection recordHave the responsible company remove all fixings, clamps and cabling installed on the duct. Draw up a joint inspection record with site management, with numbered photographs locating each point of impact.
  2. Consulting the VKF approval holderSend the non-conformity sheet to the manufacturer of the fire-resistant elements (silicate boards, vitrified metal ducts or staff). Only the manufacturer can determine whether the penetration falls within a repair authorised by its test report or requires complete replacement of the board.
  3. Applying the system repair protocolFor small-diameter penetrations that are admissible, insert the original intumescent paste or the recommended fire-resistant grout, then fit a cover piece of identical material and equal thickness, fixed with the screws and adhesives provided for in the approval certificate, observing the prescribed minimum overlaps.
  4. Updating the safety file and signing the conformity certificateInclude the repair report, the technical data sheets of the repair components and the photos of the steps in the as-built file. Once these supporting documents have been validated, the ventilation technical manager can issue the certificate of conformity of execution required for final acceptance of the installation.

Where the penetration has broken up the core of an insulating board or irreversibly deformed the duct, complete replacement of the section between two expansion joints or assembly flanges remains the only acceptable technical solution. This requirement ensures compliance with the installation standard and preserves the legal value of the test report for the smoke extraction system.

Handling a construction site blockage and repair under VKF control

The discovery of an unauthorised penetration in a fire-resistant duct immediately paralyses the acceptance process for the air distribution installation. When a plumber, an electrician or a false-ceiling installer drives a screw or plug into an approved duct, the entire conformity report becomes void. The cantonal or municipal fire protection authority refuses the occupancy permit until the integrity of the compartmentation has been restored in accordance with the VKF fire protection regulations.

Faced with this type of damage, the ventilation site foreman applies a strict technical and administrative reinstatement procedure:

  1. Joint inspection record and formal noticeNotify the defect without delay to site management and to the fire safety coordination manager. Attach time-stamped photographs showing the spacing of the penetrations, the thickness of the damaged material and the precise location of the damaged section.
  2. Consulting the approval holderSend the survey to the manufacturer of the duct or fire-resistant board. Only the holder of the VKF recognition is authorised to prescribe a certified repair protocol or to require the outright removal of the damaged section.
  3. Carrying out the restoration to complianceReplace the complete element or apply the official repair kit prescribed by the manufacturer, including the specific intumescent sealants, the original screws and the approved fire-resistant joint covers.
  4. Updating the documents and new certificateDraw up the technical intervention report, record the supplier's written validation and issue the new ventilation certificate of conformity submitted to the cantonal fire protection authorities.

The costs of removal, rebuilding the system and revising the reports are charged in full to the company responsible for the damage, on the basis of the rules of the SIA 118 standard governing coordination defects between finishing work trades.

Frequently asked questions

Can a self-drilling screw hole be filled with ordinary fire-resistant silicone sealant?

No. Spot sealing with fire sealant does not restore the mechanical strength or the hot-gas tightness required by the VKF fire protection regulations. Any modification of the duct voids the Swiss technical recognition. Only a cover piece complying with the system manufacturer's installation manual, fixed with the adhesives and screws provided for in the test report, allows the repair to be validated before the cantonal fire protection authority.

What does the ventilation company risk if it signs the final certificate despite a penetration?

The installer or company manager incurs full civil and technical liability. In the event of a fire, the insurer and the courts will hold that the VKF fire protection regulations and the recognised rules of building practice were not observed. The certificate of conformity certifies that the work was carried out in accordance with the approved plans; any courtesy signature conceals a major defect and shifts the burden of the damage onto the ventilation installer.

How can we prove that a duct was perforated after our own installation?

The project manager must draw up an internal installation report with dated photographs as soon as the sections and dampers are installed. When the damage is discovered, he records a joint inspection record with site management and the company at fault. This document, supplemented by the delivery notes and the daywork reports in accordance with the SIA 118 standard, proves that the work was sound before being damaged by the third party.

Does a manufacturer allow partial replacement of a perforated silicate board?

Some approved manufacturers provide repair instructions for small openings. The protocol generally requires a backing board of the same material, overlapping the penetration by a defined minimum amount, bonded with a high-temperature binder and screwed according to a precise pattern. If the damage exceeds the supplier's tolerances, removal and complete replacement of the duct section remain mandatory.

Texts and standards cited

  • Directives protection incendie AEAISwiss fire protection requirements for smoke extraction ducts, fire-resistant compartmentation and certificates of conformity
  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, handling of notices of defects and coordination between trades

In the same section