Key takeaways
- The cantons apply the MoPEC, which requires a minimum heat recovery on the extract air.
- The gross catalogue efficiency must be corrected for the actual air flow and condensate.
- The specific electrical power of the fan depends directly on the pressure losses of the network as built.
- The final file requires the energy compliance form, completed with the actual air-flow measurement records.
Gap between the manufacturer's data sheet and the cantonal energy compliance form
When ordering a supply-and-extract air-handling unit, the selection sheet generally shows a high thermal efficiency, often above 80 %. This commercial value almost always corresponds to laboratory-optimised operation, based on favourable fresh-air and extract-air temperatures, taking into account the latent heat gain from moisture condensation. However, the Model Energy Regulations of the Cantons (MoPEC) and the cantonal energy regulations require strict proof: the heat recovery rate must meet the minimum thresholds on the basis of standardised calculation conditions, generally calculated at the winter design point in pure sensible heat.
- Heat recovery rate (thermal efficiency)
- Ratio between the temperature rise of the fresh air through the exchanger and the maximum temperature difference between the extract air and the outdoor air, measured at balanced mass flow rates without moisture input.
The installer must require from the supplier the exact calculation sheet for the actual project air flows. A counter-flow plate recovery unit or an enthalpy wheel does not react in the same way if the supply air flow is higher than the extract air flow. As soon as the flow ratio departs from unity, the efficiency drops. In the French-speaking cantons, the official energy compliance form for ventilation and air-conditioning installations requires the dry thermal efficiency at nominal air flow. If the building permit application was filed with an overstated theoretical value, the delivered unit may fail the compliance check without a costly change to the rotation speed or the fin spacing.
| Data source | Condensation taken into account | Validity for cantonal form | Consequence on the construction site |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commercial catalogue | Often included (wet efficiency) | Rejected without detailed calculation | Risk of thermal undersizing |
| Software selection sheet | Separable (sensible / latent heat) | Compliant if calculated in dry mode | Document required for technical validation |
| Measurement on the installation | Varies with the humidity of the day | Acceptance check on site | Requires simultaneous temperature measurement |
Specific electrical power and compliance of acceptance measurements
The other central part of the cantonal energy requirements concerns the specific electrical power absorbed by the fans, often referred to by the acronym SFP. The MoPEC sets power ceilings per cubic metre of air moved, in order to prevent the installation of undersized fans running at excessive speeds on networks that are too narrow. The power taken into account is not the nominal motor power engraved on the rating plate, but the electrical power actually drawn at the terminals of the frequency converter or the electronically commutated motor at the nominal set point.
On the construction site, the specific power depends directly on how the air network was installed. Unplanned sharp-angle bends, sudden reductions to avoid a sanitary pipe, or filters clogged from the structural work phase increase the overall static pressure. To overcome these unforeseen pressure losses, the motor has to run faster, which makes the absorbed electrical power jump above the threshold declared in the initial compliance form. The team leader must ensure that the duct routes are respected and that the casings are kept clean throughout the works.
- Static pressure readingsMeasure the differential pressure across each component of the unit (new filters, coil, recovery unit) with a calibrated differential pressure gauge to validate the internal pressure losses.
- Balancing of set-point flowsAdjust the dampers and the fan speed using an anemometer or a measuring hood to reach the exact fresh-air and exhaust-air flows stated in the project.
- Measurement of absorbed powerRecord the actual active power absorbed with a wattmeter upstream of the control electronics while the machine runs at a stable nominal flow.
- Drawing up the balancing reportRecord the flows, the temperatures upstream and downstream of the exchanger and the electrical powers in the official protocol attached to the as-built file for the cantonal authority.
Preparing form EN-3 and compliance under the MoPEC
The building permit application file requires the submission of a specific cantonal form for air-handling installations, generally indexed as the EN-3 compliance form in the French-speaking cantons applying the Model Energy Regulations of the Cantons (MoPEC). The ventilation installer or the appointed design office cannot simply insert a commercial brochure from the air-handling unit manufacturer. The official document requires the precise inclusion of the local calculation conditions and the nominal operating air flows.
- Form EN-3 (Ventilation / air-conditioning compliance form)
- Technical administrative document prescribed by the cantonal energy departments. It compiles the supply and extract air flows, the type of heat recovery unit, the minimum required thermal efficiency, and the specific electrical power absorbed by the fans under nominal project conditions.
The MoPEC requirements set a strict framework: any unit handling fresh air and discharging extract air above a regulatory volume threshold must incorporate a high-efficiency heat recovery system. For a compliance form to be validated by the municipal or cantonal authority, the calculation of the recovery rate must not rely on idealised theoretical temperatures, but on a strict mass balance between the extract air and the fresh air admitted, taking into account the behaviour in case of risk of frosting in winter.
| Technical data | Catalogue sheet value | EN-3 form requirement | Consequence on compliance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gross thermal efficiency | Up to 85 % dry | Calculation under standardised test conditions | Risk of rejection if the condensation and mass flow correction is not included. |
| Reference air flow | Manufacturer's standard volume | Building's hygienic design air flow | The face velocity in the exchanger changes the actual efficiency and the pressure loss. |
| Fan-motor absorbed power | Nominal motor power | Specific electrical power (SFP) | Failure to comply with the consumption ceiling for auxiliaries blocks the compliance of the building. |
| Frost protection | Not taken into account by default | Inclusion of preheating or bypass damper | The resulting seasonal drop in efficiency must be declared in the overall balance. |
Acceptance measurements on site and final approval loop
The occupancy permit or the final release of energy compliance does not rest solely on the theoretical sheets submitted with the permit application. The project manager and the inspection services require a balancing and air-handling acceptance protocol, drawn up before the final handover of the ventilation installation. This protocol validates that the performances measured in situ correspond to the data entered in the initial compliance form.
- Pressure readings and air-flow adjustmentMeasurement of the differential pressures across the filter casings, coils and recovery unit using a calibrated differential pressure gauge. Adjustment of the main dampers and setting of the speed of the electronically commutated (EC) fans.
- Measurement of actual air flowsCheck of the total air flow by hot-wire anemometry or Pitot tube on a standardised straight section (according to the section method) to confirm that the fresh-air volume corresponds exactly to the exhaust-air flow stated in the file.
- Verification of exchange temperaturesInstallation of calibrated probes on the four air streams: outdoor air (taken upstream of the machine), supply air (after the recovery unit), extract air (from the rooms) and exhaust air. Calculation of the net thermal efficiency in stable operation.
- Measurement of absorbed powerElectrical measurement of the actual consumption of the supply fan and the extract fan at the frequency converter or the terminal block of the machine, calculation of the specific electrical power per cubic metre per hour moved and comparison with the permissible limits.
If the efficiency calculated on site is degraded by heat losses in the fresh-air intake or exhaust ducts located in an unheated plant room, the energy compliance form is compromised. The ventilation company therefore ensures that the thermal insulation of the external connecting ducts strictly meets the required insulation thicknesses, in order to avoid any parasitic temperature drop before entering the exchanger.
Non-compliance at energy acceptance: diagnosis and remedies
When the acceptance measurements contradict the cantonal energy form, the ventilation fitter is on the front line. An exceedance of the specific electrical power or a heat recovery rate below the MoPEC requirements blocks the issue of the occupancy or operating permit. Before blaming the air-handling unit, the foreman methodically checks the air network: a balancing damper throttled too far to compensate for poor distribution creates a parasitic pressure loss that pushes the fan-motor consumption above the target value.
- Checking static pressures at the flangesMeasure the exact differential pressure across the unit with a calibrated gauge. If the external pressure exceeds the assumptions of the energy compliance form, the downstream network presents an abnormal resistance that shifts the operating point.
- Checking balancing and pressure lossesOpen the terminal dampers fully and favour control by frequency variation on the EC motors. Replace the saturated construction-site filters that increase the absorbed power during the official measurements.
- Measurement of exchange temperatures and flowsRecord the temperatures at the four probes of the plate exchanger or the wheel. A poorly controlled bypass or an internal air leak distorts the calculation of the actual thermal efficiency.
If the network complies with the execution drawings but the delivered machine does not deliver the certified performances, responsibility shifts to the equipment supplier. Art. 365 para. 3 CO requires the contractor to inform the client when a circumstance jeopardises the proper execution of the works. In practice, the notice is sent in writing as soon as the first series of non-compliant measurements is obtained, together with the calibration report of the anemometers and wattmeters.
In the event of a proven defect in the installation with regard to the cantonal requirements, art. 368 CO governs the client's rights regarding the rectification of the work. The installer proposes targeted corrective measures: overhaul of the blade profiles, replacement of the fan-motor with a high-efficiency stage or resizing of a critical duct section to lower the air velocities.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the thermal efficiency measured in winter often lower than the catalogue value?
Catalogue data frequently show a dry sensible efficiency calculated under laboratory test conditions. On site, the presence of condensation, partial frosting of the exchanger and defrost cycles reduce the active exchange surface. In addition, an air-flow imbalance between the fresh-air flow and the extract-air flow directly changes the ratio of the thermal capacities, degrading the final value of the measured efficiency.
How should you react if the specific electrical power exceeds the limit value set by the MoPEC?
First check the clogging of the filters and reduce the network pressure losses by reopening the main throttling dampers. A methodical re-balancing branch by branch makes it possible to reduce the fan rotation speed. If the theoretical operating point remains outside tolerance, the installer checks the pressure control settings and reports the deviation to the appointed engineering office.
Does a change in duct routing during the works require the energy compliance form to be recalculated?
Yes, if the change causes a significant increase in linear or local pressure losses, for example through the addition of unplanned 90-degree bends. This additional resistance forces the fan to run faster, increasing the absorbed electrical power. The company must report this variation in order to avoid rejection of the revised form at the final compliance check by the cantonal department.
What should you do if the cantonal authority rejects the EN-3 energy compliance form at acceptance?
The company analyses the rejected points, generally a specific power that is too high or an uncertified exchanger. An adversarial air-handling audit is carried out to identify the origin of the exceedance: component defect, network that is too resistant, or overstated flows. The installer applies the technical corrections, draws up a new measurement protocol complying with the recognised rules and sends the corrected file to the site management.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 365material and ground: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the material he supplies; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by him is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, he must inform the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3).
- CO art. 368client's rights in the event of defects in the work: refusal, price reduction, rectification, damages; any clause agreed in advance that restricts or excludes the right to have defects remedied is void if the defect concerns a building (para. 2bis, since 1 January 2026).
